Revenge15 min read
When the Little Yellow Cat Stayed: A Story About Scars, Lies, and Public Truth
ButterPicks11 views
I remember the phone ringing like a small bell in a flooded room.
"Pick it up," someone behind me hissed, and hands closed on my shirt as if I were already their property.
"Don't make it complicated," a voice said, casual and small-talky. "Just teach her a lesson."
"Yeah," another voice laughed. "Don't let it get messy."
I pressed my palms to my mouth because a laugh bubbled up and tasted like bile. They tugged, pushed, struck. The stars behind my eyelids were not beautiful; they were children of light that blinked and died.
"Ow—" I whispered.
"Look at her. Gross," a flattened voice said. "So dirty."
Someone pried open the packet I'd carried like a secret. White pads fluttered like fallen snow over my knees.
"Is that—" another voice sneered. "Is that her 'time'? How can she go out like this?"
My breath hitched. My hands moved before I could stop them, pressing into the floor, gathering something like pride in the palm of my hand that kept slipping away. Then a figure detached itself from the darker shapes: his profile cold and habitual, the kind of face that looks better in photos.
He was pretty, and pretty people always looked like they were made in better light.
"She's ugly," the monkey-faced one said, pinching my cheek. Someone called out a name.
"Dalton, come see. She looks like SpongeBob."
Dalton Ewing glanced, then looked away like a neutral god who had better things to do. He flicked at his phone, his expression bored.
"She's not worth our time," he murmured, and they let me have whatever they wanted.
The next day I opened the message I'd sent him earlier. It was a stupid, hopeful thing—an attempt at something that was only mine: a picture taken for his eyes, the collarbone and a V-neck and a bruise displayed like proof I'd risked myself for an audience. A voice note came back—the voice I had believed for months.
"Sis," he said, the way he always did. "What a surprise. I have things tonight. Good night."
The voice, small and careful, had saved me once. In the dark it had been an island I swam toward. In the alley it was the sound the men ignored.
"Please, leave me alone," I had mouthed the first night they left. He watched. He didn't move a muscle beyond the phone in his hand.
I learned a name for my shame. I learned a shape for my fear. I learned later that people who are cruel seldom feel centuries of consequence the way their victims do; they feel a second's horned pleasure and fold the rest away.
I moved cities. I used the small nest egg my mother had left me and the name on an acceptance letter to buy a ticket, a ticket for a new face.
They told me I had decent bones. The surgeon wrapped my face; I woke seeing stranger features in the mirror. It hurt. The price was larger than money; it was the knowledge that in wanting to not be me, I was paying with my history.
Rowan Fisher opened his apartment door as if he had been expecting a storm and found a smaller rain waiting. He looked at the bruises and said, "Surgery?"
"Yes." I forced my voice into a calmness I didn't feel. "I wanted it."
"You look tired," he said, and carried my bags up like an old-timey friend. He showed me the corner where he kept an orange cat.
"This is Little Yellow," he said. "He is heavy when he sits."
He made me tea. He offered me space and decorum and tiny acts of human decency that were not dramatic. He was the first person to treat my scars as something of value rather than as a joke. That made all the difference.
"He will like you," Rowan said once. Little Yellow purred and rolled onto his back like a lazy sun.
I made a little life out of thrifted blouses and cheap-camera pictures. I learned how to angle, how to crop out the old jawline from old photos, how to be the version of me that wouldn't draw the kind of attention that came with violence.
Dalton messaged me like clockwork. He was tender, devoutly small-voiced, someone who said the things I wanted to hear—soft, flaky texts that fit neatly on ordinary nights. "I miss you," he would say. "You are so pretty." He called me "Sis" in a way that suggested safety and possession at once.
Rowan watched me from the kitchen doorway, patient like a lighthouse. "Is he... real?" he asked once, and I lied and said, "Yes."
We all tell the half-truths that keep us breathing.
Gabrielle Jonsson became my real friend. She was open, practical, a laugh that would not be barked away. She found me on a day when I had barely the courage to change my clothes for the first class of the semester. "I'm Gabrielle," she said, between bites of a candy bar. "You okay? Want to sit with us?"
"Yes," I said, and her smile had punctuation. It tied my sentences into meaning.
Things seemed to smooth. I learned to take compliments. I learned to cook soft noodles and share them without flinching. Rowan's apartment had a hand-printed house rule that read: "No late nights. No strangers in the hallway. No hiding who you are." He had drawn his handprint in ink and stamped it on the corner, as if his palm could physically assert limits.
"Stubborn," he muttered when I teased him about it. "Necessary."
When Dalton finally asked to meet, I agreed. It was easier to hold a string than to let the world untether me. We met at a campus café where sunlight pooled in the chairs and made dust motes look holy. He stood; he was more fragile in the roundness that flesh makes. He was pretty the way porcelain is pretty. People noticed us. I noticed his friends in a way I had tried to bury: one of them seemed familiar. Too familiar.
When a group of men I once knew cheered his name, my stomach dropped. Among them were faces I had frozen to keep. And then there came the recognition that split me open. The memory of an alley flashing like a wound.
"Hey, it's her," someone said, and I felt like glass. I felt like I could break.
"Sit," Dalton insisted quickly, protective in a way that was performative. "They're old friends. They shouldn't—"
He had, though. He had watched when I was a heap of shame on the pavement. He had been the phone I thought was a friend.
"Why didn't you stop them?" I asked much later, when we were alone and the words could fall like knives.
He blinked like he had blank spots in the map of his life. "I... I didn't see—"
"You were there."
"I was with them after."
That evening he deleted numbers. He said, "I won't go back," like a little saint freshly repentant. I nodded, because his apologies fit my plan. His contrition became keys to a house I thought would open happiness.
At first he was protective and soft. He bought a camera and paid for a beginner's class so I could take better photos. He took me to places and spoke about small futures like a child drafting an imaginary city. He liked showing me to people. It made him glow.
"I like showing you," he said once. "You're mine."
Those words tasted of ownership. I let him have them, because ownership felt like warmth.
Then the internet found my old bruises, old photos, the labels the young had stuck onto me. Someone posted the alley photo. Comments swelled; the world is a place where people click "share" and make a history for you they prefer—unedited, cruel, public.
Angelina Cox, a campus influencer I had vaguely met in class, watched the traffic swell and leaned into it. She had a platform, and her followers loved the easy cruelty of piling on someone down. She made a montage and wrote mocking captions. People who'd seen my face at school remembered their mischief and added new layers. "Why are you acting like a victim?" they wrote. "She deserved it for stealing attention." They reposted the SpongeBob nickname. They made memes about a pad tucked into a skirt. The sexual shame poured into comments as casually as the rain pours into gutters.
The humiliation spiked and then roared. I sat in Rowan's lit kitchen and let his hand warm my back while the messages flashed on the phone. "What do you want me to do?" he asked, voice small.
"Tell the truth," I said. "If someone speaks, maybe others will hear."
So I started to speak. I opened accounts and channels to gather the stories of others. I learned from people who had been scarred that public truth takes on a weight that private whispers cannot. The moment you put language to pain, you become an object of both sympathy and criticism. You become a thing to debate.
There was a day the online tide turned.
A student journalist reached out. A law clinic offered help. Volunteers messaged. The small constellations of truth we were forming began to glow. When a major talk show invited me to speak—"We want the survivor's voice"—I took Rowan's hand backstage and went onstage under a light that felt like a real interrogator.
"This is my story," I told strangers and cameras. "My real name is Lydia Courtney. I was bullied. I was beaten. I was called names. I was shoved into alleys. I was told that I belonged to people's jokes."
"Why didn't you fight back?" the host asked brusquely.
"Because sometimes fighting back doesn't stop hands from joining you," I answered. "Because teachers saw nothing. Because names became permission."
"Don't you want apologies?" the host asked, keen with the taste of a headline.
"Yes. But apologies won't make the bruises go away." My voice steadied. "I want them to know that other people like me don't have to die quietly."
After that broadcast, things that had been tidy in the other side of town became ragged and unraveling. The university could no longer pretend ignorance. A reporter traced the alley photo to a campus phone, and the phone led to names I recognized. People wanted a scapegoat, and the net found one: Frida Conway, a girl whose father had influence; Angelina Cox, the influencer; and the men who'd been there the night I was beaten. The university opened inquiries.
Public punishment doesn't have to be theatrical to hurt; it can be the slow collapse of props. But our story needed something public, raw, a scene where the pelting light could illuminate the faces that had once watched me on the ground.
We planned a hearing. Not a court, but a campus assembly with reporters, students, parents, and a live stream. I sat on a folding chair in the front row, hands folded the way my mother used to fold washcloths. My lawyer sat beside me—she had her own history of being a target and knew how to aim words.
"She looked at me like I was a joke," a voice started over the speakers. "Like a thing to play with."
"That was me," I said, rising slowly. "My name is Lydia Courtney."
"You're sure it will be okay?" Rowan whispered behind me.
"It won't be 'okay,'" I said. "But it will be seen."
The room was packed. Cameras bobbed heads. The dean sat behind a table with a university crest that seemed to watch the proceedings like an animal. Frida Conway and Angelina Cox took seats at the other side, flanked by polished parents, a quiet lawyer, and a cluster of friends who looked like they had not yet been told the rules had changed.
"You hurt me on a night where I had no defense," I said into the microphone. "You shared my wounds like trophies. You made jokes about my body, about what happens to girls when they bleed. You laughed while people stepped on me. You took pictures."
Angelina shifted. Her makeup was perfect. "We were young," she said. "We didn't think of it as—"
"You drew a picture of someone else's pain," my lawyer cut in, steady and white-knuckled. "You broadcast it. You used your platform to humiliate a survivor. That isn't a mistake; it's a choice."
Frida's smile had frozen. The first change was the way the room stopped laughing at the wrong crowd. People who had previously chuckled at me now tried to look neutral. Students who had been petty mercenaries stood beside their phones like apologists.
"You will both be suspended pending further review," the dean said, voice invisible and official. "The evidence is substantial, including personal testimonies and photos. The university will cooperate with authorities."
Frida's face went through phases. First, shock like someone who'd misread a menu. Then denial, a flash of anger. "You can't do this," she hissed. "We were just kids."
"Being young doesn't absolve you," I replied. "If you can't see that, then you are choosing not to grow."
Outside the assembly room the press swarmed. Students who had once been quiet now wanted to speak. "I was there," one boy admitted to a camera, voice shaking. "I laughed. I didn't stop it." His eyes lowered.
The scene stretched over hours—interviews, cameras, the hum of people saying the exact phrase "I didn't realize." The backlash arrived like a weather system: Frida's father, a civic official, had his desk raided after an investigative piece turned up unrelated misconduct; political consequences flew like birds from a broken nest. Angelina's channels filled with angry messages and demands for accountability; sponsors paused their contracts and the comment sections, once playgrounds, became sites of moral verdicts.
But there was one punishment that unfolded slowly, painfully public, and terribly specific for Dalton.
He had thought his private contrition would remain private. He had imagined our small boat intact, and that the rest of the world could not enter. He had been wrong in all the ways a person can be wrong.
There was a panel discussion at a student union where several survivors gathered. Dalton agreed—naively, surely—to come and bear witness. "I want to say I'm sorry," he told me days before, eyes small and catlike. "I'll say it where it matters."
I had wanted to vomit when he used the phrase "where it matters," because nothing mattered more to me than the place where I had been kicked, and he had watched.
"Do you remember the night in the alley?" my lawyer asked him publicly.
Dalton swallowed. "I... was with friends. I was... I thought we were just talking. I didn't—"
"You heard them call her names," the lawyer said. "You heard them mock a girl's menstruation. You were on your phone. You looked at pictures you had already stored of females and made jokes. You didn't move away; you stayed."
There was a whisper like dry grass in a wind. His face went from smooth concern to a face with edges. He tried to shape himself into regret, to a human who had learned. But the room noticed his timeline: deleted contacts, messages that admitted jealousy, a string of gifts after I'd told him about my past that read like bribery.
"Did you intend to hurt her, Dalton?" someone asked—a reporter with the voice of a child.
"I didn't intend to—" he started.
"Then why didn't you stop it?" a pastor in the audience said quietly. "Why did you treat another human's pain like another prop?"
He faltered. The live stream captured the crack. It captured how a man who'd once been a convenient shoulder became a fragile figure with nowhere to hide. His mother called from the audience, whispering a plea. "Please" she mouthed. Her lips did a useless prayer.
He stood and tried to speak to me like a lover making amends. "Lydia, I'm sorry. I love you. Let me fix it—"
"Love me?" I repeated. My voice did not shake. "Do you know what you loved? You loved an image that didn't fight back. You loved a voice note. You loved the idea of possession. Do you remember watching me on the pavement and doing nothing?"
He looked like somebody who had looked into a mirror and seen a stranger. His jaw worked. "I... I was scared," he said.
"There's nothing brave in not saving people," I said. "It's cowardice dressed as fear."
That was the public part. The rest of his punishment spread: his friends withdrew like teeth from a mouth. They realized they had aligned themselves with a man who had not only been passive but had benefited. His own social circle did not wrap around him; it receded. He was cut loose digitally—messages left unread, dinners canceled, a video of him at our university's cafe found its way to a forum where students discussed accountability. His employers—tiny art studios and commissions he had hoped would make his name—backed away after the press called. Dalton's mother released a statement asking for privacy, but the world had already decided that privacy belonged to those who had done nothing wrong.
People who had once laughed at me were now the target of shame. "Why?" Dalton asked one night when he came to our door and banged on it like a child who had lost directions. "Why are they doing this to me? I didn't—"
"You didn't do enough," I said. "And you never did. You chose people who took pleasure in harm. You made them feel safe. That is why."
He sat at the steps and broke in the shape of a human sob. Students who had once admired him filmed him, but this time the audience's mood was different. They called out the things he had not done. Someone handed me a phone with a live feed of him apologizing to cameras and getting interrupted by people who'd been hurt worse. He shifted between voices in a shame chorus: abject, pleading, incredulous. He tried to pull a circle of pity around himself. The circle closed on him.
The public humiliation was not a single theatrical moment with a spotlight; it was a long, merciless falling away—friends gone, commissions lost, messages deleted, and the haunting of seeing your own face on screens while strangers debated whether you were redeemable.
Frida's punishment was different. She faced suspension, lost her father's backing, and had to explain herself to an investigative committee. Angelina had to post a streamed apology and subsequently lost major sponsorships. The men who had been present—petty and loud—faced disciplinary actions, community service, and the slow burn of social exile.
"The thing about cruelty," Rowan said to me late one night, Little Yellow sleeping like a warm stone on his lap, "is that it wants company. When company withdraws, cruelty gets lonely."
I thought then of the small things that saved me: Rowan ladling soup when I couldn't swallow my own shame; Gabrielle laughing at a stupid joke to let me breathe; the cat's warm weight; the house rule with the inked palm. Those were my scaffolding.
I didn't want vengeance for vengeance's sake. I wanted the records corrected. I wanted the children who had once found laughter in brutality to see that such laughter ages badly.
"You shouldn't have had to—" Rowan said once, in that way he had where the sentence never finished because the weight proved too much.
But I did. I had to. Because the scar that had been my name could no longer be the city's joke. Because other girls started writing into the account I had made, their words sounding like metal against the same wound.
When the worst of it settled, life took on a new kind of texture. I founded an organization that helped victims document abuse and navigate the system that had often failed us. I worked with lawyers who had the patience for paperwork. I spoke in rooms where microphones didn't feel like judgment but like scales.
Rowan and I moved slowly. He gave me a handprint on the wall not because he wanted to judge me but because he wanted a place to say, "I will stay." We married in a soft September that smelled like dry leaves and fabric softener. Little Yellow was the ringbearer in a way; he stepped on the aisle and refused to move. The man who had once pretended to be my refuge, Dalton, showed up at a press stand months later and watched me sign forms that created safe spaces for other girls. He waited by the edge of a reporter's table and tried to ask questions in a voice that had become thin. "Will you ever forgive me?" he asked me once.
"Forgiveness is—" I began.
"Is what?" he pushed.
"Is not for you to demand," I said. "It's something given to heal a wound. Right now, I am using my time to heal others."
He breathed like a man learning a new alphabet.
People still tried to name me by their old jokes. The internet occasionally flashed my younger photo and someone would snicker in the back canal of comments. Sometimes it stung, like a lamp that flickers when you least expect it. But my life had a spine now.
One afternoon at a panel, a girl raised her hand and said, "How did you stop hating?"
I looked at her. Her eyes were small and honest. "I didn't," I said. "I changed it. I moved hate into fuel. Hate taught me where the doors were. Then I opened those doors and let people out."
There were times my chest still clenched. There were nights I woke to the taste of salt. But those nights were shorter and fewer.
In the end, the punishment scenes were visible because I insisted they be. I insisted that the cruelty which once hid behind jokes be exposed under the same light that once gave the bullies their courage. I insisted that a man who had watched me be treated like a prop be seen in the shrinking of his social sphere: venues canceled, friends removed, opportunities halted, the humiliation of being called out in front of people who once had complimented him and now watched him unravel. That was not to celebrate the seeing of a person falter; it was to show that actions had consequences.
On our bedroom wall, next to Rowan's handprint and a taped polaroid of Little Yellow asleep on my lap, I keep a small, battered camera—an old gift from someone whose love had been counterfeit. I don't throw it away. Sometimes I take it out and look at it, remembering that even a tiny object that was once a bribe became a tool. I use cameras now to record, to document, to help others summon truth.
"Do you regret all of it?" Gabrielle asked me one evening as we ate noodles in Rowan's kitchen.
"Regret?" I frowned. "I regret the pain more than the choices I made after it. Those choices made me a person who could stand and speak."
Little Yellow bumped my ankle with his head and meowed, and the small sound felt like a proof.
When people ask me the final thing, the thing that only belongs to my story, I point to the house rule with Rowan's inked handprint and the camera on the shelf. "I keep both," I say. "One is a promise to stay away from harm for those I love. The other is a promise to record truth for those who cannot yet speak."
"Will you ever change your name again?" someone joked once, cruel but curious.
"No," I said, and smiled. "Lydia Courtney is mine. It holds my scars and my new lines. It holds the night I went down and the morning I stood up."
The last time Dalton tried to speak to me in public, a dozen women who had written to my organization were in the room. They answered him with the weight of their lives—stories that didn't end in sound bites. He watched them like a man watching rain find its level.
I closed my eyes for a second and remembered the first time I had opened a phone and found a voice that sounded like shelter. I also remembered the night he watched me on the pavement and did nothing. That memory had been a stone; using it had built a path.
"Why the cat?" a reporter asked me at a ribbon-cutting for a shelter my organization opened.
"Because sometimes the smallest warmth saves you," I said. "Little Yellow saved me many times. So did a handprint and a camera."
The ribbon was cut. Crowds clapped. Cameras flashed. A volunteer, a woman who had been in my live stream of the public assembly, burst into tears and hugged me. The world, messy and loud, had pockets of tenderness in it still.
When I go to bed and press my hand in the shadow of Rowan's inked palm, I think of a tiny, ridiculous truth: that a person can be beaten and still choose to make other people safe. It is a small victory, but it is mine.
And once, in a quiet midnight, Dalton found the courage to speak into a room full of people and apologized in a way that was finally not for his relief but for acknowledgement. He stood and said, "I am sorry, Lydia. I failed you."
I nodded. "You did," I said. "But I am not the judge for what must come next."
He left the room, head down. A college life slips away in small and unrepeatable ways. He lost parts of his world he had assumed would always be his.
"What will you do now?" someone asked me in the corridor.
"I will make sure others have the tools not to be alone," I answered. "I will teach girls the vocabulary to name what happens to them. I will remind the world that laughter at another's pain is a choice."
Little Yellow twined a tail around my ankles as if to close the story with a purr.
The last line I like to say when interviews end is this: "If anyone wonders which small items I keep as proof of everything—it's the inked handprint and the battered camera, and the small, yellow cat who insists on sleeping on my chest. Those things are mine, and they remind me who I am."
I press my palm to the wall where Rowan's handprint is, warm from the day's sun, and close my eyes. It is not heroism. It is quiet work. It is the kind of change that tastes like warm noodles in a cold season and the hush of a cat's breath.
The End
— Thank you for reading —