Sweet Romance10 min read
When He Landed: A Long Goodbye That Wasn’t Harsh
ButterPicks15 views
I remember the first time I saw him there was light in the room and he looked like he belonged to the light.
I didn't know then his name would wrap around three years of my life.
I didn't know then that small, ordinary moments would either build a home or reveal a hollow.
I tell this like a map I followed and unfollowed, so every turn you read is the exact one I took.
1
"It's Paolo's friend," my brother had said months before I'd ever speak to him.
"He's coming over?" I asked, thinking it was some casual visit.
"He'll be on the sofa," Paolo Neumann had laughed. "Just go say hi."
The summer sunlight poured across the living room when I pushed Paolo's door open. He sat on the sofa with his phone, the light catching his hair so he looked almost washed in gold.
He heard me, turned his head, gave me that brief, small smile, and then—because he was polite—he pointed with one finger toward the bathroom where Paolo usually sat when he changed clothes.
Then he went back to his phone call. He moved, rose slightly, and the light fell at the back of his neck so I could see the line of his spine.
I stood there for a moment too long. "Hello," I said.
He looked up. "Hi," he said, soft as a bell.
That was the first look. That was the first small smile. I left the doorway planning a thousand sentences I never said.
2
When Paolo took me to the mountain trip in winter, he was different—paler, quieter. The light that had made him seem golden in summer became thin and cold.
He was Axel Fernandez.
He sat in the passenger seat scrolling his phone while the car hummed through slush. I climbed in and said hello.
He looked at me like he had to remember my face. "Hi," he said with the same small practiced smile.
"Are you well?" I asked.
"No," he said after a beat.
"Are you sick?" I pushed.
"No," he said, tapping his phone and then smiling. "Go talk to Paolo."
There were pauses in his voice, and in the spaces between his words I learned how much was polite and how little was personal.
We became a couple because I asked and everyone around us cheered. Paolo nudged, friends clapped, and Axel, who had been patient with many calls and many people, asked me to sit beside him by the fire and let himself be coaxed.
"I thought this would be fun," he said, and kicked Paolo in a joking way. "Don't call him 'big brother' in front of me."
3
"For three years," I told myself later, "we were flawless in the eyes of others."
He remembered birthdays. He gave me gifts with ribbons and notes. He knew how I preferred garlic to pepper, how I liked to sit on the left side of the sofa. Sometimes he would pull me inward from the edge of a sidewalk and gently place me on the safe side.
He stayed gentle and even.
But I burned like a fire and he watered like a patient stream, constant and cool.
We never argued. We never erupted. We never had the red light of jealousy, the heated words that leave a mark. Not once.
"Is this a relationship?" I'd ask my friends. "Is this a partnership?"
They would shrug because from the outside it looked beautiful and secure. But security without depth is like a door painted well but hollow inside.
4
One night I saw him lose his temper in a way I'd never expected.
Amber Brown—my roommate—had been led home from a bar by me; she'd ruined one night with someone new who'd been cruel. We were in the alley by our building, she leaned on me, and then I saw him.
He stood a few steps away, with a woman draped in a light khaki blazer close under his arm. They looked like they were leaving another bar. He came up to us and offered to get her a ride.
I felt that strange, cold stab of not knowing where I stood.
"Who is she?" I wanted to ask. My hand wanted to find his, to say a thousand clumsy things.
When she sat with him in the car instead of him taking us home, I realized how much of my affection had been carefully scheduled into neat little boxes in his life that didn't include surprise or heat.
Later, when I asked him, "Are you happy?" he said he was.
But my question wasn't whether he was happy—my question was whether he felt anything enough for me, and for months the answer I watched was "no."
5
"Are you breaking up with me?" he asked once, in a voice like winter rain.
"This is my decision," I said. "I don't think I can keep pouring and never feel anything in return."
He looked at me as if the idea itself had been an interruption to his plan.
"Why?" he asked like he had the right to all reasons.
"It's not you," I lied for a second, because it sounded less cruel. "It's me." But I couldn't keep the words clean. "It's also you."
He said only this then: "I didn't know."
"I told you the truth now," I said, "and the truth is I'm tired."
We spent that night on a patch of field, the moon above us. The first night we'd come together years ago was in a similar place; firelight and the world whistling cold. I remembered the boy who'd sat careless in the light. I remembered being able to run toward him because he looked large and warm.
The moon was big over our heads and I said, "This is over."
He said quietly, "I can ask why."
I said, "No. It's my decision."
He let it sit. He did not beg. He did not shout. He put his jacket over his knees like any man, and the wind passed through us with nothing but polite regret.
6
The days after we stopped living as a couple were quiet in strange ways.
I slept alone. I took the jacket away from his side of the closet and boxed up the gifts that had once made me dizzy with gratitude. I sold some things, donated some things—tried to make the place I had carried only about him a house that could hold me again.
Paolo fussed at me like a vigilance I had not known I needed. "You can't do this to yourself," he said when he found me sulking on the sofa with my hands empty.
"It's best to stop pretending," I said. "I don't want to be someone who waits forever."
"Then stop waiting," he said. "Let the world surprise you."
7
There were nights when I sat at a bar with Amber and watched other people live out a kind of messy, genuine love. I ordered non-alcoholic drinks because drinking felt like melting into forgetfulness, and I didn't want forgetfulness. I wanted repair.
At one bar, a man handed me a blue drink on a tray.
"A gentleman ordered this for you," the waiter said.
"That's okay," I told him. "Put it somewhere."
My counter moved as if in slow motion. Then I saw Axel. He stood near the bar, polite as ever, and looked at me like he had to remember my face. "Keira," he said.
"Axel," I answered. "I'm with Amber tonight."
"I thought—" he started. "Can I walk you home?"
"No," I said. "It's late. Amber's fine."
He didn't take the car I was offered. He stood there, folded like a question mark.
"Don't let me turn into the person who waits at the door," I said to him. "Please don't make this awkward for me or for your life."
He let the silence sit like a blanket. On the street, the two of us were different people in the same outline.
8
He began showing up more often after that. He sent messages I would ignore. He would stand where my friends and I would eat and watch. When he finally sat down across from me in the school cafeteria—because he wanted to explain—I listened.
"That season of our life, I'll own it," he said. "I didn't love in the ways you needed."
"You didn't," I answered. "We weren't a pair. We were convenient cohabitants."
"I want to change," he said. "Let me try."
"Try for yourself," I said. "Don't try for me. That won't make love."
He smiled the patient smile that had become his shield. "I want to try for us."
I got up and said, "I have to go. I don't believe you."
9
I applied to study abroad. The decision was in part running, in part learning, in part a stubborn thing I had always wanted—being alone in a place that would not give me familiar echoes.
When the plane left, a sliver of the world slid by and there he was at the gate like a shadow that had caught up with me.
He stepped forward, placed both hands on my shoulders, and looked into my face as if to anchor me. "I said I wouldn't let go," he whispered.
"Then don't," I said, "if you want to keep me in your life as a thing that can be kept. But don't expect me to be the same girl who burned herself out bending to a polite man."
He let me go. That was the last part of our unfinished conversation. I walked into the new sky and let it swallow me.
10
The first semester abroad swallowed me in other ways—a language to learn, a small room that felt bigger than my home, professors who spoke like engines, and friends who were more raw than my polished old life.
Axel's messages came less. He sent small notes and the occasional article about something he'd seen. I delved into studies. I met people who made mistakes loudly and repaired loudly, people who argued and smoothed and apologized.
I sent him nothing. I let silence be the wall I used to grow.
11
I saw him again in winter.
He stood in the drizzle under my building with a coat too big for him. I remember the way the rain clung to him and the way his eyes looked like he'd been sleeping with some unresolved grief.
"I came by," he said, as if that explained everything.
"Why?" I asked. "To make me hard to forget?"
He shook his head. "I wanted to know how you were."
"I am fine," I said, but my voice wobble betrayed me. "I'm living in a place where I can make myself."
He came inside because I could not push him away. He dried himself by the dryer. He sat with me and made a meal. When it was simple—potatoes and a bit of stew—he ate with care.
"I missed you," he said quietly.
"I know," I said. "But you didn't save anything."
12
That month, he asked me to stay with him some nights. I refused most of the time. Yet he was patient, present sometimes in ways that felt surprisingly human. He did not push as much as before. He would sit and read or fold his hands and say nothing and simply be there.
I told him once, "When you were distant, I burned up. Now I want something riskier than warmth. I want someone who scares me in the good way."
He said, "I'm here."
I believed him less than I had once, but I let him sit in my room and listen to music. I let his hand touch mine without flinching.
13
In December I caught a fever. I was too stubborn to call my mother immediately. I sent an awkward text to a friend who rushed to fetch me and eventually to the hospital.
Axel arrived in the hospital like a shape that had learned to hurt and still chose care.
"You came," I said the first time my eyes opened.
"I came," he answered. "I was passing by and heard."
"You didn't work?" I asked.
He gave a small laugh that was nearly a sob. "I left my meeting. It's nothing. Seeing you matter."
He stayed. He sat in the waiting room and watched the IV drip like he was counting the seconds in which something could be mended. He saw the nurse steady the line. He helped me when I could not lift myself.
"You don't have to," I murmured.
He pressed his hand on my wrist with a weight that was part apology and part promise. "I wanted to," he said.
14
Sickness undid me in the kind way illness reveals how fragile things are. I was embarrassed at needing help, and he was a man unused to being necessary in such blunt ways.
"How long will you stay?" I asked, feeling foolish comfort grow heavy in my chest.
"As long as you want," he replied.
I wasn't sure I wanted anything. I had lived months teaching myself to be whole. I had tasted the relief of not waiting. But the sight of Axel bringing a thermos of soup, boiling water, and a small, ridiculous stuffed keychain he insisted would ward off germs—these were small things that landed like gentle weights on my heart.
15
We spoke. Real words with edges and slipstreams. He admitted the things he'd not told me before—how he'd been confused by his past with Juliana Yamada, how he thought that past had ended fully but it hadn't, how he had thought that staying still would be enough.
"This isn't an excuse," he said. "I have been selfish. I thought I could keep you by being steady, by letting you do all the burning."
"You let me burn by not matching my blaze," I said.
He nodded. "I didn't see the need to show fire because I thought constancy was enough."
"Constancy like a machine," I said bitterly. "Never surprising, never raging, never tender in the sudden way."
"I was afraid of making mistakes," he admitted. "Afraid of losing you by trying and failing. So instead I didn't try. That was cowardice, not devotion."
For the first time in years, he was not the unruffled man I had dated. He was raw. He was honest. The honesty stung and it also warmed.
16
We sat in the hospital with our hands near each other and said things we should have said three years earlier and things there was only time to say now.
"I don't want you to feel like you need to fix me," he said. "I want to do the fixing."
"I don't want to be your project," I said. "I want a partner."
"I'm trying to be one," he said softly. "If you'll let me."
I looked at him. The man across from me was someone who had loved with a low flame and now insisted on changing. Inside me something both weary and curious stirred.
"It's not a yes," I said. "It is a maybe that will not be counted as a debt."
He accepted that with a nod. It was not dramatic. There was no film music. There were only hospital beeps and our breaths.
17
After I recovered, I went back to my life and my books. The space between us settled into a quieter rhythm. He came by sometimes, sent me photos of things he thought I'd like—small, careful, non-demanding messages.
We did not resume our old scripts. We started a different scene where sometimes he made coffee for me and sometimes I let him walk me home. Sometimes I invited him and sometimes I said, "No, I can't."
"Are you sure?" he would ask, more gently than before.
"I'm sure I need my own life," I'd answer. "But I won't lie and say you are not part of it."
That was the truest thing I could have said.
18
When I left again at the year's end to a new chapter, Axel came to the airport. He came, and this time he did not thrust a promise at me. He wrapped his arms around me in a way that was patient and soft.
"I didn't know how to be enough," he whispered. "I'll learn."
"I hope you do," I said. "Not for me, but for you."
We parted at the gate. I walked through the security line with hands that had been held and released and with a heart that had been both hurt and healed in small places.
19
Years later when I came back—older, more patient—I met him again at a gathering. He was still the same man in many ways. He had grown, I had grown. The people around us saw friends. Paolo and Gloria were there, laughing like the world hadn't changed.
We said, "Hello," and it meant something different now.
I had closed a door years before and left it closed. But life is not a line; it is a house with many rooms. We crossed paths in different corridors.
"I remember you," I told him once with a smile that was not raw.
"I remember you too," he said. "I wish I had shown you fire earlier."
"I wish I had asked for it," I said honestly.
We laughed and left it there.
20
There were three moments that still press against me like notes that will not stop ringing.
He smiled at me in that doorway the first time. It was a small, casual thing that made my chest ache.
He came to the hospital and boiled me soup when I could not even stand. His hands were clumsy, and they were honest.
On the last day at the gate, he wrapped his arms around me and did not say, "Don't go." He simply held me like he had learned how to hold a thing precious.
Those are not grand, cinematic moments. They were three small, telling acts that made my course shift without telling me.
21
We never had a dramatic public unmasking of a villain. There was no ambush, no shaking of the world. There was only the slow reveal of what love can be when two people decide to try, and the slow surrender that comes when one admits a mismatch and chooses kindness over possession.
If there is a moral, it is this: sometimes staying is a brave way of giving love and sometimes leaving is a brave way of preserving it.
When Axel landed in my life again, I had learned to fly on my own. That is, I think, how we became gentler people for a little while. We didn't always get it right. But in the quiet places where something like mercy grows, we found room to be honest.
The End
— Thank you for reading —