Sweet Romance12 min read
The Red Dress and the Broken Hairpin
ButterPicks14 views
I am Meredith Barrett, and I learned early that to survive in a great house you had to be very small, very quiet, and very useful.
"I wrapped the washing bowl tight," I told her once, when she ordered me around. "And I swept the courtyard twice, Madam Bianca."
"Good," Bianca said, and the word was like a bright coin dropped into my palm. "You are obedient, Meredith. Like a little bowl should be."
Bianca Lange laughed then, the sound quick and careless as someone who believed nothing terrible would ever come for her. She was the most strange person I had ever met: blunt as a fishbone, daring as a child, and stubborn in ways I could not pry open. She called herself foolish, but I saw something harder in her—light that wouldn’t be smothered.
"Where is he now?" she asked one dusk, tilting toward the window. "Andres will be at the barracks, teaching men to die properly."
"Andres Hall has been away a lot," I answered. "He keeps watch of the lines. He is very busy."
She put her hand over her mouth and sang one of the old cheerful tunes she liked, a tune that never fit the quiet of the house and made the servants stop what they were doing to listen, bewildered.
"Madam," Faith whispered to me later that night, "she hummed that song again. She never was silent."
"Let her hum," I said. "Humming is harmless."
It was harmless until the day the court papers came and the great house fell under the emperor’s scrutiny. The papers tumbled like dead leaves through the gate: indictments, writs, banners proclaiming treason. Someone who had sat in the highest seat of power—Bianca’s father—was named a traitor. They called him a chancellor, and the street vendors cheered when the guards gave them fragments of paper.
I would be lying if I said the household mourned for the man who had put the house on top of the world, for we had all watched how power bent the proud to cruelty. But when they bound the old man they bound something of Bianca’s life too—her gilded world snapped open.
"She will not be touched," Bianca whispered in the first week after the arrests. "I will not be dragged like a sheep."
"You must keep quiet," I told her. "You must not give them reasons."
She looked at me and smirked. "Meredith, you and little Faith are always scared. Which is good. I like that about you. A scared girl survives better."
Faith Jordan, who had once cried until her eyes swelled shut and could no longer see the sun, is the kind of person who will stand between you and a falling curtain without asking the price.
"Where's small-peach?" Bianca would ask, calling Faith by a nickname, and Faith would choke out, "Here, Madam. I'm here." She always was.
One night, forced laughter and wine on many lips, Bianca tried to make a joke at the general’s table. "Andres Hall," she called, loud enough for everyone to hear, "tell us if a woman’s cooking can be as fierce as a battle plan."
"Stop," Harrison Burt snapped from across the table. Harrison was one of the general’s sworn brothers, a man who had lost his arm in the wars and gained a habit of throwing his sword like a joke into any silence. "We are not here to joke."
Harrison saw an affront in everything Bianca did. He wanted her demeaned. The hall filled with the kind of laughter that is not warm but meant to cut. It made the air taste like iron.
"I will take a cup," Bianca said, and poured her wine for Andres.
"Bianca, leave the plate." Andres Hall’s voice was low. He looked colder than the moon. "You should not stand by us."
"Then why marry me?" she asked, the laugh gone and a raw edge showing. "Why keep me if you only guard my step?"
His hand tightened on his cup. "Because I cannot be soft and still be a commander."
"You chose soft once," she whispered, and because she was wearing her red that day—she loved red—he saw red reflected back and something inside him cracked.
They fought as if it were their private war. We could hear the vehemence from the servants’ corridor. There were nights she tried to trap him with tricked wine; other nights he would forbid her steps. She would rage and then curl small as a child, still humming that ridiculous tune.
"She was like a caged bird," I told Faith once when the wind tore at the garden leaves. "I think she wanted to fly."
"Then maybe she tried too hard," Faith said. "When you have no wings and you keep opening the door you will only hurt yourself."
A day came when the edict announced the family's doom. The chancellor was paraded through the market square before the crowd. I did not think I could bear the sight of the man who had been a father in title. But I went. In the press of people I could see Bianca's red hair ornament pinned in someone’s hand, and I thought my lungs would empty.
This is the scene I will not forget: the public punishment of the man the court called a traitor. They brought him out on a cold, gray morning. His face was once the face of cleverness; now it was a map of small defeats. Guards in silver mail held him upright. The drum of the city beat a rhythm meant for shame.
"Traitor!" cried one bystander. "The country is safer without him," another shouted, and their voices piled up like stones. The official read the seal that afternoon—a long list of crimes. People spat. Women with coarse hands beat drums. Boys held up knives meant for meat and cheered.
"Father," Bianca had whispered into the pillow the night before, "I will go on."
"Meredith," she said to me that morning before the procession, hands shaking as she tied the little hairpin into my palm. "Keep this for me."
"I will keep it," I promised. "I will not let it be lost."
The chancellor walked like a man who feels every step carved into his soul. He attempted a smile at the crowd; it crumbled when someone called out about the poor families who had starved, about the official coffers emptied into velvet pockets. The crowd's voices were a tide against a cliff. They were cold, and loud, and bloodthirsty. A merchant who had once received a favor spat in the chancellor's direction.
"Is there any last word?" the executioner—tall and wrapped in black—asked, though the man had no breath left for anything but regret.
Bianca’s eyes were in the crowd, searching. I could not see them meet. The chancellor’s hands trembled. He moved his lips as if to say his name, to call for a pardon or a witness, but the sound was gone between dust and banners.
Then they brought forward the punishment—an old, public cutting off of rank that would leave a man shamed in life and in stories. The official read aloud, calling the chancellor by name, listing the misdeeds in a voice that rang. People pressed closer as if to hear better, to feel the authority of the act.
"Forgive me," the chancellor managed to say, voice thin and surprised. "Forgive—"
"Shame on you!" people screamed. Women wept, but there was not sorrow for him—there was triumph, a rough satisfaction in seeing a mighty thing fall. The captain of the guard removed the chancellor’s ceremonial robe and ripped the gold braid away from his shoulders. A child in the crowd picked up a strip and waved it on a stick, as if hoisting a flag.
The punishment ritual was public, slow, and deliberate. The chancellor's title was taken from him by the stroke of a blunt instrument on a wooden block; the blade did not fall without a sound. He swung his head and his eyes widened. At first there was a flash of disbelief on his face—then denial: "This is wrong, this is not true!" His lips mouthed for mercy like the dying trying to hold onto daylight.
The crowd changed. Curiosity hardened into cruelty. Men pointed fingers. A former ally spat at his boots. "You ate while we starved!" a woman yelled, and the shame seemed to bend the man's backbone. He began to crumble, then to curse, then to plead. "No, no—my life—my name—" He tried to smile to recapture something of power, as if posture could fool the world. But power, once peeled like an onion, leaves a man smelling of nothing but his own breath.
I felt the blood go out of me. Men around me shouted. A bowl man next to me clapped until his palms hurt. He shouted, "Let the dogs see their kings fall!" Others brought up the children for better view. The guards made no mercy. They walked the man to the post—he walked like a puppet with his strings cut. When the final stroke came, there was a silence heavy as iron. The crowd exhaled, a great relieved thing. Some wept quietly for the country; others cheered.
Bianca could not watch. I had to yank her away, though she had insisted on being near. Her face went white as paper, then red as the dress she wore when she married Andres, and finally hushed into a small, helpless thing. She clutched the hairpin in her fist until her knuckles went white.
The aftershock was something else: gossip, bargaining, smells of oil and onion. The great man’s servants were shoved out into the street; people threw the heavy trappings into a pile and danced on them. Harrison laughed like a man who had never been loved and would never be again. I stood apart. I thought of the children who had once been fed at the chancellor’s table and who now picked through fields for sweet roots.
"They will not stop," Bianca said later, her voice small and broken. "They will turn on us until there is nothing left."
"It is done," I said, looking at her, and I felt like a person who had been handed an ember and had to decide whether to keep it or throw it to ground.
Months blurred. The generalship of Andres Hall hardened into a scaffold of white hair and iron. He became a commander who let duty strip him of softness. But in secret—when the night fell and his candle burned low—he was a man who sat by Bianca's window and waited for silence to speak.
"Why did you save her?" people asked once, accusing. "Why did you keep the traitor’s daughter?"
Andres’s eyes were quiet as the inside of a shell. "Because cruelty makes me cruel if I join it," he said. "Because war does not end the debts of the heart."
"Do you love her?" Bianca once asked no one in particular, when she did not know whether she had the right to ask.
"Andres," I heard her say in private, two years into nights when she was free, "if I had not been foolish—if I had not been such a fool—would you have loved me back?"
"I have loved you since you laughed at a ladder," he replied, his voice thin with old war. "Do you remember telling me a ladder was a way to steal the moon? I loved the way you thought the world could be plucked like fruit."
He softened in those rare hours. He fed her with his hands. He would boil a bitter herb and give it to her when she could not keep food down. The two of them played a crooked, dangerous dance—sometimes they tripped and fell into old wounds, but sometimes they held together like two splints binding a broken bone.
One summer, when the border lines trembled with rumor and the emperor sent orders that a new concubine—the palace’s chosen—was to be brought as a peace bribe, we all saw the old grief return to Bianca. She tasted the possibility of being discarded, of everything being wrenched away for political favor. Her eyes hardened as she promised herself small rebellions.
"I will not be a bargaining coin," she told me, quiet and terrible. "If they want me sold, I will choose my own fate."
Her choice arrived in the thin shape of a carriage. We had been warned—rumors spread like sparks—and yet none of us foresaw the cruelty that would come.
Japan-like names and modern cameras have no place in our tale. But crowds have always loved spectacle. The emperor’s envoys took Bianca’s choice from her chest; they offered her as a peace prize to the north tribes, to Fabien Ahmed's lord—the fierce warlord who had no care for soft things and loved spoils of war. They used her as the price to buy soldiers against fire.
"Meredith," she said, packing a small satchel, the luck of an old hairpin tucked in the lining. "If this is the end, don't let them say I was weak."
"You will not end," I said, trying to lie as if lying were a comfort. "You will make them regret everything."
She laid her palm on mine. "Then keep my hairpin. If I am ashes, if I am gone, keep it. And, Meredith, tell them I laughed."
I told the secrets I was asked to tell—the lies that smoothed paths—and then the night came when the route to the north was a river of dust and cold wind.
We left by dawn. Faith came with us till the last. She whispered, "Be brave," as if bravery were a thing she could gift. The carriage rolled away, and I stood at the gate until it was no more than a small red dot.
"You promised you'd be brave," I heard Bianca sing in my head long after the sound faded, humming that same ill-fitting tune.
War is a slow beast. The news arrived later like a sealed arrow. Andres Hall returned from the field at last, broken, ragged, eyes hollow and white at the temples. "She set a fire," he told us in the courtyard, voice not bold but raw. "She burned the camp to let us escape. She burned herself to keep us hidden."
He buried his head in his hands. "I carried the ashes."
"She was a foolish woman," Harrison said, and there was an edge in his tone that tasted of regret.
"I carried the ash box myself," Andres whispered to the morning. "I carried what she gave me. I carried her song."
He rode north and fought and bled until a man named Fabien Ahmed fell by his blade and the war was ended. They brought the ashes back, a box of bone and dust wrapped in fabric that had smelled of jasmine and smoke. Andres refused every title. He drank sometimes in his study until dawn found him staring at the little box.
One night—some long while after the final battle—I walked into the quieting room where he kept the porcelain box. He had opened it, and the hairpin—my hairpin—rested on top like a tiny red flag.
"She loved red," he said without turning. "She loved the ridiculous, the dangerous, and the wrong things—like ladders for stealing moons." He laughed until it broke. "She was an impossible woman."
"Do you blame her?" I dared ask.
He looked at me, and his face had the shape of someone who had learned how to live with regret like a second skin. "I loved her until the world demanded I hate her. I fought with half a heart. I kept her. And the world took her back anyway."
"Will you let her rest?" I asked.
"I buried what she left," he answered. "I avenge what she could not fix, and I tend to what she had loved. That is what a man can do, limited as he is."
The house still remembers her humming. In the kitchens we tell the story of how she baked pies that tasted of disasters and joy. Children point at a red thread stuck in the rafters and ask about Bianca Lange, the woman who laughed like a storm.
"She was the strangest," Faith once said, cleaning the courtyard steps. "And I loved her."
"You loved her because she gave you a home," I told her.
"We loved her because she was not afraid to fall," Faith answered, eyes steady as if she had seen the shape of the future.
I keep the hairpin in a small box behind the store of cloth. Camila Rahman—the lady who once sheltered us, the princess who took Bianca’s place at the court and who became the caretaker of our child for a time—once folded fabric for me and her hands trembled.
"You did well," she said to the silent box. "You gave her dignity."
"Did she ever know?" I asked, wanting the truth.
"She knew enough to be brave," Camila answered. "And she chose to be.
"It is enough," I said.
Bianca's little daughter grew with the almond eyes and lashes of her mother. Andres held the child like a treasure and cried like a man who had learned how heavy love could be. The girl would ask him, "Who was she? Why is her song sad?" and sometimes he would tell stories that made the girl's eyes shine like coins.
"She used to think ladders stole the moon," he told the child once. "She called me a cold man and then trapped my warmth like a butterfly in a jar."
"Did she laugh?" the little girl asked.
"Every chance she could," Andres said, and he smiled, and the ache in his smile sounded like a small forgiveness.
Once, just before the first snow, the whole house gathered around the little box that contained the ash and the hairpin. We all pressed our palms to the lid, and I felt a small heat. It was not the heat of war or anger, but a warm remembering, like the place where someone left the kettle on the stove and the air tasted of tea.
In the courtyard I buried a small dented spoon where the red dress had brushed the grass. I call it a silly grave for a woman who would have laughed to see it so. But the music she hummed is a thing that stays, a crooked tune that will always come through the bones of the house.
"Meredith," Faith says when she sweeps the steps, "do you ever regret it?"
"I regret the things you regret," I say. "But I keep her hairpin. It keeps the tune alive."
At night, when the wind slips through the shutters and the moon throws a small window of light across the floorboards, I take out the hairpin and listen for a laugh that belongs to no one and to everyone at once. It is a simple thing—red lacquer chipped where fingers have held it too hard—but when I put it to my ear I can almost hear the hum she hummed at odd hours and in forbidden kitchens.
"She laughed at ladders," I tell the sleeping child sometimes, and she giggles, and it sounds like a small promise.
And when the wind carries a little ash away from the place where I buried the spoon, I think of Andres holding a box of dust and saying, "I brought her home." I think of the public shouting, the drums, the shame, and the mercy that never came quickly enough. I think of the front door that always seems to creak the same way, no matter who walks through it.
The hairpin is small and red and crooked. I have kept it through hunger and warmth, through the relentless seasons. It is my witness. It is her joke left on Earth.
When the little girl's hands grow sure and she asks, "What happens if someone you love does a bad thing?" I tell her the truth: "Sometimes they do bad things to save what they love. Sometimes the world makes choices for them. What matters is that someone remembers them with softness."
She will never know how I watched her mother carried like a banner of shame, nor how I kept a small hairpin to guarantee a laugh in the years after. But she will keep the hairpin when I am gone. It will be a small thing to show that a laugh once refused to be buried.
So I keep it in the box behind the cloth and sometimes rub the red with my thumb. I push the lid back and the little sound of lacquer on lacquer is like a sentence unfinished.
"Keep it," Bianca had told me the day she left. "If I go, make them remember I laughed."
I tuck the hairpin away, and when I hear the child hum her mother’s strange song, I allow myself a small comfort: that she is remembered, not as a traitor’s daughter, but as a woman who stole ladders to see the moon.
The End
— Thank you for reading —