Rebirth14 min read
The Pork Stew, the Iron Chain, and the Man Who Became Less Than a Rule
ButterPicks17 views
I have loved a shadow three times over and once I loved a man who wore a chain for a living.
"He looks ridiculous in red," I said the first time I curled into the funeral smoke and watched a man's life be boiled into soup.
"Ridiculous?" The voice was all frost, and when the frost laughed, it sounded like metal. "He's dead. You should be disappointed."
"I am a pig," I answered, because the last life had been a literal pig and I remembered the taste of blood being stewed with fermented cabbage. "I prefer pork with rice."
"How modest." He smiled then, a small cruel thing behind the fog. "Modesty suits you."
He was Black—black robe, black mist—and everyone else called him Jin Decker because sometimes rules like labels. He called himself a warden of damnation, a collector of debts, and he liked the sound of my confusion. He liked to watch me die.
"Why would you do that?" I asked, even when the log split open and men began to shout about the fire, even when the blade found the throat of the pig-body I inhabited and the butcher's hands were slick with warm blood.
"Because you are mine to teach," Jin Decker said, and his chain slid like a cold whisper through the fog. "You will learn what it means to be bound."
"When you get bored, do you keep the leftovers?" I tried for a joke. He didn't laugh.
That was the life when my soul hung between the ribs of a kitchen and the next breath. After that, I learned to be a woman again. After that, I became Monica Day.
"Monica?" Earl Robertson asked at my birth, sitting cross-legged on the smoky yard like he owned the story. He smelled of warm bread and something larger than me; he looked like the sort of man who knew how to hold the shape of a world in his hands.
"You'll not be a pig this time," he said and winked. "Not on my watch."
"Are you making a wager?" I asked then, before I could remember all the hollow places in me. "On when I will die?"
"On when I will let you die," he said, and his hands reached for the line that would never entangle him—that is, until it did.
People think of the underworld as iron and ledger, as inevitable machinery that hums in the dark. Earl Robertson is the sort of man who used to hum with that machinery and then, in a whim of compassion that looked a lot like impatience, took a piece of rule and wore it as a coat. "I am not rule without feeling," he said, "I am the feeling that learned the rule."
"Then why are you here in my wedding chamber?" I whispered once, red veil heavy on my head, smoke already skimming the rafters because someone had spilled a lamp.
"You didn't think I would miss this," Earl said, like an apology and a verdict in one breath.
"You can't be allowed to plan weddings," I told him. "You make my life into a ledger and then complain I don't balance your column."
"Then balance it," he answered, like it was the easiest thing in the world, and he fed me a piece of roast chicken as if bribery could pay for fate.
Of course fate cannot be bribed. Fire can be started and stopped; decisions sometimes cannot. On the night of my supposed happiness the ceiling came down and the flames took the bed. "Let me stay just one night," I begged Earl with the last of my breath, and in the small of the hour he reached for a hand that wasn't his duty and did something he had never promised.
Monica: "Please, one night."
Earl: "I will try. I will try, but I do not promise miracles where the lights have been set to go out."
"You promised," I said, because I had a habit of believing a soft voice meant a harbor.
"Shut up and be brave," he said, and he shed the softness and held me as the world got hot and then very small.
He saved me sometimes. He also broke me—the two are not always different when gods are learning human hands.
"You have a curious sense of humor," Jin Decker said later when he found me alive again in simple clothes, market dust under my nails. "Persistent, that one. She likes pork."
"Don't call me 'that one,'" I told him. "I'm Monica. Monica Day."
"And yet you appear before me as a debt," he murmured.
"Who told you to collect me in the first place?" I demanded. "Was it the council? Or your appetite for culinary tragedies?"
He flicked his chain. "It is a complicated ledger. Some things are owed."
That ledger kept me turning. I resurrected with enough memory to know horror and enough amnesia to gamble with hope. Each life, the shape of me was the same: a heart that kept misreading men, a hunger for warmth. Each life, the irons of his chain found different necks—sometimes mine, sometimes other unlucky bones—and he made a sport of my seasons.
Earl, though—Earl learned to be plagued by things more like sympathy than law. He became a man who could feel hunger, and so he ate. He relearned breath. He would laugh in sunlight and then worry over the oddest things, like whether his hands smelled of earth too much for someone who had once outlived judgment.
"You look like a person who will miss me terribly when I'm gone," Jin said one morning, clearing his idea of me as if he could rub grease off a plate.
"I look like a woman who remembered centuries of pig feed," I replied. "So that will be new."
We lived between jokes like that—two beings learning the wrong sorts of mercy from each other.
"Do you ever want to be forgiven?" I asked Earl once as he leaned against our crooked fence, watching children playing by the river.
"Ear—" he started, then laughed. "Earl, yes. But what is forgiveness to someone who kept a ledger? Sometimes forgiveness is a bad arithmetic problem."
"Then stop keeping ledger."
He didn't. He promised, instead, in small ways: he got me a bowl of rice when I was hungry, he learned the names of the mice that crept into our pantry, he went out into storms to fetch roofs for neighbors whose roofs had been swallowed by wind. He was the sort of man who marked his days by the people he helped, and then the one day he marked by giving me back to a sky that smelled like coal. He took his ancient, bureaucratic power and turned it into a loneliness I could recognize.
And then there was Ginevra Hansen—silver wolf, laughing blue eyes, the kind of woman who walked into a room and rearranged the shape of everything.
"You're still alive?" Ginevra asked the first time she found me with Earl in a small guesthouse in a town where everyone swore at the weather.
"I am," I answered.
"You were a fox once, right?" She grinned like she kept candies in her teeth. "Cute. Always the dramatic types. Remember when we used to decide weather for crops in the valley?"
"I remember your beating hearts," I said. "I remember you offering me soap and telling me my fur needed brushing."
She laughed. "You were ridiculous. The whole lot of us were ridiculous." She kissed Earl's cheek like it was still her own winning.
"You left," I told her one night with more gentle sorrow than accusation. "You left him."
"Yes," Ginevra said simply. "Because he was starving for success, and I was hungry for everything. He wanted the skies, and I wanted dinners and dances and small things." Her eyes softened, though. "We found our pride in different places."
That line between pride and hunger—between a soul that will swallow a fate whole and a soul that will make a home of gentleness—was where our tragedy sat. I loved Earl for the small things; Ginevra loved as a wolf sometimes loves: intensely and in practice, not in promise. Jin Decker loved as a rule loves: with an appetite for order, no matter the collateral.
At some point, the ledger shook. The piece Earl had kept as his heart—the humanity he had smuggled from the order of things—started to fade. There was a humourless satisfaction in the underworld's ranks that was starting to look like a revolt. The part of "rule" that he had left would not remain quiet while the other half grew soft. And when very old laws find new appetites, they send a reckoning.
"Monica," Earl said one afternoon as we bundled carrots into a basket, "I must go back to the place where numbers live."
"Back to Yama," I said. I saw the word in his face before it left his mouth. "Are you going to fight the ledger with a ladle?"
"Do not be silly," he said, a little pained. "I am going because a part of the sky needs mending. I am not the sky, Monica. I am a man with a cliff of debt to settle."
"You're always so good at metaphors," I muttered. "Try not to die in the rearranging."
He smiled. "I will not die," he said, and because he believed it, for three months we stacked our time together like a thrift store of small joys—an extra egg here, a new boot mended there, flowers in odd jars.
The thing about love is that even when you know it's doomed you try to be of more use than you are. In the final days before Earl went, I kept telling myself to walk away like a smart heroine. I could never help it: when he touched my shoulder I melted.
"Do you hate Jin?" I asked him during the last night.
"I hate punishment," he said. "I hate the way it lingers."
"Do you forgive him?" I pressed.
He looked out at the sky then, as if hoping to see whole years stitched between two clouds. "I think I forgive him in increments. Enough to tell the truth."
And the truth was ugly and small. Jin Decker had been allowed to grow jealous and vindictive. He had kept a count and the count had become a blade: he wound and snapped, and he turned people as if they were marionettes. He had tied his iron chain to my neck as if it were a charm, as if it were a seasoning for his favorite dish. That dish—his fetish—was the ritual of a pig boiled down and turned into something he could savor. I had been served and tasted like a lesson.
Earl did not come back how he left. He took a piece of law and tried to wear it like clothing; but clothing frays when you use it to do violence. He went back to plead with machinery and with men that had no faces. "This isn't the system I took an oath to hold," he said. "She has grown. She is not a ledger entry."
In halls that smell of ash and accounts, he argued softly for us.
For that act, the underworld had a punishment equal and immediate: Earl's rights as a rule-bearer were questioned. He would have to wear a human life like a test. The portion of rule he had carved into flesh was separated from the list of powers. It trembled, like an old lamp being handed to a new owner. "You will be human," came the decree, not cruel so much as inexorable. "You will be something very close to death—so close that you will learn what it means to be eaten by time."
I watched him grow smaller in the way of the important. I watched him come home with pockets of ash and a smile that was both fragile and very dear. He stayed as long as he could. We had a winter of quiet love in a little house patched with whatever the world would lend.
Then the day came when I woke and the world had been rearranged. Jin Decker was exposed.
The punishment was not a private thing. Bad bureaucrats in a place that pretends to be all business are punished best by spectacle—by a plain, public, unavoidable unraveling that leaves the offender exposed to everyone he'd tried to manipulate.
It happened in the Hall of Names. The hall smelled like dry ink and old spices. Hundreds of ghostly clerks sat with scrolls and attendants stood like white posts, and the dead peered in from the rafters like an audience waiting for a play. They called the offender to the center, and when he stood, the black fog around him seemed to curl like the tail of a dog that has been told it cannot sleep on the bed.
Jin Decker was arrogant at first. He snaked his iron chain with a flourish and said, "I collect only what is owed."
"Let's see what is owed," Earl said, and before Jin could wrap the chain around anything, he heard his ledger.
"Be quiet," Jin snapped. The chain bit the air and the fog sparkled. "You have not the right to pry into my accounts."
"Everyone's accounts are public when they serve in the Hall," said a clerk with eyes like smear of coal. "That is rule."
They unrolled documents, and the first one listed names: debts that were never recorded as fines but as petty cruelties, as hours stolen from life and sold for experiment. "He has been taking lives to taste an idea," said a thin woman with a violet ribbon. "He has been treating remit as recipe. He turned living souls into courses to be observed."
Jin's smile thinned. "You speak as if you understand cuisine," he said. "You should be grateful for the order I provide."
"Oh?" The clerk's tone sank into cold water. "We should be grateful that you wound souls in circular fashion, then pass them off as 'cooking practice'?"
The hall laughed, and it was a brittle sound—page against bone. They produced witness after witness: the farmer whose wife was taken because Jin fancied an evening meal, the seamstress whose last breath was watched like a TV program, the small boy who had been forced to watch the thing Jin called a demonstration. Each voice chipped at Jin until his arrogance began to crumble like a bad crust.
"Do you understand what you did to her?" one woman cried out, and the ghosts turned their hollow heads toward me.
"Monica?" Jin's fog rose in question. "You again? You should have stayed a pig this time. Pigs are simpler."
"What you did was to turn life into a lesson," I said. I stood then because the trail of my lives had made me bold. "You made a game of people's deaths. You made me into a dish and used the grief of others like garnish."
He tried to sneer. The hall, however, already knew the taste of his cruelty. They burned the ledger in a ceremonial light and from it flared the faces of everyone he'd wronged. They played back his acts like a puppet show in sunlight: him smiling while I was bound; him not caring when the butcher made stew of my body; him laughing at the thing he called the 'killing-dish' before he tasted it.
Something in the room shifted into contempt. The flyfolk—those small attendants who usually buzz with indiscretion—whispered and flitted over his chain. They clucked their tiny tongues as if the sound could flay him.
"How dare you," Earl said quietly, but his voice carried the weight of a real thunder. "Rule is not a taste. Rule is not for play."
It is one thing to be tried by law and another to be publicly made small. The more the hall spoke, the less Jin had left to be. He began in the usual order: denial, then sharp anger, then bargains that sounded like an inventory of excuses.
"You don't understand the necessity!" Jin barked, clinging to his chain like a man who believes his coat will keep him warm. "I kept counts. I was efficient. Without me the line would be endless!"
"At whose side did your efficiency stand?" a ghostly voice asked. "The ledger holds bodies because that is what you used it for."
Jin's face faltered. He looked at me. "You were always foolish, Monica. You were always a joke."
"Then watch," I said. "Watch how the people you toyed with find their voices."
And they did. The courtyard's faces—souls, servants, trades—crowded the hall on that day. A thousand witnesses that Jin had thought merely spectators. A thousand remembered the way their loved ones were turned over. People brought not weapons: they had no right to carry them in the Hall. They brought truth. They brought the names of their mornings and the way a hand had fit in their own. They described small things—how someone's laugh had been cut off as if a string were broken when Jin decided the story would be better with emptiness. They spoke of a thousand small torments that together make a life unbearable.
His reactions were a map of a soul unmoored. At first he sneered, then he raised his voice to drown them, then he insisted the rules permitted him, then he laughed as if laughter could hope the moment away. Finally, when the screams and testimonies pooled like rainwater at his boots, he outright begged.
"Please," he said. "Please—"
His voice had lost its metal. It sounded like a pot that had been emptied.
"Begging does not wash what you did," said the violet-ribboned clerk, and people took out their phones—if the underworld has a frivolous gift, it is that witnesses can make a display of you. They recorded him as he lost his shine.
People who had once bowed to him in fear now bared teeth in scorn. "How could you?" a voice called. "How could you be so hungry?"
"You're a coward," another cried. "All of us knew better than you. You pretended to know the weight of law but you used it like a spoon."
The room applauded—slow, cold hands. That was the most stinging thing, because applause in the Hall is what happens when the public says, "We will keep watch now." He had been left to a chorus of disgust.
They stripped his chain, one link at a time, in a ceremony that felt like undoing stitches from a wound. Each link came loose with an explanation: "For collecting lives for entertainment," "For abuse of position," "For turning grief into a lesson." They flung the links into a brazier where once there were accounts; the iron shrieked and bent, and as it did the fog around Jin Decker thinned into something very small and brittle.
He went from a man who commanded to a man swatting at shadows. First his smirk cracked, then his jaw slackened, his eyebrows arched in panic he hadn't felt since he realized people can call you out. Then a fast, rattling denial, "I didn't—no—" Then he screamed, a sound like a bell struck in reverse. He tried to rewrite his actions into heroics—"I gave order!"—but the witnesses had given their own history and it held stronger than his defense.
"Shame," said someone near the rafters. "Shame like this is rarer than mercy."
A child—who had been the first to lose a mother because of Jin's appetite—stepped forward. She tossed a bowl of water at his feet. "For the taste he loved," she said, and the bowl splattered. The Hall tasted salt that day that wasn't meant for Jin's palate. People clapped; they took pictures; they turned the footage through a world of whispers.
He tried to bargain. He promised to work. He begged to be allowed a post as a minor clerk—anything to avoid complete humiliation. The governing spirit who once might have given him back an inch of dignity looked down on him.
"No," the governor said—we will call him by a human name because he looked human enough for a moment—"You will answer for the souls. We will make you watch, forever, the meals you made of people. You will be given a post, yes: the lowest office in stewarding the living memories. You will tidy up their things; you will polish the brass on the bell that rings names back. You will be made public property of people's remembrances."
He collapsed in a heap that might once have been dignity.
"Let him keep his face," I said finally. "Not because he has any right, but because mercy is not a thing we give the guilty; mercy is what keeps us from becoming them."
People murmured. Some spat. He glared at me then, because if anything in that room felt like a weapon, it was my quiet.
"You won't see your little dinners again," he sneered.
"I never wanted to be your dinner," I said. "I wanted to be someone's home."
He ceased all attempts. He was reduced to a man swallowed by a litany of names. The crowd dispersed with a kind of exhausted satisfaction—no banners, no martyrdom—only the plain fact that the man who had once turned death into an appetite would live the longest punishment: being known.
That public judgment turned into a different life for Jin Decker. He was not broken in a way that brokenness is final. He was sewn into a fabric of being observed. The Hall will sometimes let its worst men live so they may be watched until they choose to be less monstrous.
"Why did you stop my sentence?" the clerk asked Earl later, after the last of the witnesses had gone and the hall hummed like good machinery.
"Because being human must mean being part of truth," Earl answered. "We will not make monsters of people who pay the price. We will make them watch the consequences."
"You bear a lot of blame, too," the clerk said quietly. "You broke rule."
"I will make it right," Earl said, and he told me later that he would—he would go live among the people of the world, he would learn nothing and everything by failing to be infinite. He would return when he could bear it.
We left the Hall with Jin's limp form behind us and the memory of the crowd like a bright net. Public punishment is a strange thing: it doesn't end suffering, but it sends a message that suffering will be accounted for and that no ledger may be so private as to be unanswerable. I had seen a thousand deaths, and this time it was different: the killed had been given speech.
"Earl," I said. We sat afterward under an old tree that had seen fewer riots and more marriages than either of us. "Did you think I would keep the taste of that stew in me forever?"
"No," he said. "Because now you will have all these small breakfasts with me."
"Promise you will not leave at dawn," I said.
He laughed, and the laugh was his oath. "Not at dawn."
We never went back to the sort of life Jin Decker liked to play with. He kept his chains where they could be seen and learned to make liturgy of apology. Public punishment marks a man; it does not end the world. It changes the watchers because they must become watchful.
Years later, sitting by a rain-streaked window, someone asked me: "Did being punished truly mend him?"
"Not entirely," I answered. "Some people are mended by knowledge, some by time. Jin was mended in the only way the underworld understands: through the eyes of those he used. The scariest thing was not that he changed; it was that he had to learn how to bear being watched by the ones he'd used. That is a daily cruelty with a mind for the just."
He never returned to his old appetite in full. He grew small. He learned to tuck his chain away. He smiled sometimes like a man who has seen the heat and is content to keep a cool kettle on his small stove.
And for me—Monica Day, once fox, once pig, always a woman who collected lives like birds—I set a table with better soup. I learned to cook for the living, not as seasoning for the dead. I married a man who had once been a rule and then chose to be human. When he went to sleep I would stitch the hem of his sleeve and study his hands for the way he expressed a life of small mercies.
"There will be more bad men," I told him once. "There will be people who assume they can season lives like stew. They will come again and again."
"Then we'll be ready," Earl said, and wrapped his arms around me.
"Will you promise to close the door on anyone who brings a recipe of cruelty?"
"I promise," he said.
I trust him like I trust the warm bowl in my hands and the way a dog trusts a kindly hand. He may not be perfect, but he is the one who found a way to be less than a rule and more than a sigh.
"When you die next time," Jin Decker's last voice in my memories said like a thread, "I will be waiting with the iron chain."
"Then hang it on the peg," I answered in return. "But don't expect me to be your pork."
I laughed alone, and the sound carried into the house where Earl slept and the city where Ginevra danced and the underworld where people like Jin learned to be seen.
The End
— Thank you for reading —