Sweet Romance14 min read
The Pear Tree, the Quiet Man, and the Choice I Could Not Refuse
ButterPicks12 views
I was born to a small trading house that once had more luck than sense, and I learned young how to trade smiles for chances.
"My name is Joanna Chandler," I told myself like a prayer, standing by the crooked pear tree in the garden at the high house where we lived as guests. "I will not be small forever."
"Table manners, Joanna," Luisa Bertrand said one morning, clicking the beads on her wrist like a rosary. "Look like a lady. Make a line for power."
"Yes, Mother," I said, with the exact softness she expected. I bowed until my knees cracked. I learned to bend early. I learned to present.
Marina Torres, my maid, watched me with worried eyes. "Miss, be careful with that gentleman," she whispered.
"Who?" I asked, though I already knew. The house where Luisa had put me—borrowed favor with the powerful—had a son famous for not being moved. People called him a cloud of frost. I called him my obstacle.
"I mean Cyril Bowman," Marina said. "He rarely speaks to anyone twice."
"I will be charming," I said. I laughed too loudly and curtsied until my ribs hurt. It felt like an act in a play where every move was written for me.
He was always there and nowhere. When I first arrived, he nodded like a breeze. "Table manners," he said once when I dropped a cup. He did not smile. He did not need to.
"Joanna," Marina said one night in a low voice, "you look small in their big rooms. Do you want to go home?"
"No," I said, and it came out too quick, like a coin dropped into a locked box. "I want to climb."
I practiced my flirtations like lessons. I tripped in the paths, hoping he would scoop me up. I allowed my skirts to be too bright. I pretended to swoon and giggle. I made a fool of myself in public to make them see me.
"Enough," Cyril said once, catching me in a stumble and setting me gently on the grass. "Table manners, Joanna."
"That's three times," he added in a whisper of a voice that was colder than the morning sun. "Table manners, Joanna. Be careful."
"You're kind," I told Luisa later. She smiled with teeth tight as a trap. "He is gentle because he has been taught not to break fine things."
"It will be fine," she said. "Make him want you."
I practiced wanting nothing. I wanted everything.
One moonlit night, Marina and I crept to the pear tree in the garden that touched the boundary of their house. The pears were fat and cold with moonlight. I picked one and bit, sour on my tongue.
"Ugh," Marina said, coughing. "Miss, it's bitter."
"It's a pear," I said and ate more. I had not had fruit like that in years. My stomach had learned hunger as a companion.
"I wish you could run," Marina said. "Go back to our city. Find a husband who is kind."
"I can't," I said. "No papers. No path. Here is our ladder."
I climbed the tree despite Marina's warnings. I remember thinking of the way the branches caught light like hair on a woman's head. I remember the drop, and then the sudden hold of arms.
He had been watching. "Again," he said, low and almost playful. "You will break something if you keep doing this."
"Table manners," I said, huffing, and the world tilted.
He steadied me and our faces were close—too close. "You are light," he murmured.
"My foot slipped," I told him. I tried to smile guilty, foolish. He did not smile. He stared at me.
"Stay down," he said, and then he did something no one expected: he kissed me.
The kiss was not soft. It was honest and quick and left me dizzy. I tasted pear and something bitter and the way the air felt when a storm will come.
"I'm sorry," I stammered, pulling back. "You are a gentleman. I am nothing."
He looked at me like a man looking at a secret map. "You are not nothing," he said. "Be careful of your pranks."
When I fell into his arms, the whole world flipped and rearranged itself. I thought to run away, to make my scheme turn the other way. But his hold was quieter than any scheme I had. I froze.
"Don't make this messy," he murmured. He was the kind who said very few things but meant a whole rain.
I went home flustered, and Luisa looked at me as though I had been a puppet in a bad play.
"Did it work?" she asked, sharp as a needle.
"It might," I lied. "He kissed me. He is not cruel."
"Then keep going," Luisa said. "Make him see you. Make him want you."
I pretended to be light. I pretended to laugh as I pinned bright bows into my hair. The house ladies laughed at me behind their hands, and their laughter made me a smaller thing.
One morning, I woke dizzy and faint. My head spun and I could not understand the room. A cloth smelled sweet and foreign. I tried to leave and could not. I heard a footstep, and he—Cyril—opened the door and looked at me.
"Who is sick?" he asked, with that flat voice no one could tame.
"I don't know," I croaked. "I thought it would pass."
"Come with me," he said. "You shouldn't be alone like this."
I tried to move and failed. He lifted me like a basket and carried me to his room. The world blurred into lacquer and warm steam.
"Drink," he said, and they set a bowl of white porridge before me. He sat and read. I was ashamed, and ashamed of being saved. I said the only thing a proud woman can say: "I am not someone's kept thing. I will not be a hidden name."
His hand reached and tugged my chin. "I never thought to make you a kept thing," he said, softer than any other voice had been.
"Then why do you keep me?" I whispered.
"Because you are the only face I have not learned yet," he said. "Because you are honest in your tricks."
I swallowed my pride with the porridge. "I will leave soon," I told him, the lie sharp as a coin. "I will go back to find a husband with silver."
He didn't answer. Instead he watched me until I finished every spoonful. For the first time, someone who could have looked away watched.
"Eat well," he said.
That was a kindness he had no right to give me, and it sent warmth along my spine that lasted a week.
He left for a posting beyond the river, and I told myself I would be relieved. Yet every day my throat ached at his name. He came back, suddenly, one night when the lantern smoke had gone thin and the rain edged the eaves. He came like a storm.
"Joanna," he said without preface. He held out his cloak. He took me under his arm and carried me away from the man who thought to make me his plaything.
"Let her go," Gwendal Taylor said, standing in the doorway of a room crowded with men who had more pride than control.
"She is mine," Cyril said.
"She is not dirt to be stolen," Gwendal answered with a grin like a blade. "She is company."
"She is mine," Cyril repeated, and in the way he said it the world shifted again.
I learned then that men who claim you can also shield you. I also learned they can be dangerous.
When Cyril carried me back to his rooms, he held me like a thing he would protect.
"Why did you do that?" I asked in the flicker of lamps.
"Because you were in a place I find obscene," he said. "Because you looked helpless."
"Do you think me helpless?" I said.
"No," he answered quietly. "I think you are dangerous for your honesty."
Dangerous. I liked the word because it suited me now. It meant I mattered.
But Luisa did not give up her plans. She moved me like a token, setting me before men to see where I might land.
"Do not say trouble," Marina begged me one evening. "I cannot watch you be sold."
"I will not be sold," I said. "I will choose."
And yet, when news came that a petty prince—Gwendal—had his eye on me, Luisa smiled like a cat with too many mice.
"Opportunity," she said. "A side seat in wealth is better than none."
I let her carry my feet into gilded rooms. I let myself be dressed so fine I hardly felt like me.
Then the night came when I thought I had seen the end of me. In a private garden, Gwendal's hand came to my waist and moved with an animal's right. I froze. The world caught itself in a small, sharp noise.
"Let go of her," the voice said like iron.
Cyril stood in the doorway, wet with the rain, like someone who had been carved out of stone. He swept off his cloak, put it over me, and carried me as before. His face was a map of something old and terrible.
"She is mine," he said not to Gwendal this time, but as if claiming a lost piece of himself.
Gwendal flushed red with anger and pride, then pretended a laugh. "You would fight me for a woman of trade?"
"She is mine," Cyril said again.
"And who are you to claim her?" Gwendal snarled. "A family man with duties. A son of a house."
"She is not your toy," Cyril said. "She is not to be bought."
The words were small swords. The prince stumbled. He could not fight a man who had truth at the center of him.
"Leave us," Cyril ordered.
Gwendal left grudgingly, but his anger did not end.
Later, in a room warmed by an oil lamp and wet with rain, he pushed me to a bed and then started to press kisses into a punishment that was not for me.
"Stop," I cried. "Don't make me your secret."
He tightened his hand. "You have been with my men," he hissed. "You owe me what others owe me."
"Never." I spat the word.
He laughed like a man who has had many things. I bit him. I tore the right of him with my mouth. The taste of copper and pride filled me.
He stumbled back, more shocked than hurt. "You little—" he gasped.
Cyril sat up, eyes sharp as knives. "Who taught you to bite?" he demanded, but there was no anger now, only a strange, guarded wonder.
"Who told you to touch me like I was a prize?" I shot back.
He did not answer. He could not. He had declared I was his and then had to bear the truth of whose bed I had been in. He was a man forced to feel.
"You will not be another man's secret," he said in a voice softer than the storm. "I will make you mine, properly."
"Make me your wife?" I asked, incredulous.
"I want you for more than a night," he said. "I want you for always."
I laughed at him for a long time, a sharp, ugly sound, then wept, then let him fold his arms around me. "You are serious?"
"As the river is long," he said. "If you will say yes."
"I am not simple to present," I warned. "Your house will not be pleased."
"Then I will make them," he said.
He did make them.
First his mother, Emilia Makarov, visited as if borne on spring wind. She sat like a sovereign and offered kindness like a command.
"Joanna," she said, taking my hands, "there is no shame in a good match. You have the look of a woman who will be steady."
"You will accept me?" I asked in a whisper.
"She is not of our station," Luisa said later, as if she had been wounded by the turn of events. "We will be a laughingstock."
"Then let them laugh," Cyril's mother said. "I will not stand for my son to be told he cannot choose who he loves."
In less than a season we were married while the bridesmaids made faces and the lawyers signed papers. I wore my red hood and pretended not to tremble.
Years passed like soft cloth being folded.
Then the winter the world almost ended, the emperor was stabbed in the street. Cyril stepped forward and took a knife meant for a king.
He fell with a scream that lived in the room like a chill. The poison in the blade ate at him. He coughed black blood and the air tasted like iron. They told me to leave. They told me to sit. His life was in pieces on a table.
"Please, just some of the medicine," I begged. "Do not—"
"Joanna," he whispered, and his voice was a thread. "If I go, take what is in my box. It is registered in your name. There is a paper to free you if you want to go."
"Go," I said like a bell. "What are you talking about?"
"Take what can be yours," he said. "Do not be trapped here. I cannot promise everything. But if I die—"
"Don't say that," I said, a stupid plea.
He looked and said with slow strength, "You must be free. If I die, I ask you not to stay where my name is a chain."
I took the papers he gave me and broke them into pieces between my hands in the silence that only two people who love each other know. I refused them. I refused his offer of exit.
"You cannot make me leave," I said. "I will not be a woman who runs."
The morning after, the fever broke. His color returned like dawn. He coughed and then smiled, weak as a candle, and said, "Tell me you love me."
"I do," I said, and the whole house listened because the word found itself a place in the world and refused to move. "I love you."
Years passed. I learned the heavy kindness of being someone's wife and learned to give it back. People who had mocked me stopped laughing. The house that had once sniffed at our union lost its footing.
But Luisa never forgave. She wanted to sell me, to string me up on men until I paid her price. When she saw that failing, she turned venomous.
One day, at the Spring Market, I stood with Cyril at my side and watched as Luisa moved among the crowd like a moth with sharp wings. She had sold our story and tried to stitch it into something ugly. I thought of Marina's scared face and the nights I had been drugged in a temple. I thought of all the times she twisted my life like a ribbon.
"I will not be silent," I said.
"Do you want me to speak?" Cyril asked, his hand near mine, fingers warmed.
"I will speak," I said.
We had arranged little: a small stall near the fountain where the city merchants came to show their goods. The market was busy and the crowd generous with eyes. We had invited a few friends—Emilia among them—and a few enemies. I watched Luisa across the square with her head held like a queen, satisfaction written on her face.
I called to her, "Mother, come here."
She turned, and the crowd turned with her.
"You look well," she said, with that smile that had no kindness. "Have you been making friends at the market?"
"Yes," I said. My voice did not shake. "Would you like a seat? You have done me so many favors."
Luisa came forward, curiosity lighting her features. "What are you doing?" she asked to the crowd.
"Just telling the truth," Cyril said. He had stepped close, hand on my shoulder.
I met Luisa's eyes and felt every slight she had given me fold into a small, cold stone in my stomach. "You put something in my kerchief at the temple," I said, loud enough that the cloth sellers paused in their bargaining. "You used a powder from a trader and told me I was traveling with you. You told men lies about me. You offered me for a position with a fifty-year-old official."
"That's—" Luisa started, color draining from her face.
"You drugged me," I said, and the words spread like oil on water. "You left me in a guest room, and when I woke you were gone. You told our neighbors that I had been with that man. You told merchants I had been traded."
A murmur rose. People drew closer.
"I have proof," I said. From my sleeve I drew a folded paper. It was a list of payments—merchant names, dates, notes like receipts from a room in the temple. "These are receipts from the trader you met with. These are notes you let fall into the hands of those who wished to buy me for a night."
The crowd gasped. I saw Marina's face turn pale and then proud.
Luisa's face contorted. She took a step back as if someone had struck her. "Lies," she said, and her voice cracked. "You are trying to shame me."
"Listen," I said. "Look at these names." I held the list up so the sun flashed off it. "This is your handwriting."
It was. I had traced it in small, quiet moments—enough to know the curve of her t's. People in the market leaned in. The woman who sold tea set down her tray and stared.
Cyril moved forward then. "You told the Prince that Joanna was available to you," he said. "You told him she was a woman who could be bought. You told the city she had no family. You stopped no one from calling her a thing to be taken."
"That is a lie," Luisa cried. She tried to raise her voice and find sympathy. "This girl has turned everyone against me."
"Look at her face," I said. "See Marina?" I pointed to my maid. Marina came forward, shaking but steady, and held up something from her pocket: a small square of cloth with a faint scent of the powder and a smear of the name of the trader.
"You thought you could buy men with coins and make me smaller," Marina said. "You took my mistress to the temple and left her like a crate of goods."
A silence settled like dust. People whispered, then shouted. "What kind of woman does this?" someone cried. "How cruel!"
Luisa's face went through stages: first shock, then fury, then denial. She lifted her chin high. "You're lying," she hissed. "I did nothing."
"Tell them," I said. "You sold my name to the prince. You tried to push me into an old man's house."
She staggered. The crowd pressed closer. A man in a bright robe—a merchant who had known Luisa's family—said, "She has been known to bargain with more than cloth."
I felt the air change. Where once I had been a thing to bargain, I became the woman who had spoken the truth. People took sides.
The magistrate, who had been passing markets that day, heard the outcry and came over. He looked at the documents I had shown and then at Luisa. "Luisa Bertrand," he said loud enough for all, "you stand accused of deceit, of drugging, and of trafficking a woman under false pretenses."
"That's not the law we use for ladies," someone stammered, unsure.
"It is the law for crimes," the magistrate snapped. "We will take testimony now."
They took Marina first; she told them how Luisa had bought the powder in the market and had left us in the temple. She told them about the offers Luisa had made to men to take Joanna away. People cried out in outrage.
Luisa's face went from bravado to pale to a kind of fury that made her look like a wild thing. "You will not disgrace me!" she screamed. "You will not take my name!"
"Shame!" called a woman. "You thought you could make a living off shame. See how shame returns!"
Men in the square pointed. Lantern boys pulled out crude recording tablets and began to copy the words. Someone started clapping. The crowd's voice turned from curiosity to condemnation.
Luisa fell through stages: she first tried to stay proud and deny. Then she tried to bargain. "I was only looking for my daughter's future," she said, and her voice broke. "I had to save our house!"
"No," I said. "You tried to sell me. You sold me like a piece of cloth."
She lunged at me then, hands like claws. "You ungrateful—"
Cyril stepped forward and caught her arm with the gentlest force and set her down like a child. His eyes were steel. "You will not touch her," he said. "You have humiliated her enough."
The magistrate sentenced Luisa to public restitution: she must sign a public confession, she must pay for the temple offerings she cost, and she must publicly apologize in the market square for seven days. People would be allowed to say what they wished. She would lose favor and patronage.
The punishment was not meant to ruin her life; the law had mercy. But the crowd's judgment was harsher than any magistrate. Women spat on the ground where she had stood. Men refused her trade. Friends walked away.
Her face crumpled under the weight of their scorn. "I—" she began. "I didn't—"
"No," Marina said. "You did."
Luisa moved through the stages I had been told about when a person's public image falls apart. At first she was proud. Then shock. Then a frantic denial. She tried to climb back but the crowd's eyes would not let her.
"I will not be made into a spectacle," she wailed, and then she started to cry, real and raw and nothing like the measured smiles she had practiced.
People took out small tablets and wrote down her confession. Children pointed. The tea seller spat into the gutter. A woman who had once taken in Luisa's son stepped forward and slapped her hard across the face.
"How could you?" she shouted. "For money, you gambled with another person's life!"
The slap echoed in the market square like a verdict.
Luisa scrambled away and fell to her knees. She begged. She crawled. She tried to find the sympathy she had once harvested so easily from others. None came.
"People!" someone cried. "Let the law be done."
The magistrate read his verdict aloud. Luisa was ordered to stand and publicly read the confession. She trembled with the paper in her fingers. As she read, the words fell from her mouth like old coins.
"I took advantage of Joanna Chandler's helplessness," she read. "I acted for my profit. I am sorry."
The grieving son of a merchant spit in her direction. Someone else called for the law to take more. They would not get it. The law had margins. The crowd had teeth.
When Luisa's reading ended, the crowd hissed like a storm leaving. She had been reduced from someone with influence to someone whom people would avoid in the street. Her friends broke away and refused to speak. Her trades sank. The house that she had intended to lift with me looked at her as a finger to point at and a lesson.
Luisa wept openly and, for a while, was a creature of public contempt. She fell into the last stage—broken and pleading.
"Cyril," she said, looking up, "please."
He did not approach. He set his hand on my shoulder and led me away.
I watched her shoulders slump, watched her grasp the remnants of a life she had thought safe. The market started to return to its old business. The vendors shouted again. The pigeons scattered.
Marina bowed to me and said nothing. Later she told me, with a small smile, "Do you know what the people said? 'You made the bed, now lie in the market.'"
I laughed. It felt cruel and right.
The punishment had been public, long, and clean. Luisa had been reduced from a predator to a woman who could offer nothing but apology. She had gone through the motions: pride, shock, denial, bargaining, breakdown. The crowd had reacted with horror, then with fury, and then with a kind of satisfaction I had not known I could feel. She had become a lesson and a cautionary tale.
After that, people started to look at me differently. Not as a trick or a pawn, but as a woman who had teeth and who had told the truth.
"Cyril," I said one night, in the quiet that followed the storm, "why did you stand with me?"
He looked at me over a cup of hot tea. "Because I do not like liars," he said, simply. "Because I like you."
"Because I bit a man who touched me?" I teased.
"Because you were brave," he answered. "And because when you cried, you did not ask for my pity. You asked to be seen."
I pressed my forehead to his and felt that the answer I had sought for years had finally come home.
We stayed married. He recovered from the poisoned wound and continued to stand by me. We made a life that was not perfect, because lives are not, but it was ours, built out of a pear tree fall and a bookshop of quiet mornings and the stomping anger of a marketplace.
"Stay," he said once, when the wind slammed the shutters and the rain wrote thin lines on the window. "Stay with me."
"I will," I said. I did not promise forever like some empty coin. I promised then, in a voice like a bell. I promised the small, important things.
I was no longer a woman who made herself small to climb. I was someone who had climbed and cut the rope, and I kept the ladder for myself.
The End
— Thank you for reading —