Rebirth13 min read
The Heart I Dug Out for Him
ButterPicks18 views
I first learned the feel of my own ribs the way others learn to read—by touch, by habit, by repetition until the shock dulls.
"Show me," Findlay said in the dream again, and I laughed because the words had become a ritual between us: a way for him to prove I wouldn't betray him, and for me to prove that there was nothing left I wouldn't give.
I do not look like people imagine. I do not look like those pretty heroines for whom lanterns are hung and songs are written. When I was born—stitched from too many things, a patchwork of fox, spider, snake, wolf, rabbit—my first world was a narrow cave smelling of damp straw and old incense. A mad cultivator made me as experiment and trophy; he fed me the viscera of other low-rank spirits and taught me to dread the day he would harvest whatever part of me made his pills potent.
"You're an abomination," the cultivator used to say. "A mold for immortality." He never thought of me as a person.
Findlay found me the night my cave door flew open. He cut through men and moons alike by the way he carried light—half ember, half frost. He stood at the mouth of the cave with a fan in one hand and a smile that was not meant for me, and he said, "What are you?"
I could not answer. I crawled into the blackest corner and watched the world through the whites of my eyes. He stepped in. The cultivator shouted and cursed, and when the last swing fell, the world had room for one more heartbeat.
He carried me home like a curiosity.
"Lexi," he named me later, when the syllables had been ground smooth by years. "Lexi Henderson. It means... crossing hardship." The name did not fit the shape of me any better than his unexpected kindness fit inside that huge, stern chest. But I accepted it because names give people reasons to spend themselves on you.
For hundreds of years he taught me to be what he liked. "Don't stand like a beast. Don't bare your hair before strangers. Learn to speak when you want to be understood." He plucked out the worst edges of me with patience and with the quick, bright sting of his power. He fed me pills that smoothed my bones. He fed me lessons. Once I could stand on hills and look like a person, the wolves and foxes and lesser spirits stopped recoiling.
Once I could be a woman in front of him, I believed I would be enough.
He loved spectacle. He liked the way things looked when they were arranged. For a time, arranging me on his arm, teaching me jokes that made his mouth do things I only ever saw then, was a game we both played.
Then Loretta came.
She was a flare. She was the phoenix everyone whispered about as a living hymn. The first time I saw Loretta Atkins in her full flame-form—her feathers like rivers of live light falling from the wutong trees—I forgot how to breathe. She laughed the way a bell splits sound; she cried the way embers learn to fall. She was bright and unshy and every compliment she ever gave him was a coin Findlay didn’t know how to refuse.
"Cut her feather for me," he said to me once, smiling that half-smile I had learned to read like dawn. "I will make it into a brush for you."
I did not like her. I envied the way she poured herself into the world and was always met with echoes. I envied the way Findlay's corners softened around her light. I told myself I did not mind. I told myself she would pass like a comet does, leaving only the faintest trail.
Loretta changed things because of the way the world moved around a godly songbird. She had a phrase in her voice that made promises sound like they had been written by heaven: "If you pluck my tail, you must wed me," she told him in courtly tilt and song. And he—stupid in ways only those who have not been burned can be—listened.
They were married with all the fireworks the three realms could muster. The immortal court and lesser spirits came to see the show—weddings are a variety of battle, and every eye is another witness. The whole valley glittered. I stood on the edge of the crowd and watched the ceremony shrink around me.
Then Loretta thrust a blade into Findlay's back.
"Why?" I asked later, when the visions of flame still smoked behind my lids. I could not say the word betrayal without the taste of iron.
"They say she killed herself afterwards," one old phoenix's elder coughed when he was captured later. "She cut her throat and sank into the river of light. Her soul scattered."
Findlay went hollow at the mouth. He went quiet. He came back to me as an ember washed in ash. He held a scrap of Loretta's feather—she had turned it into a chain at the wedding, and he wore it like a wound—and he said, very simply, "Bring her back."
"Did you ever think," I asked him, "that she might have loved you? That someone pushed her?"
"Does it matter?" he said. His eyes were cold. They had become small and sharp, like knives kept in the sleeve.
What matters, after hundreds of years of serving you, after nights where I dug until shovels bent with the scraping of my hands, after you used my life as a mortar for your hope? You expect me to take one more cut and not crack. You think my blood is a well that never empties.
He had asked me a thousand times to prove the truth of my love. He would ask again and again, because once a god has been pierced by what he thought was love, he cannot bear the possibility of being fooled again. In his cracked chest the suspicion takes root and flowers into cruelty.
"Show me," he would say. "Show me entirely."
My answer was always the same. I reached into my own body and took out one of the small, thrumming hearts that kept me alive. I learned the exactness of that pain. A heart appears pink and fat and new when it is whole; mine were always the wrong color, or too many, or too tender. When I held the warm organ in my palm, blood dripping into the dirt like a trembling red rain, his face would smooth like a lake.
"You are sure?" he would murmur, and I would nod because words and nodding are cheaper than the thing I was giving.
Five hundred years is a number you can count on your fingers, and in those five hundred years I learned how to die a little every day.
People tell stories about my endurance as if it's a glorious thing. They call me loyal. They say my suffering made a legend. They say it as though it was once and finished. But the truth is a slow erosion. There is a threshold where pain breaks beyond language and becomes a kind of white wisdom; I walked that threshold many times.
On the day he found out Loretta had truly died—bones of rumor laid bare—he turned to the chain at his wrist like someone trying to find the pattern of a wound.
"She left a sliver of soul in this," he said. "We can feed it. We can weave it back."
"You want me to stretch what is left of me," I said. "You already used half my life."
"I only asked—" he stopped. "I only need your help one more time."
I heard the trembling in his voice like a confession or a command. It made no difference. I had been given life by him; I repaid with death. I said yes because the reason for saying yes was not a bargain. I said yes because I remembered the first sunrise he ever handed to me, and because the thought of leaving him in that half-dark was a knife I could not bear.
He tied me down neatly. That part he always did: the neatness made him feel like he could control the violence. He cut me with a calm that belongs to surgeons and executioners. He took the bright seed from my chest, and when he held it near Loretta's chain it flushed and paled in the same moment.
"Please," I whispered one time that I remember, because the mouth wants to speak into a mouth. "Findlay, did you mean when you once—"
"When I promised to marry you?" he closed his hand on the chain and did not let it go. "I said a hundred things in a hundred nights. I do not know which ones were promises and which were courtesies."
He was not cruel without reason. He had been burned. He became a man who measured all flame by its bite.
I left. I could not be cut further. I did not want to die in his neat hands. I crawled from under him when the moon was thin and the world smelled of iron and dust, and I ran because fleeing felt like the only honest thing left to do.
When I walked away, it was to the human road where one could bury the past in a different language. Someone who called himself James Thomas found me. "Lexi," he said as if reciting a blessing. He held me while the fever burned out of bones. He sewed me up with thread that smelled of sage and patience. He was not a great immortal. He was a good man, if a mortal.
"Why help me?" I asked, mouth still tasting of blood.
"Because you asked for it once," he told me. "Because debts are strange and sometimes they pay themselves back when we aren't looking."
He kept his word across lifetimes. He was the kind of person who would keep coming back to the places he'd always done a little good. A hundred years later, a hundred and another, he appeared again like a map's recurring rhyme. He called himself by the same name, and I believed he had never really changed.
We walked human roads together. He taught me to buy fish at noon markets and to laugh at the small indignities of human life. For the first time in centuries my chest did not ache with the specific knowledge that another hand would cut it open tomorrow. For the first time I wept for other things: for the memory of the cave, for the way Findlay's face had gone empty, for the wrongness of loving someone who made you into a well.
We did not know then that the world rearranged itself for us.
When Findlay rose again—resurrected, reassembled from the single wisp I had risked everything to save—he was not the same man the world once feared. He was less than his former terror, and yet, in the hollow of his gaze, something had taken root that made the same old questions bloom into a monstrous need.
"You really loved me?" he asked after waking. He asked as if hunger were a test.
"Yes," I said, and did what I always did. I took my heart out.
He watched, and in the watching he allowed himself to trust. Maybe that was the thing he could not allow himself before. Maybe that was the thing he needed to become what he thought he must be.
He stood in the middle of the valley a different kind of ruler. His justice had edges now. He was kinder to some, crueler to others. The covens and clans bent, but where they once bowed, now many only stepped lightly, wondering which emotion—fear or love—held them to his skirts.
On my wedding night—an odd thing, yes—he had arranged that I choose a mate to appease the court. "Pick anyone," he told me with that soft twist of his mouth. "Even if you pick a dog, it will be for a season."
I tried the ritual. I chose a wolf, because in a world that demands displays, one can refuse the show. The wolf was graceless and hungry, and the night became the place where a wrong hand found my waist and tried to undo the old boundaries.
"Stop," I hissed, and the man—wolf spirit, really—slapped me while the room watched like it had seen such things and decided the fun had begun.
"You will not touch her," Findlay said as he pushed through the crowd. He crushed the wolf with one foot. He wrapped me in his cloak and flew with me until night smelled of dew and our skin prickled from wind.
Later, when the wolves and lesser spirits made jokes that I could hear in passing, he did something that people still talk about. He took that aggressor and put him in the center of the Great Hollow—the market of punishments where everyone is a witness. There was a crowd—dozens, then hundreds—curious beasts lining the escarpments and the wooden stalls, gathering like carrion around the spectacle of shame.
"Who gave you the right to strike her?" Findlay asked, each word a measured stone.
The wolf sneered. "She belongs to the court now. We do as the court says."
"Do you?" Findlay smiled, the expression of a knife being sharpened. "Come. Tell the valley what you did."
They brought in the wolf on a small dais. Loretta's feather-chain hung from Findlay's wrist like the last ember of a summer. The foxes and badgers and lesser sprites leaned forward. I felt the air tighten like a net.
"You took her," Findlay said. "You struck her for being a woman standing in her wedding. You thought the law would hide you."
The wolf barked. "You are a king. Who will punish a soldier for following orders?"
"Then we will make a spectacle," Findlay said. "We will not let cowardice hide in crowded places."
He unfastened the wolf, and then something happened that would be spoken of for generations: he ordered, in the middle of the market, that the wolf's rank be stripped. "Every ribbon you have earned," Findlay said, "will be burned. Every favor you have held will be displayed at your feet. Those who have ever laughed with you will stand and name the times they took pleasure in your violence."
The crowd gasped, because in that world shame is a currency and public shame is a fatal interest rate. One by one, the wolf's acquaintances—shrunken stoats, a bearded badger who had once eaten a neighbor's harvest, a fox who had been saved by the wolf's claws—stepped forward. They told short stories: how the wolf had mocked a widow, how he had broken a fisher-lad's arm for a stolen fish, how he had laughed when a young sprite was beaten for loving wrong.
"How many?" Findlay asked when the last of them had finished. "How many of you cheered when she was hurt?"
The crowd, a living thing between their feet and the sky, murmured and shifted. The shame that rose was heavier than any iron; it was the accumulation of a thousand small cruelties laid bare.
The wolf's face, pale under his ruff, folded. He tried to speak; his voice came out like the whine of a trapped thing. "I—I only followed orders—"
"Then you will follow orders now," Findlay said. "You will stand here with these names pinned to your chest. You will sing them until your throat breaks. You will feel what it is to be exposed."
So the wolf sang. He sang every small cruelty as others had named it. At first some in the crowd laughed—cruel things are often made of small pleasures. But laughter fades, and shame burns. The wolf's voice trembled into sobs. He tried to deny one after another, but witnesses were there—those whose hands had ached with the work of the world and who had seen things done.
When he begged, the plea hung thin in the air. People began to take out their charms and pictures and documents; they wrote down names of his favors and hung them on the posts. "He must return what he took," an old badger declared. "He must help the ones he hurt."
The punishment lasted for hours. At the end the wolf's possessions were given to those he had wronged—clay pots and small terracotta coins and a child's broken wooden horse. They were poor things. The humiliation had nothing to do with the value; its force came from the crowd and the naming.
That night, when they bound the wolf to a tree and he crouched there like a defeated thing, his face had changed through stages: first smirk, then surprise, then denial, then brokenness. People took their pictures—others recorded with shard-glass—but the most painful part was later, when he came to the center and asked for forgiveness and the ones he had hurt stepped away. They would not accept his hand. They put his plea on the wind like a paper note and left it to the crows.
I watched, and I was furious in a way that is costly and clear. Not because the wolf had been hurt, but because it took so long in our world for a wrong to be named and for the wrong-doer to feel what he'd made others feel. I watched because once I had been the one exposed and no one had cared.
Findlay came to me after the crowd broke. He touched the scar on my chest with a gentleness that surprised me.
"I cannot unmake what I asked of you," he said. "But I will not let anyone touch you like that again."
"Then what are you now?" I asked. "A king with a softer blade? A tyrant who calls himself tender?"
He did not answer, except to lift his chin and show me the feather-chain at his wrist. "I wanted Loretta back," he said. "Do you think I wanted to hurt you? I thought bringing her back would solve the ache. I thought—"
Findlay was a man whose compass had been rearranged by grief. I loved him for the way he could be gentle; I feared him for the way his fear could become a net.
In the years that followed, many things happened I could not have guessed. I met James Thomas again and again in the same village where he carried a white fox that followed him. Sometimes he would be a miller, sometimes a small-town apothecary. Each time his eyes held the same patient kindness. He died a small natural death in one life and in another he bent over my bed and breathed into me when fever made my lungs a harsh thing. He told me once, with the naive bravery of a man who had learned the right thing by practice, "You are allowed to be hurt and to be mended."
We had quiet days—ironical and fragile. Findlay went to war on memory and on the heavens, and sometimes he came to the hut where James and I had set up, and would look at me from a distance like a man trying to remember which parts of his map belonged to whom.
In the end, what saved any of us was small and ridiculous. Loretta's feather-chain—the last thing he wore and the thing he would wade through blood for—became a puzzle that I could help him solve. We could not bring Loretta back fully; the gods had decreed her fate. But James—who knew the ways of human craft and human superstition—helped me braid the chain into a new token. We made something honest and small: a charm that held a memory, not a whole being.
Findlay saw it and wept like a man who had forgotten how to do small things like breathing. "Lexi," he said once when we sat beside the river and the willow leaves met the water like writing, "I asked you a hundred times for your heart. But I never asked you what you wanted."
"I wanted," I said simply, "to stop being a story about sacrifice."
He looked at me like a man hearing a foreign word and then recognizing it. "And do you still love me?"
"I loved you first," I said, "before you were a crown and a wound. But loving is not a bill you can cash forever. It is a choice each morning."
In the end—because endings cannot be set by design but only by the tide—the world made its odd bargain. James aged as men do; his bones filled with the good kind of tired. Findlay stayed and reformed in some ways and did not in others. The wolf who had struck me learned the cost of spectacle. Loretta's story became a caution and a hymn. I kept my scars. I kept the taste of blood in my mouth like a spice.
We took to living small in a world that still expected our epics. Sometimes I would go to the market and sell trinkets, and sometimes Findlay would stand across the stall with his arms folded and his face unreadable, and Loretta's feather-chain would catch the sun and glance it away into nothing.
One day, when the winds had rearranged the leaves into a pattern I could read, I saw a small white fox at the edge of the lane. The fox looked like a scrap of cloud. I remembered James' fox and the way it had nudged him, and I smiled because I knew that some things travel in circles. Findlay came and stood beside me silently, and for once there were no tests, no demands.
"Do you remember when you first told me to show you my heart?" I asked.
He did not answer at once. Then, very softly, "I remember you taking it out like someone offering a story," he said. "And I remember I used it to write my wrongs."
I laughed, a small bright sound. The sound carried. The feather-chain at his wrist glinted, and for a moment the world felt like glass—thin, trembling—but whole enough to hold our reflection.
We never had the great triumphant epiphany. Instead, we had a hundred moments stitched together: a market-bought fish, a fox at a temple gate, a public naming that taught a predator to be ashamed, a pair of hands that finally learned the difference between taking and asking.
At the river the feather-chain lay in the palm of my hand. Its links were no longer a prison but a measure. I twisted it once and felt the ghost of Loretta's laugh and the shadow of her last look. I let it slip back into Findlay's hand.
"Keep it," I said. "Not to bind, but to remember."
He closed his fingers around it and nodded. "I will," he said.
When I lay down to sleep that night, the scar at my chest still smarted sometimes, and my palms sometimes remembered the weight of a heart. I thought of James, who had been a thousand humble kinds of hero, and of the wolf in the market, and of Loretta, burning like a comet.
I understood at last that my life did not belong solely to those who took from it. It belonged to me—a patchwork being who had been made from other people's experiments and had chosen, again and again, to be nobody's ledger.
I closed my eyes. In the dark my hands found the space where another heart might one day grow. I smiled like a person who has kept a secret long enough to make of it a truth.
The End
— Thank you for reading —