Sweet Romance13 min read
The Grey Tie on the Pink Bed
ButterPicks10 views
"I found a man's tie on your bed."
The words landed like a pebble into my pink duvet and rippled straight through the quiet living room.
Kaylie Alvarado held up the grey tie between two fingers, squinting as if the fabric itself might confess a name. The tie looked almost obscene against the bubblegum sheets—too mature, too smooth, too deliberate.
"It looks familiar," Valentina Booth said from the sofa, peeking over her phone.
My phone started to buzz at the same second. I swallowed and answered it with my whole face trying to stay casual.
"Yesterday I left my tie at your place," Greyson Heinrich said, his voice low and confident and threaded with that kind of velvet you can't help leaning into. "I'll come by later to pick it up."
I closed my eyes, let the ceiling blur, then muttered into the phone, "Don't. Kaylie is here."
"Okay," he replied, and even his "okay" sounded like a kiss.
I hung up and typed, with my thumbs that suddenly felt clumsy, a message: Don't come, Kaylie's at mine.
Kaylie looked at me. "So—you have a boyfriend?"
I almost laughed. "Kaylie, we promised to be single forever."
"You lied to me," she said like it was the end of the world, and her little face squinted into two accusing slits.
"I—"
The truth was simple and sharp. I had not meant to be anyone's girlfriend. I hadn't meant to hand over my nights to anyone, but Greyson Heinrich had a way of making everything small look safe. He had wide shoulders, a narrow waist, legs that seemed to go on forever. He smiled like he meant sentences more than just words. He was older, yes—older enough for "uncle" jokes when people couldn't say his name without swallowing—but he didn't feel like an uncle to me. He felt like a place to land.
"You're a traitor," Kaylie declared, dramatic as the soap operas we used to watch in college.
"I—" I had no defense that wouldn't sound like selfishness. "I like him."
"Of course you like him," Valentina said from the sofa, eyes soft. "He's the kind of trouble you should be warned about."
"You two are ridiculous," Kaylie said, tossing the tie like it was a relic. "If you're dating him, you're my enemy."
He arrived forty minutes later with shopping bags and the weightless arrogance of someone who always expected doors to open for him.
"Hi, Greyson," Kaylie said, as if he were a normal visitor and not the reason a tie was draped over my pillow. "Did you bring food?"
"Hello, Kaylie," he said, and his voice dropped in warmth in a way that made my ribcage feel like a birdcage. "I brought something for us to cook. Olive, basil—your favorites."
I helped him carry groceries into the kitchen. He edged close to me, his scent like cedar and lemon soap.
"Does your wrist still bruise?" he murmured.
I pushed away and looked at Kaylie. She was halfway across the room, eyes trained on the TV. Good. She had no idea what we were about to do.
Greyson lowered his head and kissed me before I could protest. I slapped his shoulder hard.
"Greyson, Kaylie's here!"
He only smirked, unfazed. "I know."
Kaylie wandered into the kitchen, bewildered. "What's going on?"
"Get a bottle of vinegar," Greyson ordered, pointing, then watched her go with the kind of fond twist a man gives a pet he owns.
Kaylie came back with a bottle, and Greyson sent her downstairs to fetch something else. The door closed with a neat click.
He turned to me, eyes bright. "I like this tie on you."
I wanted to be clever, so I said, "I think your skin tones flatter mine better."
He laughed like the world had been set right, and, like all the silly, dangerous things he did, that laugh wrapped around me and didn't let go.
That night on my pink bed, he tied the tie around my wrist and called it a bow. He said it looked like a promise.
The next morning his smile was patient and dangerous. "Do you want a day off? I can arrange it."
"You can arrange me a promotion, too," I told him. "Secretary head. Same pay. I can do more."
He kissed me. "That post is too heavy for you."
"Greyson, I am capable."
"You are," he said, soft. "But I would hate to see you burned out."
"Is that concern or control?"
"You don't have to choose," he said, and then he kissed the question away.
At work, Valentina slipped a stack of files to me. "How do you get him to give you the light stuff?"
"You know," I said, "he has his favorites."
"You're his favorite," Valentina said, too easily. Co-workers murmured, "The boss treats Hana like family." My face got hot.
"Come to my office," Greyson's voice said from behind the glass partition, and my heart misfired.
He pinned me gently to the door of his office. "Still sulking?"
I twisted. "You made me come in here for coffee."
"Why didn't you bring it?" he asked, amused.
"Because you sent another assistant."
He took my hand and kissed the back of it. "Tell me what you want."
"A chance."
"A promotion," he guessed, smiling razor-bright.
"Yes."
"You're asking the wrong way." He rested his forehead on mine. "Marry me and I'll sign any papers you want."
I laughed, even though I didn't mean it. "You're impossible."
He was, and he was mine in a way that made me dizzy. He wrapped his arms around me like a cage and a cradle in one.
I tried to be practical. "You can't ask me to marry you."
"I didn't ask," Greyson said. "I offered."
Later Kaylie called. "Get ready. We're going out," she said. "Taiming's birthday."
I remembered then a boy who had once liked Kaylie. Brody Lopez, tall and earnest and easy with his jokes. He'd been the friend we all nudged toward Kaylie, and now Kaylie's call was wrapped in some mixture of excitement and guilt.
"We're going to a bar," Kaylie announced in the car. "Buy something nice."
She insisted I let her card pay. "It's my money too," she said, as if that excuse could hide anything.
At the bar Kaylie got drunk. She yelled at me to dance, to kiss boys, to be foolish like we used to be. I remember a blur of neon and the way Brody's hand brushed hers. I remember Kaylie's phone and a flurry of messages.
Greyson came for me when Kaylie could not manage her feet. He cradled me home like a secret and tugged me into bed. I did not know what had happened after the drinks because I dissolved into sleep under the weight of his arms and woke with a ache in the base of me that was not just the headache of too much wine.
"Are you okay?" he asked. "Do you remember anything?"
I shook my head. "No. I only remember you taking me home."
"I made sure you were safe," he said. "You looked like you might float away without someone to anchor you."
He left to make breakfast and then—panic—my mother arrived like a sunburst.
"Get up! Dress! We are going to meet a boy for you to marry. You'll be fine," she announced, all maternal optimism.
"Mom—"
"He's perfect: stable job, house, family willing to help. It is time."
I panicked and tried to hide under the quilt. Greyson's head popped up from the covers and he greeted my mother with the easy smile of his kin.
"Hello, ma'am. I'm Greyson Heinrich," he said, and he held out his hand as if I were his prize.
My mother beamed. "What a well-mannered young man. Thank you for coming."
He charmed my parents in a way that made me both proud and sick. He told my mother how good I was at work and how he slept better knowing I ate properly. He complimented me like a man who recorded every detail and then edited them into gifts.
After my mother left, in the car on the way back, we argued.
"Why did you ruin my chances?" I asked. "Why did you bring my mother here?"
"I'm helping," he said. "You said you didn't want to meet him. I saved you."
"You act like you own me."
"I want you to be mine," he said simply.
"You can't make things your property," I said, and for once his smile was a little raw. "You are impossible."
After a week of paper-signed nonsense and small, cozy days where he would do impossible little favors for me, I found myself at the civil affairs office. I clung to him on the sidewalk and he laughed, then when I balked he pulled me in front of the registrar and held my hand until I signed the hot red certificate that made us legally linked.
"I can't believe we just did this," I whispered.
"I can," he said. "I've wanted to since I met you."
It felt like an arranged prank, and then a warm blanket.
Back at home, everything shifted. Kaylie laughed at me like I was her aunt and now I was the very aunt we had joked about. I tried to explain later, but Kaylie's eyes darted and she grew cold.
It took me a moment to see the whole picture. Kaylie had been distant for days. She canceled plans and when I called she pushed me aside. I asked too many questions. She gave too few answers.
And then the night Brody stumbled into my bar with drunk, red-rimmed eyes and a voice like a cracked violin.
"Kaylie left me," he sobbed. "She said she never loved me. She said she wanted fun and she wanted someone else."
"I don't understand," I said.
He shoved his face in his hands. "She told me she loved me. I thought—"
I felt cold then. The clues fell into a single line and formed a new shape. Kaylie had cheated. She had used Brody. She'd been slipping away from me and into someone else's arms.
I invited Kaylie over that evening. She arrived with a grey tie in hand, like she'd found a trophy.
"Tell me everything," I said.
She flinched. "What do you mean?"
"You saw the way Brody looked tonight," I said. "Are you with him?"
She laughed, a brittle noise. "No. He was drunk."
"Then explain texts," I said, and tossed her phone on the coffee table. "Explain the messages."
She went white. "Hana, I—"
"Not here," I said. "We need everyone."
"I don't want—"
"Join us," I told her.
I invited the people who mattered to an impromptu dinner, and not one of them suspected anything. Valentina, disinterested coworkers, even Brody. He walked in, all shock and rumpled shirt, and met my gaze like a man trying to find a life raft.
I set the table and poured wine. Greyson arrived and stood behind my chair. He didn't say much. He only watched me with those eyes that had learned to read people like open books.
"Let's start with the tie," I announced. "Kaylie brought it. Where did you get it?"
She stammered. "It's Greyson's. He gave it to me to play dress up."
Valentina blinked. "Dress up?"
I smiled in a way that was all edges. "Brody, would you check your phone, please?"
He fumbled, pulled out his phone, and his face crumpled when he saw the thread I had opened on a laptop. "How—"
"Kaylie," I said softly, "these are messages between you and the man who sits in my house and uses my shampoo. You wrote to him, don't you? You told him you loved him. You told him to wait. You told him to keep it secret from me."
She shrank in her chair like a small animal. "Hana, I can explain."
"Explain to everyone," I said. "Explain to the people sitting around this table who thought I was your friend."
Her voice broke. "I didn't—Hana, I didn't mean to—"
"Brody," I said, "do you want to tell everyone how she told you she'd never leave you—until someone else showed up?"
He sobbed so loud the room went quiet. People looked at Kaylie with a slow, compiling horror. Greyson's jaw tightened. He stepped forward.
"This is a private matter," he said, but the room had already turned into a courtroom. Phones were out. A woman in a black dress whispered, "Record it. They're recording."
I had planned this like a play. I had asked Brody to come and given him all the texts and the right to speak. I had sat with logic and gathered proof: screenshots, timestamps, the string of messages that painted a careful betrayal.
Kaylie tried to stand. "Hana, please—"
I raised my voice, letting the parts that had been injured speak. "You promised we'd be single together. You promised we'd protect each other. You said you'd be my friend. Did you mean it?"
She looked at me, eyes glazed. "I—"
"Answer me," I demanded.
She looked at the faces encircling us: Valentina’s pity, the co-worker’s curiosity, Brody’s red, bloodshot despair, Greyson’s unreadable calm. She saw herself as tiny and naked and cornered.
"I didn't know what I wanted," she said, voice small. "I didn't know."
"That's not an answer," Brody hissed. "You told me you loved me."
She stared at him and then at Greyson. "You gave me attention. You were everything my life didn't have."
The room’s murmur turned. "How could she—" "Shameless." "What a liar."
I turned to Greyson. "Is this true? Did you—"
He didn't need to lie. He opened his hands and the grey tie lay in them like a confession. "She used the tie. She wore it to my office party once and pretended to flirt, and then she told Brody it was a joke."
Someone laughed, a thin, bitter sound. Phones shone like little interrogation lights.
Kaylie's face drained. "No—Greyson, please—"
"Please what?" Greyson's voice was small only when he chose. "Please stop lying?"
She fell apart, the bravado dissolving: first shock, then denial, then bargaining, then utter collapse.
"No," she whispered. "Please don't—"
Brody, who had been on the edge of a breakdown, now rose like someone who had learned the power of truth. "You used me," he said. "You told me lies."
"You never told me to wait until—and now you throw me away," he said. "I thought—"
He stumbled backward as if the floor was gone under him.
The room had become a chorus of voices. Some reached out to Brody with soft hands. Others turned away from Kaylie like a current changing. Phones filmed, hands trembled. The woman in the black dress, who had been gossiping with the table next to hers, now whispered loudly, "This will be all over the morning feeds."
Kaylie fell to her knees. "I'm sorry," she said so many times it became a chant. "I'm so sorry."
Greyson stood above her, face a mask. Then he did something none of us expected.
"You owe everyone an apology," he said, each word measured. "Especially Brody."
Brody, still shaking, couldn't stand it. "I loved you," he sobbed. "I still—"
Kaylie's eyes went to the room, to me, to Greyson, and then to the doorway where I had first found the tie.
"What do you want me to do?" she cried.
I watched her unravel, and I felt an odd mixture of triumph and shame. This wasn't a victory the way movies promise. This was messy and painful. But she had to face it.
"Stand up," I said.
She looked at me like I had asked the moon to hold a rose. She stood as if climbing stairs.
"I want you to speak to Brody," I said. "And to everyone here. Tell the truth. No excuses."
She swallowed. "Brody, I'm sorry. I wanted attention. I didn't want to hurt you. I wanted to be wanted. I am sorry."
His face collapsed. "You broke me," he said. "You lied, Kaylie."
"You deserved better," I said, voice low. "You deserve better and you will find it. But tonight you will say those words for everyone."
She nodded. She spoke. She cried. The room watched, whispered, recorded, judged. The punishment was public and thorough: Kaylie's reputation crumbled in real time. People who had liked her ignored her texts. The bar where she used to leave a tab now had staff who refused her name. Brody deleted her from his phone and then, in a single, silent move, left.
Kaylie tried to explain to my mother, to Greyson's guests, to Valentina. She tried bargaining. She tried blaming. She begged for privacy.
"No," said an older woman in the corner I had not noticed before. "You made this stage."
A crowd had gathered on the sidewalk after one of Greyson's acquaintances posted a ten-second clip that spooled into gossip. The whispers swelled. Someone took a picture. Kaylie's cheeks were streaked and she tried to stand tall but she could not.
She fell to her knees again, not because someone forced her but because the weight of eyes and shame was too heavy.
Greys on his face had softened. He had taken the tie and now he kept it folded like a small vote. Brody left with a friend, his shoulders shaking.
Kaylie's reaction was a hundred motions: shock, then denial, then bargaining, then collapse, then pleading. She crawled for forgiveness like a child.
The viewers outside? They recorded every sob. They texted friends. They posted. They cheered, they judged, they patted their own backs for being moral observers.
This was the public punishment. Kaylie's status as my friend shriveled under every phone flash. Brody's broken trust lay on the table like a wager. Kaylie's parents called. At first they'd been angry at me. Then, hearing the truth, they were speechless. Kaylie's father asked her where she'd gone wrong. She had no answer.
She had thought she could hide in our jokes and our college promises. She had been wrong.
Greyson stepped forward, his voice quiet. "We will not humiliate her to death," he said. "But we will not pretend this didn't happen."
He set the tie on the table and covered it with his hand. "No more lies."
The crowd outside dispersed like leaves. Phones still whispered. The woman in black, who had filmed from the start, deleted her clip after a face-to-face talk with Brody. She later said she did it because she couldn't bear to be part of someone's pain.
Brody's punishment was less about shame and more about a severe, unglamorous truth: he had to rebuild. People who had cheered on a moment now offered him condolences. Kaylie's punishment was harsher—she lost invitations, friends, a lane through which she'd used to stride without asking permission.
She was stripped of pretense. She looked up at the end and said, "I am sorry." It was not a perfect redemption, but it was a beginning.
Greyson turned to me afterward and kissed my forehead. "You did right."
"You think so?" I asked, though I felt the blood in my ears.
"I do." He smiled, careful. "You saved a boy from more heartache, and a friend from being a liar."
"Is saving a boy by hurting a girl noble?" I asked.
He took my hand and squeezed. "Sometimes the truth is a messy instrument, but it cuts clean."
In the weeks that followed, Kaylie and Brody kept distance. Brody moved away for a while to nurse his wounds. Kaylie's calls went unanswered; the doorbell at her parents' house stopped ringing with friends. Her punishment was social and acute: she lost the ease of being Beloved Kid. She showed up at work one day and found herself on the periphery of conversations. People stopped inviting her to things. She found herself reading comments on social media and recoiling.
She did not become a villain movie could mock. She became human, small, and stripped as if lesson and loss had been the same thing.
Greyson and I continued. He still unhooked ties and held doors. He still kissed me with the same hunger. He still surprised me, and sometimes he still terrified me with the ways he could plan and orchestrate.
But I learned a new sharpness inside me. There was tenderness and there was anger. I had married in an instant that felt like both madness and mercy. I had found someone who would fight my battles and also hold me to truths I didn't want to speak.
Once, in a quiet moment, he eased off his suit jacket and draped it over my shoulders when I shivered. "You look cold," he said.
"You do this on purpose," I accused.
"I do whatever it takes," he whispered, and for a second I believed him like a child believes a bedtime story.
One night, months later, Kaylie came back to me. Her face was thinner and more honest. "I'm sorry," she whispered.
"You're punished," I said. "You did this."
She nodded. "I know. I've been learning what it means to mean something to someone and not hurt them."
We walked along the river like two women who had once been careless. "Do you forgive me?" she asked.
"I don't know yet," I said, because forgiveness is not an immediate thing. "But I won't make you leave my life entirely."
She reached out and touched my wrist—the one Greyson had once tied with his grey tie. "You look good with that tie," she said because she remembered the night and the bow and the way I'd laughed.
I laughed too, and it was small and honest.
In the end, things were not the same. Greyson still planned our future with a ridiculous seriousness—names of hypothetical children, schools he liked, houses by the sea. He had flaws and they were visible. He was not a saint. But he had been on my side when truth needed a voice.
And the grey tie? He put it into a drawer months later, wrapped in tissue paper. Once, when we were alone, I opened the drawer and found it. I touched the silk and remembered the night, the kitchen, the way he had kissed me despite Kaylie. I laughed at myself for being dramatic and then I folded the tie and let it sit.
"This tie will always be a story," Greyson said when I showed it to him.
"It will be our story," I told him.
He frowned. "Weird to think of it like that."
I smiled. "Then let it be ours."
He kissed me then, slow and sure, and I felt like a child who had found a home.
The End
— Thank you for reading —