Sweet Romance11 min read
The General's Daughter Who Broke the Rules — My Rivals, My Vows, My Blade
ButterPicks12 views
I am Estrella Mason. My father, Ernesto Thomsen, commands the frontier; my mother, Ines Garnier, is the cleverest woman at court. I have one brother, Boyd Morales, the quieter sort who buries his life in books. We look like a matched set of wind and ink: I take after our father—strong, loud, quick with a blade; Boyd takes after our mother—calm, precise, a mind that will not stop turning pages.
"Estrella," my mother used to say gently, "you have your father's arms and my stubbornness. Use them kindly."
"I will," I would promise with a grin so wide I split my collar. Then I'd turn and break a practice post in two just to be sure I still could.
When my father decided the time had come, I was sent to the nameless mountain school to train. Boyd stayed at the nameless academy at its base, reading. He turned ink into armor of another kind, while I polished iron into mine.
"Promise me one thing," Boyd said before we left the city. "If ever the wind blows you toward battle, do not let pride cut you."
"I won't," I lied, but my hands were already itching for a fight.
Years passed. I learned how to throw my voice as well as my spear. Boyd learned to fold worlds into essays that made men cheer. The world beyond the mountain was a different kind of trial. When the southern war flared, our family answered the call. My father marched to the front and was wounded; I lied about my gender and rode in my brother's stead.
"Boyd," I said as he handed me a heavy red-tasselled spear, "keep them at home. If you ever dance with a pen in public while dragons fall, I will come find you."
Boyd pressed his palms together like a monk. "Bring back the honor, or at least the stories."
I failed at being unobtrusive. I nearly bled my way into everyone’s notice. I fought all day and slept with the taste of iron in my mouth. Then one dusk a rider cut through the smoke and chaos like a blade: Baxter Sanders of the An estate, a boy who smiled like a coin and moved like a storm. He rode in behind a cloud of dust, led cavalry that moved like a single thought, and did what no one expected—he turned the tide.
"Miss," he had said at the camp, eyes bored into mine as if reading an old map, "the world is heavier than it looks. Come stand where I can see you."
I had wanted to slam his head into a tent peg from the moment I met him. He took credit for saving my father, and he took the applause that should have been mine. For three years he chased banners and victories until the whole realm had two shining stars: me and him. But my name was always just after his.
"You seem to like winning," he said one night when the campfire was low. "Do you prefer the front line or the praise after?"
"I prefer my spear," I snapped. "You prefer taking what other people earned."
Baxter laughed, and the sound scraped like silk on stone. "You are bold."
That night he left to drink with my father and returned to my tent tipsy and foolish. He tried to kiss the wrong person—my brother, dressed in my clothes for a trick I'd pulled years back—and I did the only thing I could think of: I knocked him flat with a fist and then marched him back to the gates in a sack.
"You knocked me out earlier," he murmured later, when we'd both sobered. "You have a temper."
"I have a sword," I corrected.
A wrong turn of fate. Years later, he would tie his name to mine with a paper in the capital: a marriage contract won with military merit. It arrived at dawn like a hawk. I stood at the palace gate, stubborn as a rock, saying the things suitable for a heroine in a play.
"Baxter Sanders," I told him, voice thin with a day of waiting. "You cannot force what you do not deserve. I am not fit—"
"Estrella," he interrupted, and his voice was careful, "your brother told me you were modest and refined. Today I have seen the so-called modesty, and you are...something I did not expect."
My fingers closed around a small dagger hidden in my sleeve. I crushed it without making a sound. I did not need the blade. I needed something louder.
"Don't," Baxter said softly, as if he could see the small tremor I could not always hide. "Don't do anything rash."
I smiled and let my teeth show. "I never do."
We were wed because men trade things in the world like titles and medals, not feelings. The An estate provided a house, books, and a training yard. Baxter offered—oddly—both gentleness and a stubborn promise.
The early nights were awkward; we were brides and commanders trying on new roles. On our first night, after the crowd had left and the silk hung like clouds, I caught him looking at the shallow scar above my left breast.
"Is that from hunting?" he asked, hand hesitant over the fabric.
"A mountain rooster pecked me," I lied in the exact tone of a woman who had learned to survive with stories.
He looked at me like he had found a small treasure and then kissed the scar lightly. "Then I will keep you away from roosters."
"Good," I whispered, and felt my knees soften.
Baxter was not what I expected. He could be arrogant and maddening, but his hands were careful. He gave me books—rare ones, things I had dreamed of—and he took pleasure in seeing Boyd light up over a single volume. He seemed to make space for my brother in ways strangers would not. It infuriated me and made my cheeks warm.
"You're generous with him," I said once, cross-armed. "You treat my brother as if he were your own."
"Because he wrote a poem that made me think," Baxter said simply. "And because he cares. Family matters."
At court, long days passed between poems and drills. The long princess—Leah Cox—looked at Boyd with the shy adoration of a reader who had finally found the edition she prized. She and Boyd wrote letters back and forth, quiet things boxed in ink that smelled of sandalwood. I was livid—at first with Boyd, then with myself.
"Do you like her?" I asked him in the garden under a moon that knew every secret.
Boyd folded back a page and looked at me like the question amused him. "Do you like Baxter?"
"I am married to him," I reminded, and my skin felt hot.
Boyd smiled, a small, private thing. "Then perhaps we shall all fall into place."
Marriage and war weave strange patterns. As our household settled, odd tragedies and small mercies found us. Bandits increased along the old pilgrim roads. One dawn as I walked through the An estate garden with a cup of steaming tea, black-clad men struck—swift as wolves.
They seized women, caused a scramble, and in the chaos I was taken to a disused temple and locked in a straw room. Their leader, a broad man with fear in his eyes and arrogance on his tongue, called himself Ramon Ludwig.
"You are the general's new wife," Ramon sneered. "Tell your husband he gets to buy you back."
I looked at him, the room smelling like old smoke and dry rope, and smiled in spite of everything. "You think I am something to be sold?"
"You are something everyone will pay for," he said. "You are a ticket to riches."
I have never been good at playing small. When the rope at my wrists frayed, it was not by chance. I had kept my blade hidden in the hem of my gown. I used it like a promise: quick, sharp, and without hesitation. I freed myself, moved like a cat, and faced them.
"Don't," a voice called.
Baxter arrived not with banners but with a handful of guards and a patience like a net. He had traced their tracks the moment he'd heard the alarm. When the men realized they'd been trapped, their leader cursed and lunged—loud, stupid, and very sure of his own plans.
There was a fight. I always prefer it when Baxter fights at my side. He is not the loudest of men, but he aims like a man who measures every word before he speaks. He took the leader by the throat and said coldly, "You chose the wrong houses to plunder."
When the dust settled, the bandits were bound, but the law demanded spectacle. The court loved spectacle almost as much as it loved itself. So they brought Ramon and his men into the city market on the day of the harvest fair—a place full of people with sticky hands and bright eyes. They wanted example, they wanted noise.
I stood in the shadow near the dais. Leviathan banners flap—men and women leaned over stalls. Children ran, clutching lacquered toys. Leah Cox had come with a ribbon in her hair and a face like a bell. Boyd stood near her, hands clenched, eyes not yet hopeful, only curious.
"Bring them," barked a magistrate. "Let the city see."
They dragged Ramon forward, face black with fury, and shoved a rope around his neck. The magistrate demanded a confession, the crowd wanted theater. I had expected anger and quick punishment; what followed was worse—because it was personal.
"Ramon!" the magistrate called. "Confess your crimes!"
Ramon spat. "I did what I had to."
"Do you deny the abductions?"
He looked at the crowd and shrugged. "We took what the rich tossed away."
"Then you deserve the people's scorn," someone cried. "Let the judges decide."
The magistrate nodded. "Let them speak. Let your wrongs be known."
They read names of the women he had taken, the places he had looted. Each recital was a stone thrown through his chest. The crowd murmured like hungry leaves.
"Ramon," Baxter said quietly from the dais, and his voice carried like a bell, "why did you target weak travelers and mothers?"
Ramon grinned like a cracked plate. "Because they were easy. Because we needed coin."
"Did you imagine yourself brave?" Leah Cox called, voice trembling with courage. "Did you imagine we'd applaud the taking of children?"
"Shut up, princess," Ramon snarled.
"No," Leah said, and suddenly her voice was loud and clear. "Let everyone hear."
The magistrate's order was simple. "You will strip the leader of all his gains. He will be paraded with his spoils and publicly renounced. The children will get their things—if they live. We will let the crowd speak the shame you so loved."
Ramon laughed, but the laugh turned thin when the crowd began to react. Heads turned from curiosity to hatred. There was a chorus of whispers that grew teeth.
"You took from mothers!" a woman shouted, voice rough with motherhood.
"You have a child's blood on your hands!" an old merchant added.
They made Ramon walk the circuit around the market. They hung his belongings on a pole above him: the stolen coins, the women's trinkets, the children's broken toys. Each trinket was named: "Taken from the willow-pond lane," "Stolen from the red house," "From the boy with the blue scarf." The naming was deliberate. It gave the items memory and turned them into accused witnesses.
"Do you know whose this is?" one woman asked, pointing to a faded ribbon.
Ramon looked and sneered, but his sneer faltered when a little girl in the crowd gasped and reached out. "My ribbon," she cried, and the sound was like a map folding itself into place.
The crowd's reaction changed. Where they once wanted spectacle, now they wanted justice that burned. People came forward to spit, to shout, to shame. Merchants who had once gossiped about the bandits now threw the stolen things back at Ramon. The sound of cloth hitting his chest was like rain.
"Do you regret it?" someone asked.
"No," Ramon said, voice small.
Then an old woman stepped forward, a farmer who had come to sell eggs. "We will show you the cost of your choices," she said. "You gave us fear; we will give you truth."
They made him recount each theft aloud: every coin, every clasp, every stolen memory. As he spoke, each theft was retold by the person who had lost it. The market turned into a choir of injured things. A shoemaker spat that Ramon had robbed his apprentice and left him to the cold. A seamstress accused him of taking a wedding band meant for a girl now widowed. Each accusation cupped his face like wind.
Ramon's bravado eroded. Sweat ran down his temple. The crowd closed in, faces hard and human. Someone who had been laughing an hour before now had tears in her eyes. "You will not scare us any longer," a woman said. "We will remember your face."
Ramon tried to shift blame. "We had no choice," he said, scrambling for words. "The roads are empty. The north takes our grain. I was—"
"You were cruel by choice," Leah called. "A coward chooses the path of least honor."
He staggered under their words. His face crumpled—first denial, then anger, then pleading.
"Please!" he begged at last. "I have children—"
"Then keep them far from us," the crowd answered. "Let's teach them not to tread where you did."
They made him kneel in the mud by the central fountain and scrub the names he had taken off each trinket with his bare hands, repeating the names until the syllables were burned into him. People snapped pictures with rough wood and pinched cloth by his face. They sang the names of the stolen things like a litany. Children spat in his direction. Priests cursed him softly, and merchants refused him bread.
Ramon’s face changed as the hours passed: pride became panic, panic became pleading, pleading became the dead silence of someone who had seen his life dismantled piece by piece. He spat denials that sounded small. He clawed the dirt as if the earth could hide him. People leaned in to watch the collapse, some recording on their carved tablets, some clapping slowly like the fall of a gavel.
When the magistrate finally spoke, there were no gentle words. "Let this stand as a lesson," he said. "For theft is only the first sin; pride is the last. For your crimes you will be banished from these roads and branded, so that every time you show your face you will meet those who remember."
They marked him—not with the harshness of scars, but with the weight of being known. It was a justice that burned in quiet places: every time someone in the market saw Ramon, they'd remember the little girl's ribbon, the seamstress's band. He was not executed; he was made humanly infamous.
Ramon collapsed to the ground like a man who had surrendered his map. He begged and wept and sobbed until his voice became the same wet sound he had made when he had stolen other people's things. The crowd hissed. Children shouted for his head. Mothers spat salt on his hands.
I watched and felt something like cold satisfaction—because this punishment was not only for me, but for all the quiet terrors he had caused. He shrank in public and lost the arrogance that had once fed him. He could not return to the lanes and expect to be anyone but the man who had been made remembered.
After the spectacle, life returned to its smaller rhythms: books, boots, poems, the hum of embers. Boyd married the long princess, and the court cheered them as if two halves of a poem had finally found the same line. Boyd looked more like himself than he had in years; when Leah Cox laughed, he laughed with her as if the sound had been missing all his life.
"Do you regret swapping places?" I asked him one evening when the three of us sat by the library wall under the small lamps.
Boyd closed a book and looked at his hands. "I regret hiding things. I regret not telling truth when it mattered. I don't regret learning something new about myself."
"You never told me you loved a princess," I said, teasing.
He smiled. "You never asked me properly."
Baxter and I learned how to be a pair. He had ways of showing care that were quieter than mine—repairing my sword, leaving notes in the margins of my books, or stealing a sliver of time to practice with me. Once, in the courtyard, he fixed my armor with an attention that made my heart trip.
"Why do you do all this?" I asked, breathless from sparring.
"Because you are reckless enough to be honest," he said. "And because when you laugh, the world stops pretending."
There were moments that made me melt with small, nearly foolish pleasure: him smiling at me when I butchered a line in court; him slipping me a rare book as a gift; him resting his head on my shoulder for no reason but that he could. I answered him not with vows—those had been signed already—but with time: my afternoons, my stubbornness, my blade.
Years would pass, and stories would be told of the general's daughter who learned to wear silk without losing her edge. People would say I had been tamed by love; those people never saw him hand Boyd a book and then sit and listen as the younger man read aloud until the sun dipped away.
One autumn night, as leaves fell like small gold coins, Baxter took my hand in the garden and said softly, "I promised you once to keep you from harm. I keep other promises, too."
"And one day," I said, leaning into his shoulder, "we will both be old and disagree about everything."
"Then I will disagree in whispers."
We laughed like children and felt older for it.
I tell this now so you will know: I did not fall because I was weak. I fell because he built something better than a fortress—he built a place I wanted to come home to. And the world, sharp as it can be, will sometimes bend toward the ones who refuse to be small.
The End
— Thank you for reading —