Revenge13 min read
The Bentleys, the Broken Table, and the Letter I Kept
ButterPicks17 views
"Did you know?" Margherita said from the doorway, the sarcasm so soft it sounded like a knife.
"Know what?" I tried not to let my pen tremble. My fingers were wet with sweat even though the exam hall was full of air. "About the math problem?"
"No." She stepped closer. "That Dad and Mom—actually, your real parents—are coming tomorrow."
I didn't look up. "I heard."
She laughed in the kind of way that had always made me small. "Of course you did. They called. They're so rich. They have a Bentley. Can you imagine? A Bentley pulling into our little yard."
"Congratulations," I said, and I kept my voice flat.
"Don't be mad, Elise," she said. "If you don't do well, it's fine. You can go plant land with them, maybe marry a farmer. Ha."
"Marry a farmer," I repeated, and the words tasted like dust.
When I was a child, every toy she wanted became hers because she wanted it. When we fought, I always took the blame. "You're the older one," our foster mother, Carter Diaz, would tell me. "You must give way."
"You're the older one," my foster father, Egan Walker, would repeat, as if saying it enough turned it into truth.
I had learned to give. I learned to smile and wait until she left the room and then touch the toys she had played with, my hands hovering like a thief.
The night before the first day of university decisions, a white Bentley rolled into our street. "Is that—" Carter whispered, and her fingers dug into Egan's hand.
A middle-aged couple stepped out. "Elise!" the man cried, and he cried like he had searched for years.
"You're here," the woman said, and when she touched my face I felt something like recognition, as if my skin had always belonged to them. This was the first time in my life anyone called me by a name I didn't use at home.
"They know my old name," I told Margherita later in the kitchen, slipping the word out like a secret. "My name is not Elise on paper."
"Oh?" She tilted her head. "What is it then?"
"Elise," I said. "And that's enough."
"You could have told us," she said sweetly. Her voice was sugar on a razor. "But no, you chose them."
"They came when it mattered," my bio-father, Eldon Gonzales, said in the living room. "We waited."
I watched them from across the table. "You came late," I said quietly.
Eldon rubbed his hands nervously. "We didn't want to risk your exam. We waited because we wanted to do the right thing at the right moment."
Margherita leaned over and smiled so widely it made me cold. "Isn't that so thoughtful of them? So noble."
"You don't have to be like that," my foster father muttered. "She uses you."
"Use me?" I said. "I thought this house fed us, kept us safe."
Egan looked at me with a man trying to understand a map written in foreign language. "If you want to go," he said to the couple, "we'll help her. Of course we will."
"Don't be silly," Carter added too quickly. "Why would we stop her?"
At the door, Margherita whispered, "If you fail, Elise, nobody will complain."
I didn't fail. I sat for the final exam with the Bentley image burned somewhere behind my eyes and I took the test as if my life depended on it.
The next morning, the phone rang. "Elise—" Denis Lawrence's voice was like a loose key. "Admissions called. I think they want to talk about scholarships and majors."
"What?" My voice sounded small.
"The offices," he said. "Peking called; Tsinghua called." He laughed like he'd already poured me a glass of champagne. "You need to think, child. This is not a small thing."
When I told Carter and Egan, they stared like they had seen a ghost. "Peking?" Egan repeated. "Elise, that sounds—"
"It is," I said. "And that's why I'm going to make my own choices."
Margherita watched as our lives shifted. Her smile fell into a shadow. "So you're leaving," she said later to the group, to the relatives who had arrived to celebrate.
"Elise," Eldon said, "we'd like you to come with us home. We'll help with your studies. We can give you a room, we can—"
"You can't buy everything," Carter said sharply. "You bought a child once. That can't be undone."
There it was—the old wound reopened. "He called me his daughter," I said. "They did what they could and found me. What should I do? Pretend it never happened?"
Margherita made her voice tight. "I thought you were our sister."
"So did I," I said.
The week ran on like a tightly wound clock. I spoke to Denis Lawrence on the phone and he arranged for me to be interviewed by the school. "Bring your parents, Elise," he insisted. "This could help other students."
When the news got out, the world cracked open. Comments poured in, cruel and blunt. "She only wants money." "She betrayed the people who raised her." My foster family called me. They asked me to come back. They asked me to sit and be grateful.
Eldon and Arianna stood by me the whole time. "Our only hope is you," Arianna said once. "If you succeed, nothing will go wrong again."
"Your life is yours," Eldon said. "We only want to help."
The night before the official results, when I found out the phone calls from Peking and Tsinghua were real, when Denis Lawrence filled my father in on the formal offers, Margherita stepped in and smiled like a loaded gun. "That's great," she said, but her smile had teeth.
Then the score came. "Seven oh three," I told them, counting the digits aloud as if tasting them.
Margherita slammed a plate onto the table. "You cheated!" she screamed. "You studied under someone's hand!"
"Prove it," I said, and the house fell into a silence that could be heard from the street.
"People started to rumor," she kept up, as if she had a script to read. "You didn't study; you just left us. You don't care for those who raised you."
"I'm grateful," I said. "But I will live my life."
Their family posted videos. "She left us the second day after the test." They used the old narratives—abandonment, ingratitude. The internet lit up with people who loved to pick fights. "How could she?" "Shame on her." "Don't sideline the people who cared for her."
"Don't engage," Eldon told me. "They want noise."
"Not always," I muttered. "Some people will believe anything."
Denis called to say the school wanted to feature me. "We want your story," he said. "Come to campus. Tell them the part no one knows."
I sat under the big gym lights and told my story. I told the row of students how a month before my exams I had been told I was not from the home I thought. Some of the students whispered. Some faces hardened.
"You left us," Margherita told the interviewer in a clip that slid across the internet like oil. "She left and forgot us."
"That wasn't the point," I said on stage. "I worked through what I had. I made choices. That is mine."
Then the internet turned worse.
Some asked how a girl who once slipped below five hundred could suddenly score so high. People posted old report cards. People pored over my transcripts like vultures. "Fraud!" one said. "Admissions fraud!" another wrote.
My foster parents received calls at their workplace. They were shamed. Relatives I hadn't seen in years spoke against me online in defense of Margherita. The pressure mounted like a storm.
"Let them talk," Eldon said. "Truth is truth."
But people are louder than truth. For a while the noise drowned out everything else.
At the hotel celebration that my foster parents had arranged—yes, they called it a celebration, in a room with a banner that read 'Congratulations'—I went. I wanted to say thank you to the people who had raised me through pain and patience. I also wanted to give back a card of money I had collected from scholarships to help Margherita go to college. I took a bank card from my pocket and slid it across the table.
"This is yours," I told Carter. "Money for Margherita. For a school. Take it."
People froze. "You can't," my foster father shouted. "You can't give them away like that."
"You won't accept money from someone ungrateful," Margherita cried. "You're letting them buy people."
I put the card down, standing up. "I promised to repay what they did for me," I said. "Here. Take it."
I left the banquet and walked out into the summer heat, my acceptance letter burning my pocket like a paper coin.
The posts on the internet escalated. Margherita's interview replayed. Whispers became a wave. Carter and Egan's workplace supervisors began to receive calls. People gathered outside their home and shouted. They were no longer invited to family gatherings. Their neighbors turned away when they walked past.
But the bigger, darker turn came when the family started to collapse under their own choices.
One night, Margherita ran away after the argument, then was found in a bar, drunk and angry. The next day she refused to eat and slammed her bedroom door. Family members begged. "Please," Carter cried. "Don't do this."
Then rumors started that the foster parents had not been entirely innocent in the market of human trafficking many years before. That there had been a pattern. That they had been buyers in a system that did not punish buyers as harshly as sellers. The net widened and the story didn't stop with sentiment. Old neighbors dug up memories. Names were connected. Threads were followed.
Our city started to turn its head.
One afternoon, a company-wide meeting at Carter's workplace became the place where consequences started to happen.
"Why are we gathered?" Carter had asked, pale.
"Just a meeting," one coworker said. "They wanted to talk."
The room was full. Supervisors sat at the head table with stern faces. People filed in, murmuring. I received a text from Eldon, a single line: "Go. Please come."
I arrived and the air smelled of coffee and nervous breath. The company HR director cleared her throat. "We are here because of recent events involving some of our employees," she said. Her voice was measured, the kind of voice that counts words like coins. "We cannot ignore public opinion nor the nature of the accusations. We have launched an internal review."
The director turned to Carter and Egan. "Ms. Diaz, Mr. Walker, we asked you here to give you a chance to respond."
Egan swallowed twice. "I will tell the truth," he said. "We raised a child. We took her in. We loved her."
"How do you explain the videos alleging you bought a child?" someone in the room called. The word 'bought' hung like a bell.
Carter's face turned ashy. "We didn't—"
"You bought her?" an employee demanded, louder. "You people who hugged kids in the company picnic—did you buy her?"
The murmurs swelled. Phones were out. People filmed with small eyes.
"Please," Egan said. "We were desperate. We were lonely. We made mistakes."
"Ms. Diaz, we appreciate your honesty," the director said. "But this matter is beyond personal feelings. It affects our workplace image. We have received dozens of calls. Some partners are worried. Some clients have canceled orders. This company's reputation is our livelihood."
Egan blinked, human and small. "You can't be firing us. We raised a child. We love her."
"Due process," the director said, and that was a word that sounded like armor. "But until the investigation completes, you'll be temporarily suspended."
The room erupted like a dam breaking. People stood, some with pity, some with anger. A staff member stood forward and said, "I can't believe it. You two had nice kids smiling in pictures. How can you do this?"
"How can you?" another shouted. "How can you say you loved her and then shame her when her life changes?"
"She doesn't have to answer to you," I heard from the back. A woman stepped forward with a voice steady as stone. "But what of all the other children? If this is true, then shame is not enough."
Cameras flashed. Phones recorded. Coworkers who had given Carter birthday cakes now whispered about ethics.
The meeting lasted two hours. When it ended, Carter and Egan walked out into a sun that felt too bright. A few colleagues left bouquets at the company door. Others spat in the street. The director's email arrived that evening. "Effective immediately: Carter Diaz and Egan Walker are on unpaid suspension pending further review."
That was one kind of punishment—a professional collapse. But the public punishment had a second, uglier phase.
Within days, someone organized a protest outside the small office block. Banners read "Buyers are Guilty" and "Justice for the Stolen." A group of parents who had lost children to trafficking stood in the front row and held up photographs. The local news vans arrived.
Carter and Egan stood on the sidewalk as cameras rolled. A woman accused them on camera. "You think you can hide behind being parents?" she shouted. "They were our children!"
People in the crowd pointed. "Shame!" "How dare you?" "You don't deserve to be parents!"
Then the rage turned to the foster parents. Some of the protestors read out a list of families who had reported missing children in the past decade, and how each had been told the system was powerless. "You made a choice," a father shouted. "You chose a child instead of right. You must answer."
Carter covered her face. Egan stood rigid, lips pressed. They had not planned to be a spectacle. But repair takes a private room, not a street.
On the third night, someone threw rotten vegetables at their gate. Their mailbox was filled with angry letters. A neighbor I had once seen smile across the fence held up a sign. "Buyer, buyer!" she hissed.
It was a slow erosion—jobs lost, friendships frayed, food tossed in the street. But the public needed a climax, and the climax came when Margherita, in a drunken rage, stabbed a man in a bar fight. The video went viral.
The sequence of that night is a blur for many. But the footage was merciless: Margherita slapping, shouting, then the flash of a blade. The man collapsed clutching his stomach. People scattered. The police arrived. The next day the headlines read, "Stolen Girl's Sister Arrested for Assault."
I remember the day the news broke. Eldon called and his voice was thin. "This is unbearable," he said. "They are all losing everything."
The court hearing that followed was not a slow legal process. It became a public square.
Inside the courtroom, Margherita sat rigidly in the defendant's chair. Cameras were not allowed inside, but the hallway outside was packed. People craned their necks to see—neighbors, reporters, those who had sent angry messages. The man she had stabbed was there, bruised but alive, his face gaunt. He glared at Margherita like a man who had lost trust.
The prosecutor's office pulsed with energy. "This case shows a pattern," one prosecutor said to reporters after the session. "We will prosecute to the fullest extent."
Margherita's initial arrogance cracked in that room. She went through stages: denial, then anger, then a kind of hollow collapse.
"What happened?" someone near me asked.
"She thought the internet would protect her," another whispered. "She thought someone would take her side."
But the real punishment, the one that lasted, was not the suspension notice or the news clippings. It was how each person who had once smiled at them now looked away.
At one long public hearing that drew a small crowd, a former neighbor stood up and read a letter. "You smiled at my child's birthday party and then watched as kids disappeared," she said, voice shaking. "You looked the other way. You traded human life for comfort."
Margherita's face changed in front of everyone. First she sneered, then she paled, then she started to plead. "I didn't—" she began, and her voice fell apart. "I didn't know. I didn't—"
But the crowd had already decided it had seen enough. Some people wept. Others clicked phones in furious rhythm. One older man stepped forward and spat the word "monster." A neighbor who had once given Carter a key to her house turned and walked out, shaking his head.
The reaction was not the neat arc of a confession and redemption. It was messy, loud, and painful. People who had once called them family stood in a line and told their own stories—of missing nephews, of sleepless nights, of unanswered calls. Each story landed on the defendants like a hammer blow.
When the judge finally gave a stern warning and later handed down sentences and fines, the legal consequences were only part of the change. The bigger pain came from being stripped of the ordinary townspeople's gentleness. No one invited them to community dinners. Their children, if they had any, were excluded from birthday parties. Employers looked at their names and said no.
Margherita, who had once mocked me for being "ungrateful," now stood small in the margins. She held court papers like a badge that proved her fall. She had demanded drama and the world gave it back in full measure.
The months that followed were full of small cruelty. The foster parents sold the house in shame. They moved to a town where no one recognized them. They tried to rebuild, but their names were still in comment threads and public posts. People still posted their old photographs with captions like "Buyer exposed." The comment threads never seemed to end.
Yet for me, the noise turned to something else—relief, then a quiet. When the court closed the chapter and the legal dust settled, I sat down with my acceptance letter into Peking. Denis Lawrence hugged me in front of cameras and said, "You belonged to yourself all along."
"Am I allowed to be happy?" I asked him quietly.
"Yes," he said. "You earned it."
The internet grudgingly shifted. Many voices apologized when they saw the facts. Some posted retractions. Some sent apology messages. Others kept their anger for longer.
On the morning I moved to the city to begin my freshman year, Eldon placed my acceptance letter into my hands. "This is for you," he said.
I looked at the envelope—a heavy cream paper with a blue emblem—and felt an odd peace.
"Carter and Egan—did they get any support?" I asked, because a part of me still ached.
"They had to rebuild," Arianna said. "They lost what they had, because people chose to believe the worst."
"If they'd done wrong," I said carefully, "they should have paid. But punishment and shame are different things."
Eldon nodded. "Life is not fair," he said. "But you are not owed anyone's hate."
On the campus, the first day felt like a film. The weather was perfect. The lake—still blue—reflected a sky that seemed kinder than the one I had left.
A student photographer followed us to the lake for a picture. My mother lifted my chin. "Look at the camera," she said.
I smiled and put the thick envelope into the inner pocket of my jacket. The acceptance letter was lighter than the phone calls I had been saving. The Bentley and the banner and the broken table were now images I could hold without a burning.
"Elise?" Arianna asked softly. "Are you sure about your name?"
I touched the paper and felt the imprint of a future. "My name is mine," I said. "And I will write the rest."
We took a picture by the lake. In the photo my smile is honest, nothing sewn. Behind me the water trembled and the campus moved like a quiet ocean. The page of my life turned without fanfare, but there was a weight lifted.
When I look back now, I remember the moment Margherita threw the table like a thunderclap. I remember the rotting vegetables and the suspension notice. I remember the courtroom where so many voices were spoken and the neighbor who could not forgive.
But the thing I remember most is a small blue emblem on cream paper, and the hush that followed when I put that paper into my pocket.
"Are you ready?" Arianna asked, and my father smiled with that slow sadness of a man who had waited years.
"Yes," I said.
We walked toward the lake and the shallow path of students and professors. The camera clicked once. The light slid across the water.
I placed my hand over the acceptance letter where the stamp had left a small blue mark, a mark that would stay with me as proof that someone had believed in me enough to send an envelope across miles and time.
I folded my fingers around it like a coin.
I had my life back, and I kept the letter close so when the wind blew cold and people shouted again from the comment threads of memory, I could put my hand on that small blue emblem and feel the whole world slow down.
The End
— Thank you for reading —