Sweet Romance15 min read
My Brother's Face-Blind Mix-Up and the Late-Blooming Boyfriend
ButterPicks15 views
I never expected my life to turn into a long, public mess because my brother can't tell faces apart.
"Kelly!" my brother shouted on video as soon as I picked up. His grin filled the screen.
"Hi, Vicente," I said, smiling even though my cheeks hurt from pretending to enjoy being studied like a museum exhibit.
"You broke up with him?" Vicente asked before I could finish hello. He sounded half-outraged, half-amused.
"I—no—it's complicated," I said.
"It's not complicated," he said, fast and furious. "Who said you could get dumped? Who said anything to you without my permission?"
I held my phone tighter. "Vicente, I don't need you to—"
"Save it. I'm coming over."
"You can't—" I started, but he was already gone. He always paced from one thing to another like a storm. He was loud, he was confident, and he was famously face-blind.
"You promised me you'd look after your sister's romantic life," he said, in a different voice now, the voice that made me laugh instead of scold him.
"I never asked you to be a matchmaker."
"You didn't have to. I'm the Bright in this campus, remember?" He winked at the camera.
"Vicente—"
"Too late. I'm going to find him."
"Please don't," I begged. I already had enough to explain. Andre Burns had been my on-again, off-again, half-real boyfriend because I never wanted another sibling showdown. I never wanted my relationships built on a bargain between my heart and my brother's ego.
"Hang tight," he said, and then he cut the call like a director moving to the next scene.
Julia Burks, my roommate and loudest ally, laughed when I told her. "Your brother is dramatic," she said.
"He's a hurricane," I said. "And he's coming to wreck my symphony."
We walked into class late, and there Andre was, sitting with Katelynn Camacho.
Julia pushed me and hissed, "Kelly, do you see this?"
"Do I see what?" I asked, pretending calm. My pulse was a drum, but my face was a neutral mask.
Andre looked up and then looked away, fingers woven with Katelynn's. He didn't even try to hide it.
"Kelly," Katelynn said, loud enough for half the room to hear, and smile beamed like she'd found treasure. "You're aware Andre doesn't like you, right?"
My mouth fell open. "Excuse me?"
Julia's jaw tightened. "Are you kidding me?"
Andre didn't lift his head. He stared at his phone like he'd swallowed a secret and was too guilty to let it out.
Before I could say anything, the lights dimmed—or rather, order rearranged itself. Someone at the front knocked on the blackboard: sharp, neat, dramatic. Heads turned.
Felix Cordova stepped up to the board. Felix—our campus legend. His hair was purposeful and his walk made the floor look like it loved him.
"Kelly Fernandes?" Felix's voice rolled through the room. "My girlfriend? Where is she? Give me a chance to reconcile."
Every head swiveled. The room closed in on me like a living thing.
My face turned hot. "Felix," I whispered, not believing it.
Felix smiled that tilt that suggested secrets. He carried a takeaway breakfast like a peace offering. "I thought maybe she was here." He looked right at me like he'd been searching for me forever, and I wanted to hide under my desk.
I fumbled through my phone. I had a message from Vicente. I didn't even want to read it, and yet I did.
Vicente's voice note blared in the middle of my panic—he had sent it as a grand, accidental broadcast. "You told me to give him a love letter! You said you liked Felix! You said—"
I slammed my phone shut. My cheeks burned. I wanted to evaporate.
Felix laughed softly. "Well?" he said, tilting the breakfast box toward me like an invitation and a dare. "A second chance?"
The room watched. Julia's face lit up like popcorn.
I was supposed to be mortified. Instead, a tiny, traitorous part of me thrilled.
Because the truth was, Andre was never mine in the way a storybook would say. When Vincente misdelivered his love-letter mission months ago, I accepted what came—Andre, awkward and earnest but not my person. Andre had cared because my brother crowded around him, because my brother's size and certainty made him feel brave.
"But he doesn't like me," Julia hissed under her breath, eyes laser-focused on Andre and Katelynn.
"I never pretended to be heartbroken," I told Felix in a voice that was too small and too loud all at once. I forced a smile. "I wasn't... expecting this."
Felix didn't seem to mind. He leaned back against the desk and said, "If you're free later, let's talk. No pressure."
"Okay," I said, which sounded like permission to both him and everyone watching.
After class, the rumor mill shifted into gear. Andre left without meeting my eyes, as if guilt could be worn on his sleeve. Katelynn tugged him along like a leash.
Julia squeezed my hand. "We can fix this," she said. "You can dump him—formally. You don't have to be polite about it."
"That's the point," I said. "I don't care."
That night, my phone vibrated. Felix had sent a message: "Your brother has fantastic taste in drama. Dinner tonight?"
I read it a dozen times and then breathed. "Yes."
*
The next day, Felix sat next to me in class again, breakfast boxer in hand as if it had always been his job. Andre came in with his guilty edge, Katelynn with her smug smile, and the whole room felt crowded with secrets.
"You're the one who posted that little thread," Felix said softly, watching the way Katelynn's cheeks tightened.
"What thread?" I asked.
"The anonymous one that made you the campus joke," he answered. "I know it was small, but..."
I remembered the thread—someone had hinted that I hoarded campus-worthy boys. Someone had insulted my choices. Julia swore she would find the poster.
"That was petty," Julia declared out loud. "Whoever did it should be ashamed."
Felix raised an eyebrow. "Does she look like she posts anonymous things?"
"Who—Katelynn?" Julia guessed.
Katelynn blushed and retorted, "I didn't—"
"Enough," Andre muttered, like a referee tired of a child's game.
Felix's hand brushed mine under the desk, a small, grounding thing. "Ignore them," he said. "They're noise."
I wanted to believe him. I wanted to believe he was a bright, warm sun that would burn away small guilts. But I remembered Andre's face, the way he had ducked and let things happen.
"Do you want to go out?" Felix asked after class.
"Are you serious?" I said before I could stop myself.
He laughed. "Very."
"Alright," I said, and that was that. He became present in my days. He became the person who walked with me, left notes in my locker, and sent messages at weird times: "Did you eat?" and "Don't forget your umbrella."
Vicente, meanwhile, regaled everyone with our saga. He messaged campus boards with casual authority. "I, Vicente Bright, confirm Felix is acceptable," he'd write in all caps like a sworn decree.
People snickered. Some called him overbearing; others, charming. Julia clapped like a proud aunt. "My roommate's boyfriend is a campus hero!"
One evening, Andre cornered me on the stairwell. "Kelly," he said, eyes earnest. "Look, I—"
"Don't," I said. "Please just don't."
He looked wounded. "I... I'm trying to explain."
"Explain what? That you found someone else? That you didn't tell me because you were ashamed? You ought to be ashamed."
"I liked you," he said. "I do like you. But... you and your brother—"
"You mean your courage came from my brother's shadow?" I said.
Andre's shoulders dropped. "Maybe."
"Then go," I said. "Go and be in Katelynn's suit of lies. I'm done pretending."
He left like someone who'd been given a map to nowhere.
But Katelynn? She wasn't as simple. She smiled too easily, like a woman who practiced winning faces in a mirror. She'd been the one to toss salt on my wounds and wave it around like confetti.
For a while I thought perhaps I could shrug the whole thing off. But then the school gossip tightened like a net.
Felix, though, was steady. He kept being kind without theatrics. He made awkward jokes. He watched how my brother recognized people—by quirks, by a mole, by the way someone's laugh rattled. Once, Vicente tapped my ear and said, "Your mole tells me it's you."
"That's how you find me," I teased.
He grinned. "Works like a charm."
But rumors don't die. They fester. And jealousy can be sharp enough to split someone open.
One week, at a dorm birthday party for a friend, things detonated.
I walked in with Julia and saw Katelynn there, laughing too loud. Felix stayed beside me, calm, but tight.
"You okay?" he asked.
"No," I lied.
Someone's friend was Andre's buddy, and he leaned over. "You'd better watch out," he said. "Andre's with Katelynn now."
"I heard," I said.
Felix stayed quiet. Then, like someone removing a dull blade, he said, "Let's go upstairs. I want to talk privately."
I didn't want to make a fuss, but I wasn't in charge of my life anymore. Felix's hand in mine was both safety and a cord of responsibility I hadn't asked for.
We ended up in a quiet corridor. "Why did you come tonight?" I asked.
"Because I didn't want you to be alone with them," he said. "Because I like you."
"That's the plot twist nobody expected." I tried to laugh, but my throat tightened.
Before I could reply, someone yelled from the party room. "Hey, is that Kelly? Bring her out!"
I felt heat crawl up my neck. "Please, don't drag me out there."
Felix looked at me and then led me back anyway. People turned as we entered.
"Kelly Fernandes," Felix said, loud enough for the room to hear. "I want to say something."
Silence fell. The DJ blinked. Katelynn's smile froze like a snapshot.
Felix turned on his phone and lifted the screen. He had a tiny recorder app open.
"Listen," he said. "This is a recording of a conversation. I think it matters."
He played a clip of a message where Andre and Katelynn were laughing, plotting how to act normal around me—how to present the image that Andre was the wronged party. The audio was grainy, but the words were clear.
Katelynn's mouth dropped. "No way."
Andre swore. "Where did you get this?"
"From my own curiosity," Felix said. "I asked around. People talk. I listened."
The room buzzed. Phones came out. Faces shifted. People began to judge by the second.
Katelynn's reaction changed fast: first denial, then tightening, then anger, then the small, artistic crumble where she tried to hold her polish together. Andre went from embarrassed to defiant.
"You're making this up!" Andre shouted.
Felix's voice didn't waver. "I could have said nothing. I could have let small cruelties stand. But I like Kelly. I owe her more than silence."
The crowd reacted. Some people hissed. Some took videos. Someone laughed cruelly. My heart beat so hard I thought it might explode.
This is where the punishments started—public, unmistakable, irreversible.
Punishment scene for Andre (public humiliation and social fall):
Felix stepped back and let the room decide.
"What are you doing?" Andre demanded. He looked around for allies, but half the room was recording, half was shaking their heads. The boy who used to joke with Andre walked away, avoiding his eyes.
"Andre," Vicente's voice suddenly boomed from the doorway. He had come to the party unknown to me, all giant and theatrical, and now his presence was like a spotlight.
"Who are you?" Andre said, panic cracking his voice.
"I'm her brother," Vicente said, calm at first, then curling into patronizing amusement. "The one who finds faces by moles and manners and who isn't afraid to show up at a moment's notice."
Andre's face paled. "Vicente, I—"
"Save it." Vicente's tone shifted to public prosecutor. "You dated my sister because you were small and shy in the face of pressure—and now you've done the bold thing of playing two people at once."
People murmured. "Is that true?" someone asked.
Felix simply said, "Listen to what was recorded. Decide for yourself."
People watched Andre shrink while Katelynn tried to salvage dignity. The DJ turned the music down. Cameras aimed. It was the kind of exposure that turned rumors into a public verdict.
"You're pathetic," one of Andre's classmates spat. "You used a girl as a trophy. Who does that?"
Someone else recorded him saying, "I saw him at the coffee shop last week flirting with someone new." Another person called him out for inconsistent stories. Each new testimony was another pinprick.
Andre stumbled to the center, flushed. He tried to laugh it off, but laughter isn't the same as innocence.
"I never—" he started.
"You did," Katelynn snapped, then looked at him with something like contempt. "We both used her."
The crowd's tone shifted. Sympathy evaporated. People walked away. His phones buzzed with messages from people who had liked him and now wanted distance.
Vicente didn't let the moment pass. He walked up and placed a hand on Andre's shoulder like an executioner giving the condemned a final moment.
"You will apologize," Vicente said, loudly. "Not to me. Not to Felix. To Kelly."
Andre's eyes filled with tears in an instant; the boy who'd been conveniently weak now appeared broken. He opened his mouth and muttered an apology, half performance, half coerced.
The audience hissed. A few people threw words. Someone held up their phone and started livestreaming his apology.
Andre's friends shrank away. The room became a theatre of his collapse. He lost face, and with it, the illusion of control.
Katelynn watched the unraveling with a real-time account of her own downfall happening beside him.
Punishment scene for Katelynn (public exposure, social isolation, reputation stripped differently):
Katelynn's punishment was different. Felix had planned her unraveling to be about context and integrity, not just a pile-on.
He held up a second file, images he'd gathered over several days—screenshots of messages, anonymous posts pointing to Katelynn as the instigator, a collage of her smiling with people while whispering behind backs.
"People like a villain in a story," Felix said softly, "but they don't read the whole chapter. Here is what she said, and here is what she did."
Katelynn's composure cracked. Instead of loud shame, she got quiet, as if the room's knowledge seeped in and made a cold pool under her feet.
"You're a liar," someone said.
"You're fake," another added.
She tried to retort, but the tide had turned. People who had previously clapped for her now turned away. She was left with no applause, only the echo of her own breath and the phone lights.
"Why?" she finally whispered, not to me but to herself, and the whisper made everyone listen.
Felix didn't shout. He didn't humiliate her with insults. He displayed documentation, interviews, receipts of petty slights she had orchestrated against me and others. The lack of theatrical cruelty made her punishment more surgical—quiet removal of social currency.
"You're not powerful," Felix said. "You're small."
Those words stung. The room had been cruel to Andre with noise; to Katelynn, it gave silence. People started to avoid her. Invitations dried up. Where Andre's punishment was spectacle, Katelynn's was exile—slower, lonelier, and perhaps more lasting. She found herself filmed in hallways where once she had been the filmer. Friends asked questions and received evasive answers. The person who had smiled loudest in a room found herself left with the echo.
She tried to bargain. "I didn't mean—"
"No one gets what they mean," someone said. A laugh followed, less cruel and more disgusted.
Katelynn left that night with her reputation crumbling in a way that would follow her into classes and cafes. Videos of her earlier conquests were replayed in a mean chorus. While Andre had been publicly scolded and browbeaten into a shaky apology, Katelynn faced the quiet death of social capital: people choosing not to be near her anymore. The school's social calendar shrank around her like a closing fist.
Both of them reacted differently. Andre pleaded loudly, voice cracking, asking for a second chance that no one wanted to give him. He tried to press his case in group chats and was met with silence. People texted him to say they'd expected better. He watched relationships evaporate. Katelynn, on the other hand, tried to maintain a composed face, but the cameras and messages made her flinch. She posted a note later, an apology full of hollow words, and watched as the comments measured its sincerity and found it lacking.
The crowd's reactions were varied. Some clapped when Felix finished his reveal. Some recorded. Some walked away in disgust. A few people muttered, "Good." Others pretended they hadn't seen.
"Felix," my voice trembled. "Thank you."
He took my hand and squeezed it. "You didn't have to go through that."
Vicente stood close by, his presence large and oddly tender. "That's my sister," he said simply, eyes on Andre and Katelynn. "Anyone who hurts her needs to learn consequences the hard way."
Andre and Katelynn left in different cars, both looking small in seats that would once have held swagger.
After that night, campus life shifted. Andre's texts were unanswered. Katelynn's smile seemed forced. Their social standing crumbled like a cake that's been too long out of the oven—crumbled beyond repair.
As for me, my world had tilted. I was the center of messy, public attention, and it felt strange to be both vulnerable and safe.
Felix didn't crow about victory. He was quiet and practical. "You okay?" he asked later, when only Julia and Vicente remained close.
"I'm exhausted," I said.
"So am I," he said. "But there's something else."
He looked at me with that patient tilt of his head. "I meant what I said that night. I wanted to try, and I'm trying."
"You're trying because of my brother?" I asked, because I needed to know.
"Partly," he admitted. "But mostly because I like you. Not because of a dare."
Vicente elbowed him. "And because I insisted. You're welcome."
I laughed, which felt like a relief.
Days spread out. Felix's small acts of care became the safe scaffolding I used to rebuild. He still delivered breakfast boxes with a sly note. He still sat beside me in lectures and passed me papers that said things like, "Did you get enough sleep?" and "Meet me after class."
Our interactions were full of gentle teases and awkward revelations. He would say, "You looked at that billboard, didn't you? Cute face," and I would punch his shoulder.
"There are three moments I remember," I told Julia one night.
"Name them!" she demanded.
"The time he smiled at me in class and didn't look away," I said. "The time he handed me coffee after a night of studying, even though I told him not to disturb me. And the time he said, 'I'm officially claiming you as my person.'"
Julia squealed like a wild fan. "That's three heart-stops!"
He had another way of being present: he knew how to let me be. He didn't crowd me with overbearing declarations. He did little, concrete things.
"Felix," I said one evening as we walked under the thin winter light, "you still here?"
He smiled. "Always."
"Don't be melodramatic," I said.
"Not melodrama, devotion," he countered. "Sorry, wrong word."
We laughed. The campus felt smaller and kinder.
Vicente remained a comic presence. He still couldn't tell every face apart, but he recognized me. He recognized Julia by a freckle on her wrist that she always tried to hide, and he told Julia as much.
"You're trying to set him up," I said to Julia after one of those grin-spangled calls between her and Vicente.
"Maybe," she admitted. "But he's not the only one taking notes."
And yes, my brother's face-blindness caused some trouble. But it also caused some magic. He had sent a note to Felix months ago, meaning to help me, and by mistake he'd forged a path.
One evening, months after the party, we sat under the old oak on campus. Felix nudged me.
"What's that mole story?" he asked, playful.
"Vicente uses it to find me," I said. "He likes to tell people that he recognizes me by a mole under my left ear."
Felix smiled, reached out and gently brushed the area. "It's a good mark," he said. "I like it."
"And your proof that you know me?" I teased.
He leaned close. "I remember the mole before I remember anything else," he said quietly. "And I've memorized a dozen other odd things about you—your stubbornness, the way you tuck hair behind your ear when nervous, and your laugh that starts small and then fills a room."
"You mean it loud enough to embarrass me?" I asked.
"Yes," he said, eyes warm. "Especially that."
We sat in silence for a long while. The campus was a little quieter then; finals week had driven some people home. Felix's hand found mine and squeezed.
Later, when I told Vicente the story, he gaped. "You didn't tell him that I told you to say those things," he said.
"Some secrets are better kept," I said.
Felix laughed. "Secrets are nice," he said. "But I'd rather know everything."
"Careful," Vicente said, mock-serious. "Everything can be complicated."
We all laughed. My life had been ridiculous, tragic, and surprisingly sweet. I had been made a fool, scolded, nearly burned on the social stake, and then gently rescued.
In the end, the campus gossip quieted to a hum. Andre and Katelynn fell from pedestal and pretence; both learned the cost of playing with other people's hearts. Felix and I grew something that wasn't perfect but felt honest. Vicente kept being loud. Julia kept being dramatic.
Once, when I was packing up my bag, Felix pressed a small paper into my hand. "For emergencies," he said.
I opened it. Inside, scrawled in tiny handwriting: "If you ever feel like the world is too loud, press this and call me. I'm coming."
I laughed with all my chest. "That's the best emergency plan."
"Yes," he said. "Also, you owe me an official dinner at that awful, fancy hotel you refused to go to."
"I owe the world," I said.
"Start with dinner," he insisted.
We kissed once, small and tentative, under streetlight. It wasn't a movie kiss. It was the kind that made quiet promises.
Weeks later, walking past the cafeteria, Vicente nudged me. "You know how I recognize you," he said.
"Yes," I said.
"And Julia now has that mole idea on her wrist idea? Her little bold makeup trick?" he said, half proud, half teasing.
I sighed and laughed. The world had reshaped around my brother's faults and my own messy choices.
If you asked me which moment changed everything, I'd point to the time Felix dared to play the slow, steady hero. He didn't shout his devotion; he documented small truths and let them do the work. He made sure the people who had hurt me faced consequences. He made sure I had space to rise.
That doesn't mean everything was tidy. My brother kept being a loud, face-muddling hurricane. Julia still plotted ridiculous schemes. One morning, I woke to a voice note from Vicente: "I found a new person you should meet."
"Who's that?" I asked, suspicious.
"A famous barista," he said. "No, kidding. But she has purple hair and a good laugh. I'm sending pictures."
I listened to the pictures and laughed. The world kept moving, ridiculous and bright.
And every time I felt unsure, I pressed Felix's emergency paper in my pocket and thought of the mole by my ear. It was small and stubborn, a fingerprint of me.
"Remember," Vicente would say, "the mole is the contract."
"Yeah," I would answer. "And the contract is you promising not to make a bigger mess next time."
He grinned like he meant it.
Sometimes life is messy because the right people push into it. Sometimes someone with a loud voice and the wrong ability to recognize faces causes chaos. And sometimes that chaos brings you a breakfast, a recorded confession, and the strangest beginning.
I kept the mole story as the final code between us. If our life had to be remembered for one unique thing, let it be the mole that announced me to those who couldn't find me otherwise.
"It's my quiet signature," I told Felix once.
He kissed the spot near my ear and said, "It's mine to memorize."
And that felt like the most honest thing in the world.
The End
— Thank you for reading —