Face-Slapping16 min read
"I Stabbed the Woman Who Stole My Name — Then I Smiled"
ButterPicks10 views
"I pulled the hairpin free."
"Stop her!" someone screamed.
I had the whole hall in my hands for one instant — red silk, lantern light, whispers like knives. I pressed the cold metal to my palm and stepped forward until I was close enough to feel her breath.
"You finally leave," I whispered.
Kathryn Gonzalez laughed like a bell. "My dear, you are at your wedding. Calm down."
"Not my wedding," I said. "Not my life."
She gave me that mild look a woman gives a servant who missteps. Her daughters and the housewomen circled like sheep. My foster nurses gasped behind the screens. My heart hammered like a trapped thing.
"I will not let you steal what you stole," I told her.
"You are hysterical," she said. "Someone take her."
A maid lunged and my hairpin slipped. I swung the last bit of courage I had.
The pin flew. It hit her breastbone.
For half a beat she froze, a surprised little hole in her silk. Then she staggered. The hall gasped in a single long sound.
Someone screamed, "Kill her! Kill her!"
Hands crushed my arms. The hairpin clattered to the floor. I tasted iron in the air and finally I let myself fall.
They called it madness. Kathryn called for my arrest. I heard my own voice far away, chanting, "My mother is dead — you are a thief." I remember the jade of the floor against my cheek, the lanterns blurring. Then an odd quiet, a ringing bell, and the world folded.
When I opened my eyes, the sky was raw and the ground smelled of snow.
"You're alive," a voice said.
I pushed myself up and found no wound where I'd fallen. My throat closed.
"What's your name?" the voice asked.
"I—" I looked down at the sleeve of my robe and at the signet ring I'd been given as a child. The old story had been told so many times lately: a lost girl returned to her birth house, a match, a salt of relief for the family. But I remembered the alley cold, the foster mother's cookstove, the small white necklace my foster father had given me. I remembered being taken, welcomed, used.
"My name is Marina Carpenter," I said. "I am Grant Vincent's eldest girl."
Grant Vincent, my father, knelt beside the bed. He smelled of wind and iron and something like oak. He took my hand like a man holding a blade and said nothing.
Later, the house argued. Old emerald-haired Grandmother Emerald Giordano watched us both like an oracle. "She looks like the story," she said finally. "Bring her in. Let us see."
"She must be taught," Kathryn said, voice a silk scythe. "She came from the fields. She needs training. She can sit in the second room."
"She is my granddaughter," Grandmother said.
"She is our family," Grant said.
A few days later the whole house was a stage. I learned curtseys and how to pronounce "yes" with the right tilt. I learned to fold a napkin into a flower and to laugh at jokes that were not funny.
"Why do you do all this?" my foster father asked one night as he patched a wound on my palm where a seam had rubbed.
"Because they gave me a name and took a life," I said. "Because they traded me like a thing."
"You should let it go," he said, gently.
"I cannot," I said. "Not now."
It was strange to be the one everyone watched. Kathryn taught me with a smile that scraped like sandpaper. Chelsea Bruno — my half sister — smiled too, as if she owned the world. She sang and wore bright ribbons and played at being delicate. The servants watched me with hungry eyes. A few were kind. Sarah Carpenter, the housemaid who always smelled of warm bread, took to me the way a tree takes moss.
"Don't show them you're angry," she warned. "You'll give them a place to stab."
"Don't worry," I said. "I will make my place."
Two nights after I learned to fold napkins, I tripped over a masked man in the garden.
"Stay away," he hissed, and then he laughed like someone who'd found a joke.
He wore a silver fox mask. His clothes were torn, and he was gashed on the side. Snow stained the white around him.
"You're hurt," I said.
He eyed me with something like hunger and then something like relief. "You saved me," he said. "You sewed a man into the belly of a cart and drove him to the doctor?"
"I am no thief of men," I answered. "Who are you?"
He pulled off his glove and placed a warm jade pendant in my palm. "If you are ever in trouble, find the man with this mark," he said. "The rest I will tell later. For now— go."
He left like a shadow. The pendant was heavy, green and alive. I slid it into my inner robe and tried not to think of running the moment I saw my reflection.
Days later, when the city breath smelled of winter woodsmoke, a banner arrived: the Emperor had chosen. I was to be given to DENNIS LOPEZ, the Prince, as bride.
Stars dropped from my stomach. "A prince is a path or a blade," my foster father told me. "If he loves you, he is a lantern. If he does not, he is a spear."
Dennis Lopez arrived with a bowed head and curious eyes. He was small and clear-faced, and he watched me like a child seeing snow for the first time.
"You are very beautiful," he said, without ceremony. "Do you like sweets?"
I ended up teaching him how to chew sugar without making a face. He asked for more like a hungry bird, and I put more on his plate.
There was a strange warmth about him that made the house less cold. When Kathryn saw him smile at me, the lines at the corners of her mouth tightened like a trap spring.
"She was brought back for a reason," Kathryn said to any who would listen. "She will be our offering."
"An offering?" the Grandmother said. "You mean a bride."
"Yes," Kathryn answered. "A match."
I learned to bow. I learned to keep silence when knives were being whetted. At night I rose like steam through the rooms of the house, listening for voices. Once I overheard her in the corridor.
"The old daughter would have suited better," she said into the dark. "But the plan stands. Grant Vincent will not protest when he sees the gifts."
"Do you mean mother?" I said sharply from the doorway.
She started as if I'd slapped her. "Marina—" she began, and then she smiled like a cat. "You should rest."
I planned slowly. I planted my temper like seed. I let them think I was theirs.
Kathryn's plan wasn't only for the prince. It was older than she was. Years ago she had taken my true mother away. She had stirred rumors and given gifts until the family agreed to reclaim the lost girl — me. I was meant to be a quiet thing to be used. Worse, they wanted to move Chelsea aside later and have her marry the prince. I could imagine the chessboard: I as pawn, Chelsea as queen. I would not be someone else's pawn.
"Whatever they do to me," I told Sarah one night, "I'll make them wish they had never opened their mouths."
"You already have," she said. "But you must be patient."
I learned patience with a taste like iron.
Winter came harder. Kathryn sent a maid in with hot porridge, her voice honeyed.
"Eat," she said. "It will warm you."
Sarah watched the bowl. "This smells wrong," she whispered.
"It's too late," Kathryn said, smiling. "You are new. We must see to your health."
The porridge tasted of bark. My pulse jumped. I almost choked.
"Stop," a voice said. The door burst open and a man in black robes stepped in. He smelled of herbs and storm. He bent to the bowl, sniffed, and smiled a small, very cold smile.
"I am CHU STARLING," he announced. "The prince sent me."
Chatter rose, sharp as knives. Kathryn's false face cracked.
"You sent for—?" Kathryn stammered.
"Someone must be punished for this," Chu said. He took the bowl and looked at Kathryn with an easy disdain. "Do you know what you've given her? This belongs in a healer's hand, not a housewife's."
"What is it?" Grant demanded.
"A stimulant," Chu said. "Given in the wrong body, it can burn the person from the inside. If she had taken it every day, she may have been put in the ground before the emissary left."
The hall burned with a new silence. Kathryn's hands trembled. Chelsea's teeth showed in a forced smile. The Grandmother's eyes were cold as winter.
"Who gave it?" the Grandmother asked.
Kathryn knelt as if struck. "I only wanted to help," she said. "I feared she was weak."
"Your staff claims you bought the herbs from the green market," Chu said. "Lie to a doctor, and you'll find your lies in the open."
"You—" Kathryn tried to stand.
Dennis stepped forward, and for the first time his voice wasn't the bird's warble. "Do not touch her," he told Kathryn. "You broke the rules."
"Rules?" Kathryn laughed, the sound sharp. "You are a prince's match. You do not speak."
"I am her husband-to-be in every way that counts," he said. "She is mine. You will not kill her in my walls."
There was a tremor in the room like a phone line snapping. People shifted. Someone in the corner whispered, "The prince protects her." Heads turned.
Kathryn's face went white. She slipped from heat into something raw and wet. When she tried to deny, the Grandmother put down her fan.
"Enough," Emerald said in that small voice that always cut.
"I will make this public," I said softly. "Bring everyone."
They did, grudgingly. They filled the great hall when I said the word, all the noses and jewels and watchful eyes. I picked up pieces of the porridge pot, found the exact root that had been ground, named the herb by taste alone — an odd habit from my years with the healers who taught my foster father. Kathryn's mouth fell.
"She knows herbs," Kathryn whispered.
"I remember," I said. "The woman she killed was my mother. She was not an accident. She fell ill suddenly and Kathryn stooped to whisper a man at a time. They called it care."
A murmur ran like a cold wind around the room. Chelsea looked at me as if a cat had spoken. Kathryn tried to speak but the sound was thin.
"Who will believe you?" someone asked.
Dennis pushed forward until he stood with his hands folded, innocent as a child and dangerous as a lion. "I believe her," he said. "The Emperor believes in justice. I ask the Emperor's men to witness this household's faults. If there is theft of life, it will be found."
That night, they spared Kathryn a public trial, but she had been clipped. She had to confess in front of the Grandmother and the house. The servants watched with mouths open. Kathryn's face moved from pale to red to green and then collapsed into disgrace. She cried and begged for my forgiveness on her knees, and for two long hours the house listened to her supplication like a play.
But the greatest blow did not come from tears.
"Name what you took," I said.
She said "I've taken nothing" at first.
Then, with a voice like a dropped bowl, she began to name things: jewelry secreted away, contracts forged, a woman hidden who told a different story—an old servant who swore she'd found payments from Kathryn to men outside the house. The Grandmother's face was a pale mask. Where Kathryn had once sat richly, now thin hands trembled and the gold in her belt was counted. The Head Steward put a small paper which read: "All valuables in the name of Kathryn Gonzalez are frozen."
Faces changed. Her daughters looked at her with the blankness of people meeting a stranger.
"Please," she whispered. "I did this for my daughters."
"A mother who kills a mother to give her daughter a station," the Grandmother said. "She is not a mother at all."
"Then punish her," someone cried.
That afternoon they took her pad of notes, her seals, her silver. The house buzzed and someone shouted that the city council would take her trade licenses. The old steward walked out and put his back to her. Her allies fled like stags.
"She cannot keep anything," I said. "She will answer. She will lose the position, the lands, the servants. She will not wear my hairpins."
They hurled her from power. Her daughters were stripped of some public displays. The Grandmother ordered that Kathryn's rooms be emptied and that her signet be taken. A small crowd formed to watch the carts. We watched them load trunks into a wagon. Kathryn's cries rose and then fell.
In the street, the steward's son spat. "You used people like stones," he said.
"I wanted my daughters a future," Kathryn wailed. "I only wanted to give them security!"
"Not by stealing life," I said. "Not by staining a house with a mother's widow's blood."
She fell to her knees in the dust of the road. People took out their tablets and marveled, but the city law was a slow beast. Kathryn's public disgrace was immediate: her friends turned away, her jewels were seized, and within three days her name was whispered with the word "poisoner" beside it.
Chelsea disappeared into the rooms and we did not see her for a time. The servants who had helped Kathryn were punished by the steward's hand. They were marched out. Their laughter in the kitchens stopped.
"You wanted to be invisible," I told them once. "You are not."
Dennis never stopped looking at me with that raw, open adoration. The prince surprised everyone by walking into the house each day, sitting beside me, holding my hand under the table.
"You are my wife," he told me once, flat, in the corner of the tea room. "No one can say otherwise."
It felt like a promise.
But Kathryn's defeat was a seed. Some men grow back like weeds.
Three months later, just before the big public banquet called the Hundred Flowers Gala, I was accused of stealing a prized needle from the house — the needle that had a carved circle on its end. It was proof, they said, that the old story was a lie. The accusation came from an unlikely place — the Grandmother's mouth. Her nurse, an old woman with a rusted smile, had found the needle in my room and insisted I explain.
"Why put the needle in my room?" I asked.
Kathryn's shadow could still be felt. "Whoever found it must show the proof," I said.
They set a time: the Hundred Flowers Gala, where the Emperor's circle and city lords would patronize the house. My punishment was to be unveiled there, in front of the guests.
I sat at my corner of the long table, cheeks hollow, while Chelsea smiled like a painted bird. The Prince came and sat on my right as usual, his face patient as a child's when shamed.
"Play as you always do," he mouthed. "We will be fine."
I nodded. I had worked three months to create the trap. Face-slapping required a stage, and a stage had been set.
"In honor of the Gala," the steward announced, "we will mark those who keep the house honest."
There was applause. I stood and went to the center, a small paper in my hand.
"People of the house," I called, and the crowd quieted, turned toward me as the moon turned to a new face. I went slow. I unrolled the paper and shoved it into the steward's hands. It was a list of names of people who had been paid by Kathryn. It had dates. It had signatures in her hand. The steward paled.
"These are forgeries," Kathryn cried.
"No," I said. "Let us ask the city clerk."
The clerk nodded. "The handwriting matches samples," she said. "The stamps were bought in the market with coins from the house."
Gasps. She was breathing too quick.
"Let us show the needle," I said.
They brought the needle forward on a velvet cloth. Everyone watched its tiny circle. I picked it up.
"This needle was found next to the pot of herb paste fed to the old mother, the night she died," I said. "I wore it as a child. The pattern is the same. It ties two stories together."
"She framed you!" someone shouted.
"She framed me," Kathryn sobbed. "No— no!"
"Bring in the witnesses," the steward ordered.
They called the gardener who had been paid to bury an old woman's letters. They called the smith who had melted down two coins and used them in a chain she had bought secretly. Each person told the same story: Kathryn had taken small sums, coerced people, paid men to whisper.
Her face drained of color. Her daughters' hands went white.
"Mercy," she said. "I wanted my children to be secure."
"You wanted their names," I said, very low. "You took names like coins. You sold them in the dark."
The steward, annoyed at how his house had become a stage of scandal, made a simple decree: Kathryn's seals were to be burnt. Her signet ring would be hammered into a slab. Her name would not be used forward in any official lists. The Grandmother, who had been kind and gullible, stepped forward and spoke in a voice that made people bow.
"Let the court decide," Emerald said. "But let the household not bear the stain."
Kathryn's mouth opened and closed. She looked at Chelsea. "What will you do?" she begged.
Chelsea only looked away.
"Forgive me," Kathryn begged me.
I looked at her for a long time. The room was very quiet. Dennis's fingers shifted in mine, making a small circle of warmth.
"I won't undo the past for you," I said. "I will let the law do what it must. But understand this — you took a mother's life and used it for trinkets. You must lose the things you took. Lose your friends. Lose the house. Lose the name you stole. But if you step beyond the law..."
She bowed so low her forehead hit the floor.
"Please," she begged. "Please—"
"Not in my house," I said.
The humiliation was slow and complete. Her social circle dissolved in days. The steward called the council. Kathryn's husband — a man with a dull face who had favored the quiet ways of ledger books — took their daughters and left for a smaller house. They left without the servants they had once commanded. Kathryn's name was tied to nights and herbs and whispers.
When the council finally met, Kathryn found herself standing at the public bench with nothing but a thin shawl. The judge read pages. The city seals were blotted on paper. They stripped her of her steward title. She begged. The crowd watched as she was led away with hands that had once brushed the prince's robes. People spat. Some shouted. Others took bets on how fast she would be forgotten.
But I did not let it be only public law. I had a private sword.
"Tell them what you did," I said to the woman who had taken the old mother's letters.
"I can't," she said, voice trembling. "They will kill me."
"You'll stand with me," I said. "You will tell the truth."
They did. One by one, she named men Kathryn had paid, the nights she had sent poisoned bowls into the kitchens, the moment she had tipped a candle to make a woman slip. Each confession sounded like breaking glass.
They dragged Kathryn into the street. People thrust coins and curses. Someone hit her with a mud pie. A servant spat. Her hair came loose and fell into the dirt. The man who had been her lover turned away. Her small pile of things was scattered — jewelry stripped from her, costumes cast onto the ground. She knelt and pulled at the dirt with finger nails, trying to find something to clutch.
"You want to live," she wheeled her face, wild-eyed. "Please—"
"Let the public see," I said.
They lifted her by the collar and paraded her before the very people whose trust she'd stolen. Someone recorded the moment on a long scroll and passed it from hand to hand like gossip in a market. The steward read out the items found in her trunk as if reciting a ledger. Her daughters watched without helping. Chelsea covered her face with a hand and slipped away.
"Why are you so unkind?" Kathryn cried one last time.
"Because you were unkind," I said. "You were selfish. You stole a life. You used a girl's name for a bargain."
She started to weep, then to scream, then to beg, then to drool. She knelt and grabbed at my robe as if that would stop the falling.
"Don't touch me," I said. "You took my mother. You do not touch me."
They left her in the square. Men threw her cloaks into a ditch, and she crawled after them like a dog. The city talk lasted for a long week.
After the dust settled, the house rearranged itself. The Grandmother made me sit at a higher chair. The steward re-tied the locks. The servants who had been loyal were rewarded. Sarah Carpenter received a ribbon and a small pouch of money. The head cook made a new soup.
Dennis did not change, except that he smiled at me more as if relief had softened him. "You did it," he said one afternoon, pressing his forehead to mine. "You held your ground."
"I didn't want this," I told him. "I used the tools I had."
"You used yourself too," he said. "You are the bravest person I know."
Sometimes he was stupid — he would say plainly that he desired me in front of three ladies and a duke — but his silliness was a shield. He did not understand cruelty. He understood only the metrics of care: warm blankets, soft words, a cookie hidden in his sleeve for me.
"Will you marry me?" he asked once, anxious as a child.
"I am already promised," I said. "But yes. Still."
Letters came later from the city court: Kathryn's lands were seized and parceled to charity; her name became a shorthand for greed. People spat less and looked away more. Her daughters' prospects dimmed.
We continued, with caution. I took a small part of the house for my foster parents, and they moved into a little flat by the river. My foster father opened a small healing stall near the temple. He bowed to me every day with a pride I once thought impossible.
"What about the silver fox?" I asked Sarah one night, thinking of that masked man.
"Who?" she asked.
"Silver fox. The man who saved me in the snow."
"Ah," she said with a smile. "He came to deliver your foster parents a message. He said they'd have help. He said he'd be by when needed."
Weeks later, when the city was quieter, a man in a fox mask stood in my garden. He removed it and smiled crookedly.
"You come," I said.
He tipped the mask. "We are useful to one another," he said. "You are braver than you seem."
"I had no choice," I said.
"You make choices now," he said. "Most do not."
He introduced himself as EVREN CHURCH, and with his people the small problems — those hired thugs and the anonymous knives — ceased. He was not the prince, and he did not wear silk. He wore a black coat and had a laugh like a rusty bell. He taught me how to hold a blade so a hand would not shake.
"You never were a willow," he said once, spinning a coin. "You are a staff. Do not bend unless you must."
When the Emperor asked for the wedding to proceed, the house prepared. The day of the wedding, the hall glowed like a bowl of sunlight. I threaded through the ceremony like a woman who had learned to play a dangerous harp. I placed flowers on the altar. Dennis took my hand and I felt the steady beat of his palm.
"Do you love me?" he whispered.
"I love myself enough to love you," I said.
After we married, I stood at my old mother's grave, under a ribbon of willow. I took out the small hairpin I had once used and twisted it in my fingers.
"You were stolen," I told the earth beneath my palm. "They lost, they paid. I will not make my life someone else's pawn. Not again."
I drove the hairpin into the ground, then stood and tied a red thread around the willow's branch — the same color as a wedding ribbon. The image made me smile. It was a small thing, private and sharp.
"You're smiling," Dennis said from the path.
"I am," I said. "I am smiling because I decided how to live."
Years later, people would say that the house changed the day I walked in ready to die instead of shut my mouth. Kathryn vanished into a legal fog. Chelsea married a minor scholar and left the pomp behind. Some called me cruel for the way I had moved; some called me wise. I did not mind the names.
"What do you want now?" Dennis asked once, as we sat in the garden with our child asleep in the house.
"I want to rest," I said. "And to be left alone to watch the roses grow."
"You deserve that," he said.
"One last thing," I added, thinking of all the hands that had touched my life like notes in a song. I took from my hair the pendant the fox had given me and dropped it into the pond.
"Why?" Dennis asked.
"Because I will not owe anymore to shadows," I said. "If they come, I will meet them with steel, not with debt."
He kissed my forehead. "Then we will both be ready."
I learned that to make them fall, you do not need to be loud. You need to be patient, and you need to make the house witness what it already knew in its bones.
When the Grandmother placed a small box on my lap for the child years later, I opened it to find the very needle she had used all those years ago. It was bent a little now.
"Keep it," she said with a small smile. "Let it remind you we call things by their names here."
I put it away and felt the weight of all our victories and losses like a silk over my shoulders. I had no mother's face to return to, but I had my own. I had the prince, who was sometimes laughably simple and sometimes like a child with a sword. I had the house, which would not be broken again.
The last thing I did as the sun set on the yard and the lanterns flickered like small truths was drop a small hairpin into the pond — the hairpin I had used to stab and the hairpin I had used to plant. It vanished in a tiny sound like a sigh.
"Do you ever wish for her to suffer more?" Dennis asked once, and I looked at him and smiled crooked.
"Some," I admitted. "But then I think of my child and the water of the pond and the way the house sleeps, and I know punishment is not a feast. It is a lesson."
"Then it's done," he said. "For now."
We walked back into the house. I turned once and saw the willow with its red thread swaying. I had taken back my name, my future, and my small joy.
The court had stamped its papers. The streets had their talk. Kathryn's name was carried by wind like a dry leaf. I was not the girl who pushed a hairpin from a palm. I was Marina Carpenter, who had learned to use a hairpin as a tool, a voice, a way out.
And when people asked how I had survived, I told them simply:
"I showed them the truth."
The End
— Thank you for reading —