Sweet Romance11 min read
Hot Milk, Broken Teeth, and a Quiet Rescue
ButterPicks14 views
"Open wide."
I obeyed because it felt safer to obey. The white light above me made everything flat and simple, and the cool instrument in my mouth made my voice small.
"Good," he said, and his voice was the exact voice I had memorized from another life. "Hold still."
I kept still. "Nehemias," I said afterward, because the moment had to be named. My mouth tasted of metal and mint.
"Emilia," he replied, almost a hush. "Three cavities."
"Three?" I managed. "Is that bad?"
"One needs work today," he said. "The others are fine for now."
Lucy, the nurse, smiled at me like she was on my side. "Don't worry. He'll be gentle."
I wanted to be offended that my ex had turned into my dentist, but the dentist—Nehemias Chambers—only looked like a man who had forgotten how to be loud. He looked smaller in a white coat than he used to in a suit. He had the same high nose, same fine lips. His eyes were still a careful harbor.
"You took your sweet time," I whispered.
"Traffic," he said. He didn't smile the old way. He adjusted the lamp.
Amelia called me at lunch, chirpy and impossible. "Em, you are not going to believe this—your dentist is famous for being gorgeous. You should have picked someone worse to like."
"I liked worse things," I told her. "I chose not to pick a dentist at all."
"Be bold! Be shameless," she said. "Go flirt."
I laughed into my sleeve and thought of the elevator that morning, the phone call she made me take, and the small electric shock when I had looked up to find a man in a white coat. I thought I had avoided him. Fate had different ideas.
After the cleaning, Nehemias handed me a slip with the work to be done. He wrote in tidy letters: fill the deep cavity next week, two minor fillings next month. At the bottom, in smaller print, he wrote one more thing and then handed it to me without comment.
"Message if it hurts," he said.
I stared at the slip in my hand. "You're still using that tone you used in college," I said.
He peered over his glasses, his mouth almost hidden by the mask. "I have more practice now."
That evening my mother arranged a blind date. "Just go," she said. "It's polite." Amelia tutted and dared me with a grin whenever she could.
The restaurant was small, home-cooked food, wooden panels. I sat down across from a man named Everest Garnier. He smiled like that would be enough. He was warm and pleasant; we talked about food, about books, about silly things.
"And you write, right? I read something like your name on a campus blog once," he said.
"Work," I said lightly. "I write for a living."
He nodded. He was gentle. I liked gentle. He offered to order. We laughed.
Then I saw him through the glow—Nehemias, leaning against the corner, sleeves rolled just so, glasses off. He watched us, not like a man who wanted to be noticed, but like someone studying a map.
I had practiced how to be graceful for this moment. I had not planned on the way my heart shuffled like a badly packed suitcase.
He didn't come over. He didn't need to. Later, when he did, a woman at his side called him "Mr. Chambers" with a well-practiced fluency I couldn't name.
"You're Emilia, right?" the woman asked.
I forced a smile. "Yes."
"He's sick today," she said. "Maybe that's why he's so quiet." She moved away.
Nehemias had that impossible look again—half moon smile, then gone. "Sit," he said. "Please. I can talk for a minute."
"You're very prescient," I said. "I didn't expect to see you here."
He didn't look pleased. "It was custody of chance," he said. "Don't make me sound clever."
"Do you still hate me?" I asked, because the old arguments were between us like weather: storms that arrived late and stayed longer than they should.
He did not grin. "No." He looked tired. "Have you been... eating sugar?" he asked with the sort of clinical interest that had always been his way to keep a channel open between us.
"I have been human," I said.
Everest leaned in across the table. "Are you okay?" he asked, and something in his voice suggested he already cared.
"I am," I lied. The past three years had taught me how to be a decent liar when needed.
After the meal I walked home in a daze. At the corner by the little shop, a man in a shadowy jacket was lit by the faint streetlamp. He had something small and bright in his hand—a lighter—and his fingers made a quick, practiced motion. Fire, then darkness. The silhouette was familiar. Nehemias always looked like a photograph half-developed; you always found more when you waited.
I called Amelia. "He was there," I said. "At the restaurant."
"Nehemias?" she squealed. "You liar, you didn't tell me. Why didn't you tell me?"
"I thought I had," I said.
"You always think you have," she said. "Come out with me."
Before long the door buzzer dinged. There was a bag at the door. It was the little weekly care package Amelia always sent: tea, honey, a pint of milk, warming things for the body. She was obsessive the way only true friends can be.
That night I messaged Emmett Gentile, a senior from my grad days. He answered in the pleasant way of someone who liked neat lists. We agreed to meet because he wanted to visit an old professor's grave. He came with a woman on his arm, Daniela Chen—quiet, kind, a mirror of calm. Emmett looked the same but a little softer. He smiled like a boy who had a secret.
"You two know each other?" Daniela asked, and there was a ripple of recognition.
"Just a little," I said.
I had a memory of a time when I had found a post on a campus forum: a smear, screenshots crudely stitched together, accusations that could not be true. The post had exploded like a cold match thrown into dry tinder.
"Do you remember one of the names?" I asked Emmett later.
"Erick Hart?" he said slowly as if tasting paper. "I remember him."
"Jules Chang," Daniela said, voice tight.
They had hurt Nehemias. They had tried to burn him with fake pages and false stories. At the time, I had felt the heat of it, but so had Nehemias. He had handled things in a way that taught me almost everything I knew about patience.
"Why did they do it?" I asked.
"Power," Emmett said. "Money. The sort of stupid, ugly thing people do when they think they'll get ahead."
I slept poorly. The next morning I had to go back to Nehemias to fix the cavity. He was quieter, his voice rough from lack of sleep.
"Are you sure you're okay?" I asked.
He looked at me like I had asked him to measure a storm. "You really don't know," he said.
"Know what?"
"That someone told me you might be on a list of people they watch," he said. "So I paid attention."
I blinked. "You're a sentinel now?"
He shrugged. "I pay attention to the people I used to know."
He worked with a slow, careful mercy that made the tools seem less sharp. Lucy handed him instruments. He never once let his hands shake. He told me to rest and gave me a paper with instructions—an old-fashioned thing to hold onto. In the corner were his notes: 1110, 760, 395. Numbers that meant nothing to everyone else.
I left feeling oddly reassembled, like a broken mug glued again.
A few days later, Emmett arranged a small alumni meet. We were crowded into a lounge that smelled of coffee and old books. I was restless. Then, in the dim corner of a room full of old pears of conversation, I saw Nehemias leaning on a wall as if he had become the room.
He looked smaller up close; he looked better. He smiled when he saw me, and I felt something inside me catch fire, a childish ember that I had fed in secret for years.
"You're fragile around him," Amelia had told me the week before. "It shows."
I hated that she was right and could not hate the truth.
"Why didn't you go away?" I asked one night when we were both walking and the city was thin as paper.
He sighed. "I booked a flight when I heard," he said. "My mother called from across the ocean. She said I had to come home and do the sensible thing. But I couldn't do that without making sure you were okay. I don't pretend to be a hero."
"So you waited," I said.
"I waited," he confirmed. "And I planted lights."
"You..."
"Yes. The shop light, the milk, the little packages," he said. "I asked the woman down the street—Helen—to keep a light on for you at night. I couldn't tell you, Emilia. I knew what we'd promised. I knew how proud and stubborn you'd be."
I thought about the night I had bled for days, the one time the world had tilted under me and I had woken to someone saying my name. He had been on the plane.
"You are a coward," I told him.
"No," he said simply. "I am a man who is afraid of losing what he loves."
It is a small mercy to watch a person confess. It is a rarer mercy to see that person keep their promises in small ways: repairing a lamp, slipping a hot milk to a guarded friend, buying two weeks' worth of cough medicine and leaving it at a door. Each was an act small enough to be eaten by the days and big enough to save me.
"Why didn't you text?" I asked.
"I tried," he said. "And then I stopped. I was ashamed. I thought if I waited long enough, time would do us no harm."
It was the perfect coward's plan.
"I can forgive you for being afraid," I told him. "But not for not telling me."
He laughed, a sound like something breaking at last. "I deserve that."
And then the day came when the past came back and insisted on a reckoning.
The alumni hall was hosting a charity lecture. The talk devolved into a mix of platitudes and polite applause. Then Emmett stood up with a large, firm envelope. "There are things left to say," he announced. The room shifted. "There is a campus rumor that ruined a young doctor's reputation years ago. We have a responsibility—especially as people who care about truth—to clear the air."
He signaled to the projector. Slides of screenshots, timestamps, cross-checked messages unspooled across the wall. The room bent forward the way a flock leans to a new leader. "Erick Hart and Jules Chang circulated false claims and doctored images about Nehemias," Emmett said. "They did it to gain favor with parties who would profit from gossip. They used private messages, forged timestamps, convinced people to post under anonymity. They did this deliberately."
There was a low noise that could have been a gasp, could have been a cough. The door closed like a mouth sealing shut.
Erick Hart, a man in a suit whose hair had been a sign of effortless advantage since college, stood, face beige with shock.
"What is this?" Erick demanded. "This is slander."
"Look closer," Emmett said. "We have logs. We traced payment trails, IP addresses, bank transfers. Everything is here. These aren't just rumors. They were a campaign."
"You're lying," Jules cried out, the color leaving her face. Her voice trembled and fell like a dropped plate.
"Beatrice," Emmett said quietly. "They paid for fake stories through an account connected to you both. You told campus moderators that the posts came from multiple people. You paid someone—you both did."
The crowd murmured. "Show the transfer," someone shouted.
Emmett did. A photo of a transfer receipt flashed. Names, dates, banks—coldly factual. The auditorium was suddenly a stage for a public undoing.
Erick's face rearranged itself in a paniced sequence. First he tried arrogance. "This is ridiculous. You have no right—"
Emmett held up his hand. "We have every right to demand honesty." He turned to the projector. "Read the first message, please."
A private message popped up. Jules Chang had written: "Do it tonight. Nobody will check." Erick typed back: "Good. He can't fight us."
"Look at your face," Daniela said from the audience, her voice sharp with a final, personal verdict. "Look at what you did to him."
"People are recording," someone said. Phones were raised like lances. A ripple of clicking spread: snapshots, videos, the digital chorus of witnesses.
Erick tried rage. "You'll regret this," he spat. "I can sue you."
"Try," Emmett said. "But the facts are not yours to own."
The punishment was slow and public. It was different from a legal judgment because it belonged to the court of everyone present. The dean stood up with a brow like a hinge. "This was a grave abuse of trust," he said. "Erick Hart and Jules Chang will be sanctioned. Their names will be removed from committee lists. Their donor privileges are suspended pending further inquiry. The university does not entertain conspiracies for profit."
Erick's mouth opened and shut. He went from haughty to pale to pleading in the span of breaths. "Please," he said. "I'm sorry. It was a joke. We didn't mean—"
His eyes darted everywhere, desperate to find a place to land. People in the room shifted, some nodding, some shaking heads, some whispering. Jules's shoulders curled in pain and outrage. She went from stunned to fever-bright denial to the glossy pleading that always looks so fake beneath stress.
"I didn't do this alone!" she cried, then sobbed, "We were... we wanted to be noticed."
"Noticed at the cost of someone else?" someone shouted.
A woman in the front row, who had once been one of Nehemias's patients, stood. "You nearly ruined his life," she said. "Do you have any idea what you stole from him?" Her voice trembled like a violin string.
Around them, the crowd's mood tightened. Phones clicked. Faces turned. A man who had once admired Erick as a peer now looked as if he had been punched.
Erick lunged for a paid statement, for damage control. "I'll offer restitution!" he cried. "I'll donate money to charity—"
"Your money doesn't remove the nights he couldn't sleep," Daniela said. "It doesn't fix the trust you broke."
Erick tried to talk about how it had been a power move. He tried to talk about influence and positioning. He tried to say it had all gotten out of hand. The room closed on him. He begged for forgiveness like someone trying to return a broken object to a store.
"Forgiveness is not the same as consequence," Emmett said. "You will face both."
What followed was small and devastating and perfectly public. The alumni board voted to remove Erick from leadership positions. Jules's grant applications were shelved. A stream of old contacts unclasped themselves like people pulling fingers away from a hot surface. Video clips of the exchange spread beyond the hall. The comments, once cruel against Nehemias, now turned against the conspirators with the righteous clarity of a communal conscience.
Erick's reaction changed like weather. He first glowered, then lashed out in anger, then tried to bargain, then froze, and finally, he crumpled into pleading.
"Please," he begged as cameras rolled. "Please, I didn't think—"
"Hold still," Daniela said softly. "No, you don't get to cry now."
An older professor who had watched Nehemias grow up stood and spoke for him. "I apologize to Nehemias," the professor said. "We failed him as mentors. We will correct that."
Around the hall, the sound was not triumph but a slow, cleansing release. People clapped. Some cried. Others simply exhaled, the kind of collective breath a room takes when a storm moves out of the way.
Erick and Jules left under a whisper of shame. Their faces were pale, their composure gone. They had been powerful once; now their reach was visibly shortened. People who had once made room for them now averted their eyes. It was not a violent fall, but it was absolute.
I watched Nehemias from where I sat, my hand in his. He did not gloat. He did not smile with victory. He simply breathed, the breath of someone set right.
"Thank you," he said later when the night had cooled. "For standing."
I looked at him. He was smaller in a white coat, bigger in a suit, different at a desk, the same in the small ways that mattered.
"You took care of me for two years without telling me," I whispered.
"I did," he admitted. "I was so afraid you'd refuse me if I came back with empty hands."
"Then don't be afraid," I said. "Be braver with me."
That night I traced numbers on his wrist—the ones he'd written on my paper: 1110, 760, 395. He laughed softly.
"It's a joke," he said. "They don't mean anything. They were little codes I used to remember to buy the things you liked."
"That's cruelly careful," I said.
"That's me," he said. "Careful, and stupidly in love."
I didn't want a grand speech. I wanted the small things. I wanted him present, steady, folded into my everyday life. I wanted the person who fixed a lamp at midnight and left hot milk at my door to be the person who would answer to my name when I said it.
"Will you try?" I asked.
He looked at me with an earnestness that stunned me. "I will try forever," he said.
We kissed then. It was not a dramatic, movie-kiss. It was a seal of small things done rightly. It tasted of mint and a little of the hot milk he'd come to like. The city outside hummed and continued, unaware of the simple repair happening inside my chest.
Everest and I stayed friends. He became my editor in a small, soft surprise—his calm, steady attentions fit well to deadlines. He was kind and good and backyard-sunny in a way I liked. Emmett and Daniela had a quiet wedding. Lucy remained my nurse and friendly conspirator. Helen still left a light on.
At night, when I walked past the little shop, the lamp burned. Sometimes I played the numbers like a song on my tongue. 1110, 760, 395. They were meaningless and perfect. They were proof that someone had kept a secret vigil.
Nehemias used to say we were two reckless people who had learned how to be careful. Maybe that was true.
Sometimes I would wake at dawn and find a cup of hot milk on my table, still warm. I would smile to myself.
"Thank you," I would whisper to the empty room.
"You're welcome," I imagined him saying in the morning air.
And when I saw him, I said it in person.
"Hot milk," he teased once as he brushed my hair back. "Is that our code now?"
"It will do," I said.
We did not fix all things at once. We fixed small things, and those small things built the house of us. We rebuilt trust like we rebuilt lamps: one careful screw, one patient hand at a time.
The End
— Thank you for reading —