Sweet Romance15 min read
He Picked Me for the Wrong Reason — So I Took the Ring
ButterPicks10 views
I tell myself, out loud as I stand over him, that we should leave. The words come out small and ridiculous in the quiet hospital room.
"Estella," the little one mumbles from my arms, then clicks her tongue—the sound my daughter makes when she's trying to be serious and almost succeeds. "Mom, hurry. The doctor said it's the last day. We can leave."
"I know," I say. I set her down on the sofa and take off the hat and sunglasses I used to hide my face. "You be good and wait here. Don't move."
She nods obediently like a tiny, solemn queen, then tugs at the blanket on the bed and asks, as if reading a story from the ceiling lights, "Why does he look like my nose?"
I freeze. My hands are full of gauze, my fingers startle like they're waking from a long sleep.
"Because," I tell the child, forcing a joke, "maybe he used the same nose maker the stork used when he delivered you."
She pokes his face with a finger—he's sleeping in that dangerous place between breath and not—and continues to critique him like a connoisseur evaluating an apple. "Mom, he's handsome."
"Don't say that about strangers," I say, more sharply than I'd like.
He opens his eyes.
The medicine bottle drops from my hand and a sound that isn't mine breaks out of my throat. He rolls his head as if the world is made of broken glass and remembers, painfully, names and shapes. His voice is thin when he calls it: "Estelle—"
He says the name wrong, and his mouth wants the Chinese endearment he used once, in memories I buried under stubbornness.
"He's calling me by the wrong name," the child whispers, bewildered.
"Shh," I hiss, because I'm afraid he'll see more than he should. He looks up, and his eyes find me like a magnet—they search, and in them there is hunger and something like pity and a jagged, slotted hurt.
"Estella," he says again. "Estella—" and then he coughs and the life in him makes an ugly little sound. My heart starts pounding against my ribs like a fist on the door of a house that has been locked for years.
"This is wrong," I tell myself, and then, while my hands move and the world tilts, I stab him with a sedative I keep for emergencies, because he can't wake—can't risk waking while the ICU doctors still refuse us a surgery date and the rest of the house waits like a jury.
He closes his eyes again. There is relief like water rushed into a dry throat. The thing burned deep in my chest does not cool. Instead it breaks into small sharp pieces that slice me differently.
"Don't let him see you," I whisper to the child. "We leave now."
"Mom—" she protests.
I kiss her temple and run.
---
"If he chooses my daughter," my father said once, all authority collapsing into a tremor, "then the gesture alone will save the house. It will fix things."
They had plans and ledgers and a whole stern history of debts. Caroline Cruz, Laura Dixon and Kassidy Koenig all had husbands and titles and plans. I had one pair of hands and a face I had learned to hide. The papers called me the fourth daughter, a remark, an aside. The house called me a convenience.
So when a man in silver came into the room—composed, dangerous, with a jaw like folded steel and eyes too steady to be kind—I did what any tired person does to the game of chance: I moved the pawn.
"You asked after my daughters," he said when he sat down like he belonged to the room. He measured me as if I were an investment. "I met the third daughter once. She was remarkable."
Kassidy flared like a storm. Laura's eyes became knives; Gage Benton—the man Laura called husband and the boy who'd once been mine—made his face into a line of arithmetic.
I stepped forward and answered with an intentionally dumb thing. "You picked the wrong name. I think you meant Caroline?"
He smiled as if I had presented him with a rare coin. "Which one of them is the fourth?"
I had not expected words like that. I had not expected to be anything but invisible, in the same house as my father's expectations and my sisters' outrage.
So I did the only reckless thing left. I announced myself.
"You don't get to choose," I said, because it would sting. "If you want a family membership, you can pick a policy—money, asset, name. If you want a woman, then say so. If you want a good actress to sign contracts and live under stage lights, take her. But don't come into my home and announce a transfer of ownership like we are furniture."
He laughed. It was small, cruel, and I felt it like a lash across my chest. He walked closer—one step, two—and said, in a voice the room listened to, "Then why don't we test this? Will you marry me?"
"You're insane," I said.
"Then marry me," he said again. "If you accept, I will make you my wife."
"You're mad," I repeated, to say it out loud would be like breaking a glass between us, and then, because there was a man in the room I had loved and who had betrayed me, I did the most theatrical thing I could think of—I kissed him.
It was something I owed the man who had left, to twist him with jealousy before my father signed a contract. The kiss was a performance, and when he pressed his mouth to mine, I kept my eyes on the man across the room who still avoided me. I wanted the look in his eyes when I made him feel the wrongness of his choice.
That first public kiss exploded into a chaos of household shame. The room stung, and every look in it cut and climbed into me like wire.
Later, alone in the stairwell, he hauled me close and shook me like a dry rag. "You can't use me," he hissed. "I don't do possessive games that end badly. You aren't an insurance rider; you are a person."
"I know exactly what you are," I said. "You're a man who trades in risk,reward, and leverage. I wanted to be leverage."
"You wanted to hurt Gage Benton," he corrected.
"Was I wrong?"
"I wanted to control consequence," I admitted then. "I wanted to make him know what abandonment feels like."
He laughed then—not mocking, but something like understanding and something like pity. "Do you always trade with your heart as collateral?"
"Only when it comes to the people who taught me how to hurt."
He surprised me by saying, softly, "Then we are kindred."
"Don't be absurd," I said.
"Then at least let us be practical." He held up a hand. "We will sign something. Terms. Boundaries. I will give you a home, an allowance, an address. I will avoid your old lover. And you will keep the household intact while I obtain what I need."
"And what do you need?" I asked.
"Power," he answered plainly. "And an ally who won't bring me shame."
That was the deal—curt, like a business transaction. But we both knew how hollow such promises could be. I had my own demands: I wanted the emerald bracelet my mother had left; I wanted the right to live where I'd chosen, near the orphanage; I wanted a clean, discreet wedding and a paper that put a limit on how far his hand could cross before my consent. He signed with a smile and an infuriating coolness.
"You will call me Alexander," he said at one point, catching me off guard. "I have heard worse names and better ones. Call me—"
"Mr. Ferrara," I said, because I wanted the formal as a shield.
"Suit yourself," he said with a grin I didn't permit myself to enjoy.
---
"Why marry him?" Laura whispered when I told a friend behind a vending machine.
"Because sometimes, you take the match that will burn the house but salvage you." I didn't tell her about the little life I carried inside quiet time—my child, the one I kept secret because the world liked orders and legalities, not the ways of need.
"You're sure?" she asked.
"Only certainty I have is that I couldn't let them use me as a threat anymore."
So I married Alexander Ferrara in a blur of paper and a shot of courage. The city's tabloids lit up with rumors and with photographs. My face was put into frames like an exhibit. "Alexander Ferrara's Mysterious Bride" said some headlines; "The Fourth Daughter No-One Knew" said others. I felt naked in the glare and strangely relieved.
At the ceremony, I remember him bending and offering me a single spray of white flowers. "Are you satisfied?" he asked.
"For now," I said.
He laughed and said something about not needing much more than my patience. I told him he should be careful—patience is for people with nothing left to give.
We signed an agreement that read like a desperate person's map. He promised the emerald bracelet, promised a small home near the orphanage, promised that he would stay away from Gage Benton. I promised to let him have his business empire—"Bai Jue"—if that calmed the waters.
He agreed to all my demands as if they were trifles. I imagined his laughter later, private and curated. But there were nights when he brought me small kindnesses—he returned the jacket for me at the mall when it was raining, he closed the car door on me like I was something precious he didn't want crumbs on. Once, when a man shouted rude remarks at me on the street, he stepped out of his silver-gray Rolls as if the fog followed him and made him heavy, and his bark was enough to make the man cower away. It was then I saw that the beast inside him could be wickedly good.
"Does he ever get kind?" my daughter asked, watching him hand me a cup of coffee without looking like it was mercy. "He was mean to Daddy's name."
"People are like that," I told her. "Some of them are storms and shelters at once."
"He's a shelter today," she decided, and then paused. "Do I have to call him Mr. Ferrara?"
I laughed.
---
The press conference where the wedding was announced became a crucible. My father and sisters had gathered, their faces painted with an industry of false anger and genuine panic. They tried to bargain with me like I was a ledger.
"Delete the photographs," my father begged the man who had proposed to rescue the family name with money. "We will give you whatever you want—"
Alexander Ferrara sat in a chair like an oracle. The tabloids crouched like wolves.
"Five million," he said plainly, placing a check on the table in front of my father. "And a secure stake in the company. That should help patch what you call bankruptcy."
The family breathed. The offer was heavy magic.
Then I stood up and did the only thing left. I took my phone out and showed them the picture.
"This one," I said, holding the screen like a talisman. "This one is from this morning."
Kassidy's color turned purple. She started to speak and then choked on herself. "You are shameless!" she snapped. "You happen to take a photograph of my—of my private life?"
He answered calmly: "I approved those pictures."
"What?" They all turned to him like a pack of stunned birds.
He smiled. "We had an agreement about guardianship of the narrative. They were taken to allow me leverage over certain parties."
My sisters swore—words like knives. "You—" my father tried to pull at the air, to pull me in pants of repentance.
"Enough," I said.
Then I did the thing I had been learning: I let my voice be clean and loud and simple.
"You will not use your influence to shame me," I said to the room. "You tried to sell me once. You made my life a choice for the house. Alexander did not put me before my own will—" I stopped and then went on, "—but I will not let this family sell its daughter to fix its books."
There was a pause like a breath before a plunge. "What are you going to do?" Kassidy asked.
I smiled. "You'll see."
And then, in a motion that had been practiced in the corners of small revenge fantasies, I put the phone down and pressed the record button. The entire press room could see the screen as I spoke to the dozen cameras arrayed like a jury.
"These are the pictures," I said. "These are not shameful. They are private, yes. But they prove a point your family has not learned: you cannot humiliate someone and expect them to sign a contract with their dignity torn to ribbons."
I uploaded the images and the audio to a secure journalist channel, sent the link to three major blogs. I had done my homework—journalists were greedy for scandal, but also for the counseling twist: a powerful man being honest and a family bartered publicly was a better story than just leaked pornography.
Then I gave them the twist they didn't expect. "If you want those photos back, you will let go. You will stop trying to pressure me in public or private. You will stop telling lies about who I am. And you will hand over what is mine: the emerald bracelet my mother left." My voice was steady. "Or you'll live with them circulating."
My father staggered like someone slapped. "You would—"
"I would," I said. "This house made me into an invisible ledger. I took the ledger and set it on fire. Now you decide whether to watch or to help rebuild without burning people."
The journalists stopped breathing. The sisters made little animal sounds like a sinking chorus.
Kassidy rushed the table like a femme fatale with no plan. "You are a liar!" she screamed.
"Quiet," Alexander said, and his simple command was a recorded moment of power. "Miss Dorsey did not lie. She told the truth."
He turned to my father. "I'll give you the amount we agreed. But only if he signs an affidavit that he never asked for leverage against his children in exchange for cash. I will make sure the records show I gave this for the family, not for blackmail."
For thirty minutes a public bank of the family's shame was exposed. Reporters recorded the change in my father's face from greed to humiliation. Friends and socialites who had eaten from the table in our home began to thin like a flock sensing a storm.
When it was over, the family was a lineup of faces drained of color. I remember the way they looked at me as if I had become a foreign woman in my own skin.
Kassidy's reaction changed in stages: first surprise, then anger, then denial, and finally, horror when the cameras recorded the moment she was cut away from the crowd. She tried to attack me once physically—fingers grasping at my gown for a torn fabric sentiment. Security dragged her back. People watched, some clapping.
My father's face collapsed. "You—how dare you!"
"You sold your daughter," I said. "My mother would not have wanted judge and jury in one room when the truth is this: you traded the name for comfort."
"Estella—" he managed. The room was loud with the clink of silverware and the hum of camera shutters.
And then the last sliver: laughter. People started to laugh at the farce of our family's morals. That was the worst part of all—the sputter of mockery from strangers who would later forget the kindnesses and remember the spectacle.
Alexander walked me out afterward, and for the first time he didn't look like an invader. He looked like someone who'd volunteered to stand in the doorway.
"You made them pay," he said softly.
"I made them choose," I corrected. "Sometimes paying is the only language they understand."
He nodded. "And sometimes she who learns to burn has hands that can mend as well."
It was a triumph, but a hollow one. The house was still standing, but now so many of its beams were scorched that the family had to rebuild, and we both knew rebuilding would take something like time and contrition—things my father did not have.
---
Weeks passed in a blur of jewelry appointments and lawyers. The emerald bracelet—my mother's—was a scarred promise and the single link to the woman who had taught me how to tie my hair and fold my anger into a careful, useful thing. I wanted it back not for vanity but for proof that I belonged to my own history.
Alexander kept his end of the bargain. He handed me deeds and lists and an apartment near the orphanage and the workroom where I volunteered. He took meetings that cut at the edges of his empire so that the press could breathe and fluff a new narrative: The Mysterious Bride Who Stayed Private.
He bought a small gray house near the orphanage and insisted I manage it. I put up shelves and spread books like a hand that had finally learned to plant seeds. I found solace in the practice of nursing and small procedures at the orphanage. I learned to stitch again at night, born from old habit.
"Thank you," I told him once when the sky was thin and blue. He had given me more than he would admit.
"You would have taken it anyway," he said.
"Maybe," I said. "But you made it easier."
"Do you still hate Gage Benton?"
I froze at the name of the man who'd once been my why. "I loved him," I said. "Then he left. Loving and forgetting are not the same."
He only nodded, then leaned close enough that I could hear a whisper. "Let him hurt in the ways he feared," Alexander said. "I will make him understand loss."
"That's cruelty."
"Only if you think revenge has no neatness," he said. "I think it can be an art."
We both laughed, because history teaches us to make armor of jokes.
---
Months later, they came to see the house he had insisted I have built with my name on the mailbox and the orphanage two blocks away. My sisters came like weather, in bright dresses and false smiles, ready to feast on the charity they could turn into publicity.
There was a gala at the city hall that night—a fundraiser for victims of disaster. The guest list included politicians and socialites and, of course, my family. Kassidy would perform. My father would make a speech. It would be the social highlight of the season and the place where fortunes are tallied in subtle glances.
"Come with me," Alexander suggested.
"No," I said. "This is their night."
He persisted. "Come. Be there at the beginning. Take your place. Let me see you shine on your terms."
I agreed reluctantly.
At the gala, the hall shone like a vault. Crystal chandeliers threw light like judgment across expensive fabrics and nervous hands. I walked in with a dress I had chosen—a modest blue like the day I once danced under the wrong sky—and I saw every eye alight and then slide over me, as if searching for screws that would loosen a door.
Kassidy performed. She was beautiful, but there was a brittle edge to her rehearsed smile. My father took the stage with a posture that tried to be gravel and became clay.
"And now," he said, "we celebrate family and charity and new beginnings."
"Good speech," Alexander said in my ear. "Watch this."
I did not expect the sting. He had arranged it all: the event's live feed, the broadcast to an audience of thousands, the gentle nap in the wings. At the end of the speech, Alexander stood.
"Ladies and gentlemen," he said. "I have an announcement tonight."
I felt the room tilt like a ship. They all turned because everything at a gala is about spectacle.
"I promised something to the family," he said. "I promised to help. I honored that promise. But gratitude, I will say, deserves truth."
He gestured lightly, and a dozen screens around the room lit up—broadcast of the family's ledgers, documents showing debts, and then—an image of a document signed years ago: my father's transfer of my mother's property.
Gasps peeled like bells.
"And here," Alexander said, "is proof of a certain transaction that I thought had been a regret. It turns out the city record shows the sale of an heirloom under duress."
Kassidy's face was a carved mask. The audience watched the father who had built his house on lies be revealed. He stammered and tried to speak but the microphones cut him like a scalpel. The cameras zoomed in on his hands; he could not meet a single eye. People were shifting from curiosity to moral verdict.
I stood in the middle of the flash and felt no shame. I had made this choice. I had taken the stage.
"Is this what you call charity?" I asked, loud as a bell. "Turning your daughters into assets and then parading their pain?"
"A mistake!" my father wheezed.
"Who profits from a secret?" Alexander asked. "Not victims. Not those who care."
The crowd leaned like a wind. There were murmurs of disgust that rolled into formal applause. It felt like the world had turned a page in the ledger of my life.
The punishment did not come as handcuffs—this was not a legal scene. It was worse in its social intelligence. My sister's manager walked offstage. Sponsors moved their donations to other causes. Record deals were shelved. The bank that had lent my father a line called his loan and—well—money is a thing that runs very fast when you breathe on it.
Kassidy's reaction was the kind you can only get in stories: first denial, then rage, then cold-blooded bargaining, then a last, small collapse. She approached me under the chandeliers with nails like a bird's talons and shouted, "You ruined me!"
"You ruined yourself," I answered firmly, because I used to believe women were softer and now I would not pretend to be.
And the room watched. People took pictures. Someone called it "a night of reckoning" and printed it the next day.
It lasted a long time—the unspooling of consequence. My father apologized in public. It wasn't enough for some. Alexander closed doors behind which deals stalled. I watched them fall like dominos and felt a terrible, clean satisfaction.
"You did it," my daughter said later as she fingered the emerald bracelet that finally sat on my wrist. "You made them small."
"Sometimes," I told her, "you make rooms quiet so the music can start again."
I had chosen this life. I had chosen this marriage as a weapon and as a sanctuary. Alexander's face had softened in ways that made me dizzy. He no longer spoke of the alliance as an investment. He called me things like "my wife" with an affection that had been slow and cautious.
"Do you love me?" I asked him once when we were alone on the balcony, the city below like something that owed us nothing.
"I protect what I choose," he said. "But I think I might be learning to desire what I didn't know I needed."
"You are impossible," I told him.
"And you," he said, "are the most infuriatingly sensible woman I know."
"You mean charming."
"Charming," he agreed. "In the way a stubborn child is charming when they build a better house."
At night, when the lights from the orphanage shone weak and honest across the street, I would rest my hand on the emerald bracelet and remind myself that some things could be both borrowed and home.
That final evening, after we had stirred up the dust of our family and replanted the garden in truer soil, Alexander reached out and placed his palm over mine.
"Estella," he murmured.
I looked up at him. He had that look again—the one that says a man has finally decided what he will keep.
"I came because I saw a thing I wanted to fix," I said. "I married for a reason that was neat and cruel."
"And?"
"And now," I said, "I think I might want to live a life that is less neat. Maybe with someone who is honest with the ways he hurts—a man who shows his hand so I don't have to guess."
He smiled and put his head down against my shoulder like a child who had been given the spare key to a house.
Outside, the city's night hummed like an old engine. On the table between us lay the little symbol of everything that had been a wedge and now, perhaps, was a bridge—the emerald bracelet my mother wore in a photograph that smelled faintly of the hand that had taught me to tie my shoes.
I slid the bracelet on and the cool band clicked against the skin of my wrist. The world was complicated, and my hands were marked by trade and repair, by stitches and by the small acts of nursing and holding. I had made a bargain; I had made a choice. It had cost me loss and given me a house and a child and a man who could be cruel but could also be kind.
"In this house," Alexander said softly, "you can be whatever you want."
I smiled. "I will not be sold again."
He laughed low and kissed my brow. "I've never been very good at buying anything twice."
Our life began as an arrangement and had folded itself into something that allowed soft mornings and quiet repairs. Sometimes that feels like enough.
The End
— Thank you for reading —