Sweet Romance15 min read
A Life Lived Brightly Without Them
ButterPicks12 views
I was careful for as long as I can remember.
"I know how to be small," I told myself most days, and the sentence became a shield.
When people around me assumed I was an orphan, I didn't correct them. "It's easier," I thought. It saved explanations and spared me the half-second stab of needing to say the names that belonged to two people who loved each other more than they ever loved me.
"My parents," people would ask. "Do they visit?"
"No," I said. "Not often."
They believed me. It was tidy and simple and left less to hurt.
When I was very small, they were everywhere in photographs—laughing under African skies, sharing paint-splattered coffee at dawn, hands touching over a canvas like they owned the whole world. "Two people who can't live in one place without art between them," neighbors would say. "Classic."
"They should've had a child," someone once said, nodding at a gallery catalog.
"They didn't want one," I had heard later, when I was old enough to hear grown-up conversations and pretend I didn’t. "It was an accident," they said as if it explained everything.
"Your mother nearly died," my father told one doctor. "We can't risk anything. If she survives, she should paint."
So I survived. I arrived when they had nearly decided not to, and I stayed while they kept deciding to go.
At one month old my parents left. "We didn't know we could be bad parents," my father later wrote on a postcard from somewhere hot. "Forgive us, it's travel. It helps us live."
They left me with my grandmother, who smelled like lavender and told me stories in the afternoons. On the second night after the paint on my infant cheeks made them red and blistered, the grandmother washed me clean in running water and took me to the hospital. My parents left the next morning with a note on the table: We failed. We need time.
"Time," my grandmother whispered. She kept me in a small apartment, bought me soup and honey, and taught me to hum when the nights were loud. When she died in an accident two years later, I learned the world's cold edges. I learned how small I had to make myself to fit into spaces I wasn't meant to fill.
There were nannies. "Get a professional," my mother had told my father, when she finally looked at a calendar and realized time had marched on without their passports. Hilda Renard was the first. Hilda was good. She could make me stop crying with a cookie and a story. She stayed two years and left because her daughter needed help. She left a key under a fake rock and a stuffed rabbit on my bed.
Another nanny, the one with bad breath and worse patience, learned to punish softly by withholding food. "Kids need discipline," she would mutter. "Too much comfort spoils them." She left me the habit of waiting until school to go to the bathroom because at home I learned to hold myself small.
All of this happened before I began to count years. By the time I was nine, my teacher Annika Burke took me home one day and decided I ate too well under her roof and needed someone who loved me. "Stay for dinner, Gemma," she said. "Then stay another week."
"Can I?" I asked, and I meant it like a promise.
"You're staying," she said, and when I slept on her couch that first week I dreamed of rooms that were warm on purpose. Annika taught me to write my name properly, to read books out loud, and how to make tea the way her grandmother did—steady hands, not rushed.
"You're a smart girl," she would say, tucking covers around my knees. "You can do anything."
When I was twelve and small enough to hide in the crook of her arm, I wrote on the back of my math test in shaky letters: I want a mother. Annika read it and her eyes filled like mine did sometimes. "Then I'll be your mother in the ways that matter now," she said.
It was simple. It wasn't blood. It was a living kindness. In the corners of my growing life, it lit things that had been kept in shadow.
I met Zachary in the playground. "You stole my ship," he joked when he ransacked my Lego pile.
"I didn't steal it," I said.
"Yes you did. You always steal the good parts."
"You can have it." He smiled like someone opened a door and let sunlight in.
He was patient and sure, as if the world owed him nothing and offered everything. "You're Gemma Bowen," he'd say and roll the name like something warm. "You should be treated well."
He taught me math the way Annika taught me tea—step by step with a smile. When I was seventeen and my ankle snapped during PE, Zachary carried books and my pride to the hospital. "Where are your parents?" the nurses asked.
"Somewhere else," I said.
"Someone's got to sign," they said, and I learned that adulthood sometimes requires someone else to put their name on your papers.
"Call Annika," Zachary insisted. He stormed the girl's dormitory, full of a virtue I hadn't expected to see in anyone my age. Annika came and signed, sitting with me through an all-night hospital vigil like she had always been small and had always been able to lift me.
When I cried, Zachary said, "Tell me what hurts. Say it as many times as you need."
"You'd be bored," I said.
"Not if it's you," he answered.
Later, in the quiet of my dormitory, I changed my name. "My name makes me remember things I don't want," I told the clerk at the records office. "I want to be someone who chooses."
"What's your new name?" the clerk asked and pretended not to know me already.
"Gemma Bowen will do," I lied half to myself and half to the formality. "No—call me Gem." I practiced saying it and the syllables felt cleaner.
"Gem," Zachary said later, and the new sound warmed like daylight through thin curtains.
College was its own small revolution. I worked in a tea shop. I tutored kids and sold books from a stall in the campus square. I scrimped and saved while Zachary called me "my partner in crime" when he stole me hour-long coffee breaks between classes.
"Are you okay with your student loans?" he asked once, and there was something urgent under the casual question.
"I'll be fine," I said. "I've been fine before."
"You should tell me when you're not," he said. "I'm not letting you do this alone."
When the money in my bank went missing the summer before my senior year—money my father had promised would be there—Zachary insisted on finding me extra shifts, on bringing me coffee at midnight and on refusing my refusals.
"You're my chosen family," he said. "You don't have to do struggle quietly."
"You're being dramatic," I told him, but I kept his hand one night in the library stacks like a secret lifeline.
We loved in careful ways. "I think I love you," he whispered once outside my dorm window, the moon making his eyes pale.
"You've said that twice," I said.
"Third time's the charm," he grinned.
"Are you sure?" I asked.
"Yes," he said without the theater. "Gem, you're my person."
I believed him.
We married later, quiet and a little messy, because neither of us wanted a show. Our guests were friends, the old neighbors Annika and Hilda, and my classmate Clara Dyer who cried during the vows.
"You're glowing," Clara said, shoving cake into my hand without ceremony. "It's ridiculous."
"Good ridiculous," I said.
My parents came. Or rather Faron Dunn and Valentina Coleman came, two names on a wedding guest list that felt at once like formalities and like nails. They arrived late, as they always did, carrying a canvas and a camera bag. My mother had a smear of paint at her temple like a crown.
"Sorry about the delay," Valentina said, looking around with a bright face as if everything had been an adventure. "Roads were lovely for painting."
Faron laughed. "You can't paint a passing moment and rush."
There was a coldness in my chest that evening. I smiled as I should, took photos, and let Annika hold my hand. At the end of the night there was a small scene—whispers among the guests, an empty apology, nothing more. They left like two comets who had briefly zoned through my orbit.
Time moves on, and so do people.
Years later, when our son Nol was small and the house full of laughter and dog hair, my mother called out of the blue.
"Gemma," she said. "You should come see my opening. It's about memory and color."
I had to force calm. "We're busy," I said. "School's in session and Nol is napping."
"Just for an hour," she urged. "I want you to see."
I told Zachary about it. "You want to go?" he asked.
"Part of me wants to see what she paints when she thinks of me," I said. "Part of me wants to see if she'll notice he exists."
"Let's go," he said after a beat. "Together."
The gallery was a white box; her paintings were riotous, each canvas like a festival of color. Critics spoke in precise words by the champagne. People wore clothes like armor. Valentina's face was pale and focused like someone who'd caught a light. There was a crowd—students, collectors, community people—eyes bright.
I stood in the doorway, and she looked up. For a moment her face rearranged.
"Gemma," she said. "Oh, you made it."
I stepped forward. "You did well," I said.
She smiled as if the compliment landed like a feather.
"There's a piece I painted years ago," she said suddenly, "that I couldn't finish. Maybe you'll like it. It's about a girl with a lamp."
"I'll look," I said.
As we moved deeper, I saw Faron leaning near a wall, showing a photograph he had taken of a sunset to an investor. He looked like someone who had years of devotion behind glass—handsome, charming, oblivious.
A young journalist approached my parents. "Ms. Coleman, your show tonight is being called a love letter—" she began.
Valentina, pleased, began to speak.
"I owe a great deal to the early days," she said, "to inspiration and to someone who made me risk and paint. Art is a living thing."
Faron nodded. "Travel shapes work. Our lives are fuller for it."
They were praised for romantic wanderings. People clung to the line that art justified everything. Voices rose, applause followed.
"Isn't it beautiful?" someone near me said. "They always had the romance people dream of."
I felt the floor tilt. "They never missed my birth for a gallery show," I heard myself say aloud.
A man with a microphone wanted to bring my mother up on stage. "Ms. Coleman, would you say a few words on how your family life affects your art?" he asked.
My mother smiled and accepted. She walked to the small riser, hands steady, paint dry on the cuff of her sleeve. Cameras turned like beetles. People angled to see.
Annika squeezed my arm. "You can leave," she said quietly.
"No," I answered. "I need to say something."
Zachary's hand closed over mine like a vice. "Are you sure?"
"I'm sure," I said. "It's time."
I stepped forward. Lights hit my face and the crowd quieted.
"Hello everyone," I said. The microphone felt dull and alien, foreign as the world that had abandoned me as a child. "My name is Gemma Bowen. I'm the daughter of Valentina Coleman and Faron Dunn."
There was a small collective intake of breath.
"Thank you for your beautiful work," I continued. "Your paintings are brave and loud—"
"She's beautiful," someone murmured, the tone shocked but approving.
"But I am here to speak for a different kind of truth."
A ripple of curiosity moved through the room. The journalist who had interviewed my mother leaned forward, mouth open. "This is unexpected," she whispered to her notebook.
"My parents left me when I was an infant," I said, and the air seemed to hold. "They left a note saying they couldn't continue. They left me to others to raise."
Gasps circulated. Faron's smile twitched.
"Annika Burke raised me. She was a teacher and then more—a constant human who folded me into the warmth that I did not get at home," I said. "Hilda Renard cared for me when no one else would. Zachary brought me to the hospital when I broke my ankle and he never left my side for nights when I couldn't lift myself."
People were murmuring, shifting.
"I stood in your photographs," I said to them, turning to the small crowd as if the sin of invisibility could be made visible. "I was a face in a corner. When I was sick, you painted sunsets instead of me. When I had a fever, you sold canvases instead of staying home. You told stories of 'living the art life' like it was a virtue that absolved you of everything."
The journalist scribbled. "She seems angry," someone said.
"I'm not here to accuse every artist who's ever traveled," I continued. "I'm here because tonight you praise sacrifice while forgetting the people actually given up in its name. Tonight, people clink their glasses to the romantic myth. They don't ask who holds the house together while you chase the next light."
Valentina's lips parted. "Gemma—"
"Don't," I said. "Listen."
My father's hand went white on his champagne glass. "This is a private family matter," he whispered, turning toward me with a small, practiced disdain.
I laughed, a sharp little sound. "Private? A private matter that becomes public when you stand on a platform bragging about 'inspiration' while omitting the child you left behind?"
"That's enough," Faron said loudly. He tried the strategy that had always worked before: minimize, shame, then charm.
"People," I said, "you pay to hear about art because you think it ennobles the maker. But what's noble about leaving a child to be raised by neighbors and teachers? What is nobility in a paint smear when a child learns to hide her pain behind a classroom desk?"
Someone in the back stood up. "Is this true?" the woman asked. "She was left?"
"Yes," Annika said plainly, stepping forward with the quiet force of one who had stood bedside and made soup. "I signed hospital forms. I baked her first birthday cake when no one else came."
"No," Valentina whispered. She sounded small and confused, as if a piece of her world had cracked.
"Aren't you proud, then?" Faron tried another angle. "You have a daughter who is a teacher, married, with a child. She turned out—well."
"She turned out because others loved her," I said. "Not because you did. You turned out lives that allowed you to travel. You called it 'living.' You called absence 'a way to work.'"
A silence settled like dust. People looked at Faron and at Valentina with new eyes. The critic who two minutes before called their work "raw and confessional" now twisted the label in his mouth.
"You're speaking ill of two generous artists," someone said, almost as if speaking ill of them would be impolite.
"I am speaking of my life," I said. "I am speaking for the child who wiped away her own tears so they wouldn't bother anyone. I am speaking so that when the critics call your art a 'life of devotion,' they also name the people sacrificed for it."
Faron's face changed slowly—first to something like surprise, then to anger. "You dramatize everything," he said. "We did what we had to do."
"You left," I said. "You said sorry in a note. You said you needed to find yourselves. Self-finding should not have required my erasure."
"That's a lie," Valentina said. "We have been nothing but—"
"Hypocritical," I cut in. "You made an image. The image sold. People clapped. Where was your clapping when I had a fever?"
A woman near us whispered to her companion, "She speaks well. She's very composed."
I could feel the room turning like a tide. People started asking questions out loud. Was it true they left the child? Who raised her? Why did the child go by another name?
"How does it feel?" the journalist with the microphone asked. "To discover your own story in the mouths of strangers?"
"Humiliating," I said. "But better than being invisible."
Then the crowd did something that matters in the way collective judgment does. They shifted. The flattering guesses became suspicious stares. A collector set down his champagne. A student stopped taking a selfie. Someone in the front row stood up, walked to the table where Faron had been talking and took his portfolio, flipping a page to a photograph of me as a child under a violet sky.
"That's her," the student said. "You photographed her."
"Yes," Faron said, voice thin.
"Where were you that night when she was in the hospital?" the student asked.
Silence dragged like river silt.
Faron stumbled. "I—" he began, then lapsed into "I was traveling."
Another woman, a neighbor who recognized my name, stood. "My daughter watched her while the parents were away," she said. "Your 'inspiration' came from leaving your child for months at a time."
The crowd began to murmur. A man next to me whispered, "This feels like a public reckoning."
Valentina's face drained of color. "You are making a scene," she said. "People came to celebrate art, not private grievances."
"Then don't write the private parts out of the story," I answered. "Don't paint the romantic and forget the human cost."
She tried to speak, then began to cry. It was a small, sudden sound that broke the polished surface.
"Oh my," Faron said, flailing for composure. "People, please."
The public shifted to disapproval. Phones lifted not to praise but to capture. The journalist who'd been so eager for quotes now scrawled notes with a new intensity. "Will you make a statement about your family's role?" she asked Valentina.
Valentina's denial collapsed under the weight of witnesses. She stepped back, eyes glassy. "We were young," she murmured. "We didn't know how to be different."
"That isn't an excuse," Annika said from the side, her voice small but steady. "But it's a reason. People who have power must be honest about its cost."
"You're asking for an apology," Faron said, but his voice had none of its earlier ease. "From us? In public?"
"Yes," I said. "In public."
It felt like a final test, one I set for them not because I wanted spectacle but because a private apology would always sit like a bed sheet folded away. Public words asked for accountability and witnesses. If they could say they were sorry when cameras were on them, perhaps those words would mean something more than a note left on a table.
Valentina raised her face. "I'm sorry," she said, and the sentence trembled.
Faron looked like someone caught in nets. He swallowed hard, then said, "I'm sorry too."
A few in the crowd clapped, a careful polite clapping. Others hissed softly or shook their heads. Some people started whispering about art critics and ethics. The journalist smiled the smile of someone who had just witnessed a story materialize.
Valentina's knees gave. She sat on a small crate behind the table, and the kind of collapse I had feared happened: she lowered her head and sobbed.
Faron's transition moved next to something raw. At first he was angry and dismissive; then his face lost its armor; then his body went slack as if all his practiced lines had been stripped away. He tried to regain control. "We tried," he said. "You don't understand the things artists have to do."
"Don't make your work into a shield," I said. "Your art doesn't get to use people."
The crowd watched as those two people—my parents—went from being envied to being pitied. There were phones taking pictures, a woman whispering "How could they?"; a man muttering, "I always wondered about their detachment."
Faron moved closer, then farther—a pendulum between denial and brokenness. He put his hands over his face and then folded them into his lap. "I didn't know what I was doing right," he confessed to no one in particular.
Valentina looked up at me with an expression I could not name—regret or perhaps astonishment that my anger had found an audience. "Gem," she said, voice small.
"You didn't raise me," I said. "But you can try to be accountable now."
Still the gallery hummed. Some people began to speak in a softer register, as if the air itself demanded gentleness.
A woman from the press stepped forward. "So what would you like from them?" she asked me, pressing the microphone toward my face.
"To be honest," I said. "To recognize public praise as not a substitute for caring. To promise that they will use their platform to support those who pick up the child-care slack that allowed them to be 'artists.' And most of all, to stop making absence into an aesthetic."
Faron's shoulders shook. "I will do whatever is needed," he said, like a man making a promise to repair a table he had broken.
"Start by acknowledging what you did in a place where people can see it," I told him. "Start by apologizing without saying 'but' a hundred times. Start by listening."
He did that then in pieces: first a raw apology, then a shaky admission that he had used money and time in ways that made him forget, then the fragile promise to meet with Annika and me, to discuss restitution. People nodded at the words. Who knows how durable they will be? Apologies in light of cameras are brittle sometimes, and sometimes they weather. The point was the public witnessing.
Around us, the crowd's energy shifted into something like consequence. They photographed my parents in the sudden light they had created for themselves. Their faces were recorded, analyzed, commented on. "They were charming," someone said, "but they were also absent." The new narrative hung in the white air.
Afterward, outside the gallery with the cold air washing the champagne breath away, Valentina came to me and took my hands like a child asking permission.
"Gemma," she said, "I—"
"Don't call me Gemma if you mean the past," I said softly. "Call me Gem."
She flinched. "I understand," she whispered.
"I don't want money," I told her. "I want acknowledgment. And I want you to be honest when you talk about sacrifice."
She nodded. "I will try."
Zachary stood beside me, his presence steady. "You did it," he said, proud a little, proud in a way that didn't need to diminish anyone.
"I did it for the little girl who needed someone at her bedside," I answered. "For the child who couldn't ask."
We walked home under a sky that did not pretend to forgive. The night felt heavy with things finally said.
In the weeks that followed, the gallery's reviews kept quoting my words. Colleagues came up to me and asked things like, "How did it feel to speak?" Annika called and laughed softly. "You were fierce," she said. "You were right."
My parents made small attempts. They sent emails with proper subject headings and carboned apologies. There were meetings arranged where they listened and were asked concrete things: to fund educational scholarships for students like me; to donate to child care centers; to volunteer on weekends. Faron and Valentina, forced by the public to square gestures with deeds, signed papers and visited a community center. It was awkward and messy and human.
Public humiliation had forced a change that private sorrow hadn't obtained. People watched and expected them to be better. That was the point I wanted to make—accountability is social. It is not vengeance; it is the chance to have your actions measured where they can be seen.
Inside me, old wounds did not heal overnight. The record of my childhood sat like a ledger. But there was a difference now. The world could not so easily ignore what had happened to me. There were witnesses who had seen my parents' smiles and then seen their eyes change. That mattered.
"Do you regret bringing it up?" a friend asked later over tea.
"No," I said. "I regret the times I thought silence was protection. Silence protected them more than it protected me. Speaking was the only way to make private absence public and to make it actionable."
Zachary squeezed my hand. "You didn't need to forgive to be kind," he said.
"No," I answered. "But I needed to be honest."
And so we kept living. We raised Nol in a house full of noise and rules and stories. We taught him that art is beautiful but not above human responsibility. We told him that sometimes you have to speak even when it is hard because it helps other people understand what to do differently.
Sometimes, at night, I would look at the paint smudge on one of Valentina's canvases—sold later with a certificate that said "Inspired by family life"—and I would think of small rooms and hospital smells and the way Annika had hummed me to sleep. I kept the memory not as a weapon but as a map.
Maybe one day my parents will truly understand what they missed. Maybe they won't. But the gallery had given me something it never intended to: a place where truth could be seen and where absence could be named.
"Do you think it made a difference?" I asked Zachary once, fingers laced to his.
"It did," he said. "It showed them a mirror they kept avoiding."
"That's all I ever wanted," I said.
We went on, living brightly. People still praised Valentina's colors. They still praised Faron's compositions. But now, when reviewers wrote about them, they sometimes added a line about the daughter who finally had a voice. The smallest justice of all is to be seen.
The End
— Thank you for reading —